Listen

Description

The much-anticipated Santa Claus Rally window came and went last week with only more volatility and a lot of lower prices to show for it. With hardly any discernable meaningful catalysts and a lot of end of year tax-loss selling going on, there simply wasn’t much to stop stocks from rolling over early in the week. Wednesday (good) and Thursday (bad) basically cancelled each other out. Friday was a moderately decent low-volume snooze-fest.

As we begin the transition that I highlighted last week (investors shifting to taking note of what data actually shows about inflation and the economy, as opposed to exclusively caring only about how the Fed might react) we are frequently experiencing conflicts when it comes to an assessment of what we are actually looking at.

For example, the Fed’s most beloved set of indicators, the Core Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) last week showed its particular version of inflation (ex- food and energy prices) as moving 0.2% higher from October to November and up by 4.7% from a year ago. This showed inflation decelerating more than expected. Good news, right?

Well, yes, but it also showed that over the same period, Americans’ spending slowed substantially, up just 0.1% - a stat that just weeks ago would have fit the “bad news is good news” narrative and taken as evidence that the Fed could react to that by easing up on interest rate hikes. Nowadays it is being seen for what it really is; evidence that the pace of consumer spending is falling and could soon be in a tailspin. Newsflash: that isn’t good for stocks.

The report also showed that earnings for the average American were up 0.4% month over month, exceeding the rate of inflation, muddling the message even further.  

I’m not trying to imply that Fed rhetoric or policy doesn’t matter, it absolutely still does. But as we enter 2023, it’s no longer going to be the single most important factor for this simple reason: The Fed will have to react to the data just like it did in 2022. And if inflation and growth both fall fast enough, then the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) will definitely stop tightening, whatever they may say in speeches and press conferences.

But inflation data has to fall faster than economic data, otherwise we’re looking at stagflation and a potential huge Fed policy mistake. Thursday and Friday’s data implied that the opposite is happening right now; growth estimates are falling faster than inflation. And the bond market is screaming the imminent arrival of a recession by means of the persistently inverted yield curve (see EXPLAINER: FINANCIAL TERM OF THE WEEK below).

The good news (for the Fed, at least) is that interest rate hikes are totally wrecking the real estate market - as emphasized by the continued, worse-than-expected decline in housing metrics released last week, including sales of existing homes slumping 7.7% from October to November, the tenth consecutive month of declines and now down more than 35% from this time last year.

The median sales price of a house in the US fell more than 10% from June to November to $370,700. Building permit applications for privately-owned housing units crashed 11.2% over the course of the last month and are now over 22% below the level of a year ago.

All this shows just how much the vastly increased cost of borrowing has utterly destroyed demand and sentiment among both homebuyers and homebuilders. But the Fed wants to see this interest rate-related demand destruction move beyond just housing. At some point it likely will, and that's why the worries about an upcoming recession are so widespread and continue to cast a shadow over stock prices. 

This has been a year in which all the world's major central banks engineered a serious pivot toward higher interest rates and tighter money. Almost all, that is. Until last Tuesday, the Bank of Japan (BOJ) stood out as the exception to the rule.

In a surprise move and a sign that the war on inflation is now truly a worldwide affair, it “loosened its yield curve control" which is a central bank-y way of saying it will allow market interest rates to drift higher before it intervenes to cap out any rise. That tolerance cap for the ten year bond went up from 0.25% to 0.50%.

It may not look like like much, but it’s a pretty epic policy shift from the BOJ, which has been supporting easy money for many, many years. And despite recent calls from Japanese government officials to raise rates, it has refused to budge until now.

This move raises the value of the yen at the expense of the US dollar. Corporate America has been crying out for a fall in the value of the US currency, which has soared since early 2021, to help with exports - so the effect of the BOJ’s actions could even be a net positive for US stocks.

Last week I identified the two key questions that will dominate the assessment of stock market direction in early 2023 as being:

1) How fast will inflation decline?

2) How bad will the economy get?

This week I want to show more precisely what we need to see (and when) to answer those questions properly.

* The Core Consumer Price Index (CPI) measure of retail inflation (most recently up 0.2% month-on-month, 6.0% year-on-year) is the important one as it will tell us more clearly when services inflation is declining (as opposed to just goods and commodities) and it’s that decline that ultimately leads to a Fed policy pivot to re-start the process of actually lowering interest rates.

ThePositive Answer: < 5.0% year-on-year before April. The Negative Answer: > 5.0% after April.

* Markets need to see a serious deterioration in the labor market. If the unemployment rate can rise and stay above 4% early in 2023 (currently it’s 3.7% and has remained stubbornly there or thereabouts for a good while), then that will be a clear sign that Fed rate hikes are restoring economic balance.

The Positive Answer: > 4.0% before March. The Negative Answer: < 4.0% after March.

The good news is that if both these questions are answered positively, then the bottom in stocks could well be in by the end of next quarter. On the other hand, if they’re answered negatively, then more new lows aren’t just likely, they’re almost certain.

This is my final report of 2022 .. I have often expressed the futility of looking forward using forecasts, but I am a big fan of the learning opportunities derived from looking back, so I will shortly be sending my Q4 review.

This has not been an easy year in the markets, to put it mildly. The fact that stocks now seem to be defying the traditional Santa Claus Rally is a sign that those difficulties could well continue into next year.

I do want to emphasize, however, that every single time we have had to endure a period like this in the markets, it has ultimately yielded generational buying opportunities to help longer term investors secure their financial futures and I’m very confident that this is the case this time as well.

Hopefully in 2023 and beyond, this weekly report will be a part of helping guide clients and subscribers towards that security.

OTHER NEWS

Payback is a b***h .. America’s most despicable and worst behaved bank, Wells Fargo, agreed to pay a colossal fine to settle allegations that it defrauded its customers in its fake account scandal that dates back as far as when Justin Bieber was advising you to love yourself in 2016. The settlement includes a $1.7 billion penalty, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB)’s largest-ever fine, and more than $2 billion in consumer restitution.

The bank is still facing further scrutiny and possible further penalties and sanctions from multiple other regulators more than six years after its astonishing illicit behavior came into public view. It deliberately assessed illegitimate fees and interest charges on loans for cars and homes so that many bank customers had their vehicles illegally repossessed while others had overdraft and other penalty fees unlawfully applied.

In any other sector, such behavior would result …



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit simonbrady.substack.com