Fears of an imminent destructive recession and hopes of any interest rate cuts in 2023 are evaporating in equal measure, with each narrative pulling markets in opposite directions.
We learned last week that the Fed was apparently a lot less united at its recent interest rate-setting June meeting than the announced unanimous decision suggested. According to the minutes of that gathering released on Wednesday, some officials favored another quarter-point increase right then and there, but eventually went along somewhat reluctantly with a decision to pause the hikes.
Nearly all members of the rate-setting committee appeared to agree that additional rate increases would likely be needed this year, as the majority still believe there will be recession, albeit a mild one, at some point in the next year or so. The key takeaway? More interest rate hikes are coming, likely starting with the next meeting in a couple of weeks time. More on this later.
Stock markets are pricing in a continued drop in inflation and are not pricing in a meaningful slowdown in growth. Therefore, it logically follows that “stagflation” (stubbornly high inflation in a contracting economy) is the biggest kryptonite for stock prices since it would undermine all the “glass is half full” reasons for the recent rally.
So going into Friday’s Jobs Report, the greatest fear was that it could be stagflationary in nature. What would such a nightmare report look like? ..
* very low job adds (an increase of 100k or below) - implying hiring is slowing,
* the lack of a material increase in the unemployment rate (staying in the mid 3% area or lower) - which would keep the Fed hawkish and likely to continue raising rates higher for longer,
* an increase in wage growth (5% or above) - which would imply a possible bounce back in inflation.
We got a hint on Thursday morning from the ADP private sector-only jobs report which showed more than double the expected level of job creation in June. We also learned from the Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS) that job cuts by US employers have now fallen to an eight-month low and the quits rate rose by the most in nine months, indicating workers still feel confident in their ability to secure another job and that reports of the end of the Great Resignation were highly exaggerated.
In a perfect example of the lack of room there is for any kind of disappointment that I mentioned in last week’s report, Thursday’s “pre-game” employment data sent stocks plunging and market interest rates surging on Thursday as the higher-for-longer interest rate storyline was strongly bolstered.
But when the real thing came out in the form of the Jobs Report on Friday morning before the market opened, it was reasonably Goldilocks with:
* 209k jobs added and a downward review of the previous month’s number,
* a slight fall to a 3.6% unemployment rate, and
* unchanged 4.4% wage growth.
However, the stock market went on to suffer further losses on Friday, albeit less dramatic than the day before.
It’s now pretty much case-closed for a definite quarter-point interest rate hike on July 26th after the next Fed meeting (93% probability - see FEDWATCH INTEREST RATE PREDICTION TOOL below) and the odds of an immediate follow-up second hike at the following meeting in September are now rising fast (up from nowhere to 24%).
We no longer have the cushion of low expectations provided by the very negative sentiment that we had at the beginning of the year. There now seems to be a broad assumption that stocks will move higher, a very different environment indeed.
Above 4,400 the S&P 500 has fully priced in a lot of good news (it closed on Friday at 4,399) and is also rather stretched from a valuation standpoint.
So, while the major indexes’ market momentum (see EXPLAINER: FINANCIAL TERM OF THE WEEK below) continues to be higher, it’s important to be aware that if economic data and the state of Q2 earnings which start coming out this week (see THIS WEEK’S UPCOMING CALENDAR below) do suddenly turn negative (keep an eye on this weekly report for any signs that this may be the case) then there’s very little support for this market between here and at least 10% lower.
OTHER NEWS ..
Zuckerberg And Musk Face Off .. Mark Zuckerberg’s Meta/Facebook brought forward the launch of Threads, its “Twitter-Killer” micro-blogging social media site which cross-functions within Instagram, with an impressive sign-up rate of 75 million users in the first 48 hours (and that’s with it not even being available in Europe yet) and a lot of advertiser interest. The timing is smart with Twitter users growing more and more dissatisfied with the chaos on the site and open to something new following Elon Musk’s constant meddling with the platform’s features and vetting policies and the huge spike in both technical problems and trashy and toxic content since his takeover.
As The Wall Street Journal put it; “If you’re wondering what it’s like to use the new Threads app, just close your eyes and picture Twitter but with a lot less Elon Musk — and that’s exactly the point.”
Cash Is King In NYC ..More Manhattan property buyers are paying cash than at any other time on record as mortgage rates soar. According to a report on Bloomberg, about two-thirds of all purchases in Q2 2023 were completed without financing, the largest share since the tracking of payment methods began in 2014.
In the luxury tier (the top 10% of the market) the median price for Manhattan deals that closed in the quarter was $6.7 million, up 4% from a year earlier. Across all price ranges, properties traded at a median price of $1.2 million, down 4% from a year ago.
New Yorkers Can’t Catch A Break ... New York City’s air quality dropped once again to unhealthy levels on Wednesday. Instead of Canadian wildfires, however, Fourth of July fireworks and summer pollution were the main culprits this time. Those who managed to escape the city were just as unlucky, as sharks decided to join the rich and famous in hitting the Hamptons for the extended holiday break. Bloomberg reported that five swimmers are suspected to have been bitten.
UNDER THE HOOD ..
The gap between the “Haves” and “Have Nots” is still very distinct in the US stock market. As in most societies, there are far more Have Nots than Haves but the Haves are doing very nicely, thank you very much.
Broad-based Demand, not selective strength, is what drives bull markets, especially at turning points in the cycle. To date, from their respective October lows, the S&P 500 Large Cap Index is up 23% the NYSE Composite Index (which covers all stocks trading on the New York Stock exchange regardless of company size) rose just over 16%, while the S&P 600 Small Cap Index has gained less than 13%.
Another reason for skepticism is that all these gains have also been accomplished on relatively low trading volume, indicating something of a lack of enthusiasm and urgency among buyers.
These cross-currents are very atypical of the dawn of a new bull market, but are very common in unhealthy advances that tend to flame out before becoming sustainable long term turnarounds and caution is still warranted unless or until sustained and powerful broad-based Demand emerges.
The rally from the October 2022 lows embodies technical characteristics inconsistent with a new bull market (as I keep saying over and over). Despite these facts, some may still ask whether it is possible that “this time things could be different?” Exceptions are always possible, but frankly, not probable. And technical analysis (indeed stock market strategy in general) is simply a business of probabilities.
Anglia Advisors clients are welcome to reach out to me to discuss market conditions further.
THIS WEEK’S UPCOMING CALENDAR ..
And they’re off!! .. Q2 earnings season begins this week including several large US banks set to report and then from there, we'll have weeks of corporate data to digest.
Citigroup, JPMorgan Chase, and Wells Fargo will be this week's big banking earni…