The final full week of September is historically on average the worst-performing week of the year for U.S. stocks. This time round, a very limited amount of consequential economic data ahead of the latest inflation reading on Friday and only a handful of earnings reports left the market feeling untethered and drifting, at the mercy of some notoriously unpredictable moving targets such as trader sentiment, global geopolitics, an erratic U.S. election campaign that feels like it could go off the rails at any moment, a looming government shutdown and lots and lots of Fed-Speak, with at least eight central bank officials, including chairman Jerome Powell on Thursday, scheduled to make speeches or participate in conferences during the week.
The Chinese central bank made a surprising cut in one of its key interest rates over the weekend as part of a massive package of moves to give an adrenaline shot to a rapidly cooling economy. There was more appalling carnage in the Middle East.
U.S. stocks, however, began the week by floating gently higher in a rather humdrum session on Monday on the back of the still high market-driven probability of yet another half point interest rate cut in November resulting from some very pro-rate cut Fed-speak from rate-setting committee members, Austan Goolsbee and Raphael Bostic. The S&P 500 index notched its 40th all-time record high close of the year.
It was more of the same on Tuesday. Tech stocks led markets higher, partly on the back of all the Chinese stimulus news, to all-time record high #41 of 2024 for the S&P 500. This was despite some evidence of declining consumer confidence and Fed-Speak from Governor Michelle Bowman, the only policymaker to dissent on the recent 0.50% cut, who said that the central bank should lower interest rates “at a measured pace” . Sounds like Michelle is still unconvinced by this whole jumbo half point cut malarkey.
Some air was let out of the balloon on Wednesday as the dearth of any significant data or earnings-based catalysts continued and investors maybe got a little bout of vertigo at the elevated stock price levels achieved over the last few weeks and decided to back off a bit for a while. In the background, the growing prospect of an Israeli ground invasion in Lebanon started raising serious geopolitical concerns. The indexes all finished lower, erasing most of Monday and Tuesday’s record-breaking gains.
Stock prices were strongly buoyed on Thursday morning by a very healthy Q2 Gross Domestic Product (GDP) final estimate of 3.0% annualized, robust sales forecasts from Micron (the stock surged 20% in a matter of minutes), a better-than-expected pre-market weekly jobless claims number, a further super-charging of the Chinese stimulus package and the emergence of a possible Israel/Lebanon 21-day ceasefire proposal.
Although markets gave some back later in the session as Netanyahu appeared to torpedo ceasefire hopes, the plethora of good news prevailed and Jerome Powell offered an optimistic picture of the economy in a major speech. It was another up-day across the board for stocks and yet again an all-time record closing high for the S&P 500.
The most impactful piece of data of the week hit the newswires before the opening bell on Friday. The latest Personal Consumption Expenditure (PCE) Price Index, which the Fed uses to judge where it believes inflation to really be, came in as expected at 2.2% annualized, still very close to the central bank’s 2.0% target number and clearing the path for more large and/or frequent interest rate cuts by keeping the Goldilocks narrative intact.
After initially reacting very positively in response to this data, stocks settled back into a holding pattern and ended basically unchanged for the session but largely higher for the week.
We cannot get into the minds of Fed interest rate-setting committee members to know what they are thinking, but if I had to guess I’d say it’s something like .. “If inflation was caused by the pandemic, stimulus spending and now-resolved supply chain issues and all those are now gone and inflation is pretty much back at 2%, then why do we need to have interest rates so high?”
To use a simple analogy, it’s like we were in a car hurtling down a steep hill. The Fed had to ride the brakes to stop inflation and make sure the car didn’t get out of control. But now the economy is back on a flat road and the Fed still has a foot on the brakes. If they don’t let off, the car will eventually stop (= a recession).
This is where the market’s strong conviction in more jumbo half point interest rate cuts before the end of the year and into 2025 comes from (see FEDWATCH INTEREST RATE TOOL below), despite the Fed itself only projecting a total of a half point cut across the remaining couple of meetings of 2024.
Either financial markets will be disappointed or the Fed will be bullied by Wall Street into cutting rates more than it would instinctively like. We’ll find out soon enough and one big clue will be this week’s Jobs Report.
OTHER NEWS ..
Higher And Higher .. As of Friday and measured by the S&P 500 index, the U.S. stock market had moved higher in 36 weeks of the last 52, which puts it in the best 5% ever of one year periods since 1957 by this count. On average, the S&P 500 tends to go up in 30 weeks per year.
The takeaway: as long as the economy is growing, the U.S. is adding jobs, corporate earnings are powering higher, and inflation isn’t a five-alarm fire, stocks have the capability to shake off any number of seemingly unsettling headlines and continue to march higher.
Not So Simple .. Conventional wisdom says that Wall Street likes split government (no one party controlling all of the House, Senate and presidency) since the resulting potential for gridlock maintains the status quo and reduces the seismic shifts and uncertainty that Wall Street detests.
However it’s not quite that simple. A split government does indeed mean that large scale policy changes (such as widespread tariffs, significant welfare or immigration reform, etc.) become less likely, but it also increases ongoing government shutdown risk and possibility that the Trump tax cuts will all completely expire at the end of next year. This will have basically the same effect as the shock of a sudden massive tax hike and could be damaging to businesses and markets.
On the other hand, a sweep certainly increases the possibility of performative, ill-considered and damaging colossal policy changes but - depending who it is that sweeps - could allow an extension or at least more thought-out and controlled amendments to some of the expiring tax cuts, thereby avoiding the de facto tax shock that frightens financial markets.
Massive Fashion Emergency .. Seems AI can’t get everything right. Wednesday was a mediocre day for the market in general, but it was a truly atrocious session for one-time highflier Stitch Fix. The stock plunged almost 40% in minutes and its market value fell to just $277 million, having peaked at $10 billion in early 2021 - a fall of over 97%. The company went public in 2017, promising to make customers look snappy in clothing selected for them by an AI-assisted algorithm.
ARTICLE OF THE WEEK ..
The most common outcome from buying a stock is that you lose all your money. Also stocks broadly have very positive, long-term expected returns.
Huh? How can those two things both be true? Here’s how.
THIS WEEK’S UPCOMING CALENDAR ..
The September jobs data provides this week's highlights. The Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS) comes out on Tuesday. It's expected to show a roughly unchanged number of unfilled positions at the end of August.
But the week's main event will be the Jobs Report on Friday. The consensus estimate is for an increase of 145k payrolls in September, slightly more than in August. The unemployment rate is expected to hold steady at 4.2%. Americans' average hourly earnings are forecast to be up 3.8% from a year earlier.
LAST WEEK BY THE NUMB…