In a horror movie, it often happens that the poor young person being chased in the house gets right to the front door and is just about to escape onto the street when the killer suddenly jumps out and grabs them. As an audience, we are teased with the prospect of good news when, suddenly, that hope is snatched away. That’s pretty much what happened in the stock market last week, specifically with the critical aftermath of the Federal Reserve Open Market Committee meeting on Wednesday.
The market bled steadily lower early in the week amid mostly quiet news flow. On Tuesday, the Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS) for September showed openings of 10.7 million which was was a surprising increase from August, defying economists’ forecast for a decline. For stocks, the jolt was to the downside. Investors are currently looking for any excuse the Fed could use to pause its rate hikes. A slowing economy would be Reason Number One. But more job openings suggests the opposite - it suggests a still-strong economy that could force employers to offer higher wages to fill opened jobs. That's a recipe for more inflation, not less.
Markets continued to heavily punish the companies that fail to match earnings expectations. You can see from the market heat-map below in LAST WEEK BY THE NUMBERS who the most beaten-up victims were.
But spirits initially lifted on Wednesday when the Fed dangled some teasing “pivot-y” language with its statement announcing a 0.75% rate hike, saying that a slowdown decision could come soon and that further moves will take into account “cumulative tightening”, policy lags and additional upcoming economic data.
The stock market lapped this language up, taking it to imply a more measured response going forward, in recognition of the fact that there has been a lot of cumulative raises in interest rates already and that the lag-time involved meant that those hikes previously made could have baked in some future benefits, reducing the Fed’s need to add to them quite so enthusiastically.
Markets thought they got what they wanted from the Fed’s penultimate meeting of the year, before it was cruelly snatched away.
In the subsequent press conference, Fed chair Jerome Powell emphasized that the central bank has “a ways to go” in tightening policy enough to bring inflation down to its 2% target, and for that reason, he declared it premature to talk about pausing rate increases. “We have some ground to cover with interest rates,” he said, adding that “there’s no sense that inflation is coming down.”
He would not be drawn, despite the best efforts of the financial news hacks at the presser, on predicting the all-important Terminal Rate (the rate of the Fed Funds rate on the day that the Fed announces an end to the rate hike cycle).
He did say “I would want people to understand our commitment to getting this done, and to not making the mistake of not doing enough or the mistake of withdrawing our strong policy and doing that too soon,” . Scary stuff and kryptonite to stock prices.
Simply put, the message Powell sent out was that the size of future rate hikes will have no effect on when the Fed stops raising them and that these two are not particularly inter-dependent. Seeing a slowing in the extent of the rate hikes (0.50% or even 0.25% instead of 0.75%) does not necessarily indicate that the Terminal Rate (which is a far more important consideration) will be lower as a result. This distinction has now been made very clear. It sent stocks tumbling when it sunk in. The killer had just jumped onto the screen, brandishing a pretty large knife.
As investors absorbed what they had just heard, selling picked up rapidly throughout the rest of the afternoon during and after Powell’s words. The NASDAQ index, the epicenter of market valuation worries and brimming with companies that are most heavily impacted by higher interest rates, dropped over 3%. By the end of the day, the market had experienced its worst intra-day reaction to a Fed meeting since Elton John asked us all if we could feel the love tonight in 1994.
The mostly spectacular performance of equities in October suggested that the market really expected to thrown a bone by the Fed on Wednesday but was strongly disappointed. Friday’s recovery, driven by a mostly neutral jobs report which showed the unemployment rate climbing from 3.5% to 3.7%, helped to cut into the losses somewhat, but a good number of stocks (mostly in the Technology and Communication Services sector) had a rather dire week.
OTHER NEWS
And then there was one .. Remember back in the day when we all thought that an exclusive group of about six mega-tech names was driving the whole market higher? Well membership of that club is now down to just one. Even after a really bad week for the stock, Apple (AAPL) is still bigger (as measured by market capitalization) than ex-group members Meta/Facebook (META), Alphabet/Google (GOOGL) and Amazon (AMZN) combined!
Shilling for crypto .. Disgraced ex-UK prime minister Boris Johnson will address a cryptocurrency conference in Singapore next month as he forges a speaking career. Having failed to secure a second stint in the job, BoJo will be the featured keynote speaker at the International Symposium on Blockchain Advancements on December 2nd. He remains the Member of Parliament for his constituency but will skip attending Parliament in order to speak at the event. It is currently unknown how much he will be paid for his address, but he recently skipped his Parliamentary responsibilities to fly to the US to make a 30-minute speech to the Council of Insurance Agents and Brokers in Colorado for which he was paid $150k, which is close to double the annual salary of a UK Member of Parliament.
Crypto evangelists are getting more and more desperate to try and restore some kind of credibility after a long “crypto winter” (see EXPLAINER: FINANCIAL TERM OF THE WEEK below) during which prices have crashed and multiple criminal crypto frauds have been exposed, resulting in institutional and individual investors losing billions of dollars. Johnson is not the only former high-level politician speaking at the event in Singapore. He will be joined by Dick Cheney, the US vice-president from 2001 to 2009.
UNDER THE HOOD:
Despite the difficulties experienced recently by some big name stocks, broad market elements that often occur at major market bottoms, such as panic selling swiftly followed by panic buying on volume spikes, are still AWOL. In particular, volume showed no sign of spiking at or near the lows and is not increasing as it kind of needs to whenever Demand comes rushing back in.
Although some markets find their bottoms when everyone loses interest, the majority form when urgent selling pushes prices lower to the point where sellers are exhausted and buyers finally believe stocks are attractive. It is simply difficult to find evidence of this process yet.
Of the giant stocks that led the multi-year bull market into the January 2022 peak, Microsoft (MSFT), Amazon (AMZN), Tesla (TSLA), and Alphabet/Google (GOOGL) are all at or near one year lows, but a worryingly high percentage of small-cap stocks are also in the same kind of territory. With both the “generals” and the “soldiers” showing weakness and the S&P 500 now simply back to where it was in June, it is difficult to see how a bottom formation is underway.
Anglia Advisors clients are welcome to reach out to me to discuss market conditions further.
THIS WEEK’S UPCOMING CALENDAR ..
This week will be another busy one for investors: the U.S. midterm elections, the latest inflation data, and a continued parade of Q3 earnings reports from the likes of Disney, Dupont, Occidental Petroleum, Activision, Take-Two Interactive, NRG, Ralph Lauren, Mosaic, Tapestry and DR Horton.
Voting in the mid-terms on Tuesday will determine control of Congress for the next two years, with Republicans favored to win the House of Representatives and polling suggesting they may also wi…