There are three main factors that have propelled the S&P 500 higher in 2024 .. i) solid economic data, ii) impending Federal Reserve interest rate cuts, and iii) AI enthusiasm. Last week provided challenges for all three of those narratives. With key earnings reports, central bank interest rate decisions taking place in Washington DC, London and Tokyo and a pivotal Jobs Report, it always looked like it was going to be a highly volatile week. From that perspective at least, it didn’t disappoint.
Stocks cautiously meandered around with no real purpose on Monday and ended up essentially unchanged, with traders acutely aware that potentially impactful economic data and crucial earnings reports were all on the docket for the following few days, rendering this session something of a lame duck.
The real business of the week began on Tuesday with the Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS) which came in unchanged and as expected showing 8.2m open job positions in the U.S., further evidence of no imminent recession. Paypal, Jet Blue and Pfizer released impressive earnings. Procter & Gamble, Starbucks and Merck, not so much. These were only appetizers, however. The main course was Microsoft after the closing bell.
Dragged down again by tech and AI, stocks dipped partly due to pre-earnings positioning, but also as a result of the increasing geopolitical temperature in both the Middle East and Venezuela and the potential effect that could have on oil prices and thereby the global economy.
Microsoft’s Q2 sales and earnings were fine, but its mostly AI-related capital expenditure was off the charts, up by 55% from a year earlier with a perceived lack of resulting direct revenue in return. When markets opened on Wednesday, Microsoft notably failed to participate in what was otherwise a substantial rebound in the beaten-down tech sector in advance of the Fed declaration at 2pm ET.
Before attention turned fully to Fed’s interest rate announcement, the first of the week’s three big global central bank resolutions was made by the Bank of Japan, which raised the local interest rate by 0.25% to its highest level since 2008.
As was universally anticipated, there was no change in interest rates from the Fed with only very limited tweaks to its accompanying policy statement, giving Wall Street little to work with. Chairman Powell successfully navigated a rather feisty press conference, playfully dropping plenty of breadcrumbs about a September cut without actually confirming it (“A reduction in the policy rate could be on the table as soon as the next meeting in September.").
As so often happens, the Fed gave an inch and markets took a mile and stocks extended their considerable session gains, powered by Nvidia which shattered the all-time record for a one-day increase in any company’s value, adding $330 billion in just six and a half hours.
Oh and by the way, Meta/Facebook announced earnings after the closing bell and it was smiles all around as estimates were surpassed and the stock screamed higher when markets opened the next day. The Bank of England completed the global central bank divergence full house, narrowly voting on Thursday to cut interest rates in the UK for the first time since early 2020.
Unexpectedly cool manufacturing data and a hot weekly jobless claims number triggered a lunchtime collapse in stock prices. There was also a growing sense that investors might be exiting stocks (particularly the highly-valued ones) as a profit-taking exercise and rushing into increasingly attractive bonds as Treasury yields fall sharply in response to expected Fed policy. All of Wednesday’s gains were quickly wiped out.
The tech earnings parade concluded after the close with releases from Apple, Amazon and Intel. In descending order of good news:
* Apple beat estimates on overall sales and profitability, but the company is clearly still having problems with iPhone sales in China and the fact that (shocker!) no-one seems to be buying any Vision Pro headsets at $3500 a pop.
* Amazon showed decent sales growth in Q2 but missed on revenue and profitability and gave rather gloomy income projections for the rest of the year.
* Intel’s report was a complete catastrophe. The company missed estimates on just about every imaginable metric, announced mass layoffs and spending cuts, admitted that it was late to the AI party, gave grim forward guidance and made the kryptonite decision to suspend its dividend (there’s nothing Wall Street hates more than this).
Asian markets crashed overnight in their worst session in years. Europe did little better. The pre-opening bell Jobs Report over here on Friday was all that stood between the U.S. markets and a similar fate. It utterly failed to do so. Payrolls rose 114k in July, way below the 175k estimate and the two previous months were also revised downwards. The unemployment rate rose from 4.1% to 4.3%, its highest level in nearly three years.
Treasury yields tumbled in breathtaking fashion, accelerating the stocks → bonds exodus referred to above. The sudden growth scare that I have been warning about for months may well have arrived. The Fed’s decision on Wednesday to delay cutting interest rates until mid-September was suddenly viewed as a grave policy mistake and there were loud shouts for a double rate cut in September, a full 0.50% rather than just 0.25%. There were even some calls for the Fed to make an unscheduled interim cut ahead of the meeting, something I must say is highly unlikely.
It was a brutal sea of red when the stock market opened, with much of Wall Street’s venom reserved for Intel which fell over 25% in the first two minutes of trading and Amazon which dropped 10%. There was absolutely nowhere to hide with Small Caps getting heavily whacked as well. All the major stock indexes, particularly the NASDAQ, closed the day and the week badly battered and bruised. For those keeping score, more than $2 trillion in value has been obliterated from the NASDAQ-100 index in the last three weeks alone.
With a September interest rate cut now assured (it’s just a question of how big it is), any bad economic news has now shifted in Wall Street’s eyes from being good news since it that could prompt a rate cut to just being straight-up bad news.
If you thought July was wild ride, strap in for August.
OTHER NEWS ..
Ignorant politicking .. At his press conference on Wednesday, Fed chairman Jerome Powell understandably bristled when he was faced with questions about the possibility that there could be a political element to any interest rate decision in advance of the November election. There is only one more rate policy announcement between now and then (September 18th), with the next one taking place two days after the event.
The frankly embarrassing ignorance and pathetic showboating instincts of politicians on both sides was on full display last week. Democrats moaning at the Fed: “if you don’t cut interest rates in advance of the election, it’s a political call!”. Republicans whining to the Fed: “if you do cut interest rates before the election, it’s a political call!”. This conversation is being exacerbated by increasing speculation, driven by Friday’s Jobs Report, that there could even be a double rate cut in September, 0.50% rather than just 0.25%.
The Fed’s job is to act in an informed and dispassionate manner and everyone else is welcome to react however they want. What would be an economically damaging move would be to NOT make any changes that are informed by the data regardless of any perceived political consequences one way or another. Aggrieved politicians just need to deal with it and STFU.
Americans Earn A Lot More Money Than They Think .. The Economic Innovation Group published an interesting report that compares U.S. workers with the rest of the world and showed that the lowest paid workers in the U.S., who live in Mississippi, still earn more than the average worker in Germany and Canada. Other low earnings st…