A week following three major US bank failures that then saw two other banks sail very close to the wind ended with stock markets higher, the S&P 500 was up 1.4% for the week and the NASDAQ closed 4.4% higher. Anyone who claims they can correctly predict this stuff is such a liar.
Monday was the largest trading volume day so far this year on US exchanges (a record that lasted until Friday, when it was surpassed) and saw a bloodbath for shares of many regional banks on the back of the failures of Silvergate, Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank amid fears of financial contagion (see EXPLAINER: FINANCIAL TERM OF THE WEEK below).
These types of institutions are more reliant on net interest income (the difference between what they borrow and lend for) than larger Wall Street institutions which have additional diversified revenue sources including investment banking, trading, and wealth management.
None fared worse than First Republic Bank (FRC), whose stock plunged almost 70% on Monday before rallying back later in the week after it got assurances of some protection from the regulators and financial propping-up from its Wall Street banking pals like JP Morgan and Wells Fargo. It then slumped again on Friday after the bank announced that its dividends were a thing of the past.
For the third week running, there were extraordinary shifts in the market’s perception of what the Fed will do at this week’s March 22nd meeting, the idea being that in such a jumpy environment the Fed could not risk jacking rates up very far, if at all.
Indeed, there was a feeling that this turmoil could be the Fed's "get out of jail free" card, meaning that the banking crisis gives it the perfect cover to scale back or even pause its rate hikes, maintaining credibility in doing so by citing uncertainty in the banking sector as the “legitimate” reason.
This idea that the fallout from the crisis might help do the Fed’s job for it pushed non-financial stocks considerably higher for much of Monday’s trading session as, once again, the stock market priced in imminent Fed pivots and pauses having just got burned by doing exactly this literally only a month ago.
Interest rates on 2 year and 10 year Treasury bonds, which should be boring but have been acting like crazy biotech stocks lately, slumped hard, driving bond prices higher. The 2 year fell from above 5.0% to 4.0% in just three trading sessions. The technical term for this is; a friggin’ massive move - not seen since The Bangles were first advising us all to walk like an Egyptian in 1987.
As you will have seen in last week’s report, the futures market-based probability of a half percent hike by the Fed this Wednesday ended the previous week at 68%. By Monday evening, that probability was priced at .. zero,where it remained all week.
The likelihood of no change at all in rates being announced this week, priced at zero for months now, ended last week at 38% (Goldman Sachs analysts even came right out and said it - they think the Fed will leave rates unchanged as a result of what is happening in the financial sector). The remaining 62% probability said that a quarter of a point rise was on the cards.
The market has now priced in large interest rate cuts by year-end, with the probability of rates being lower than the current 4.625% now at 99%, and a two-in-three chance that rates will be below 4.00% on New Year’s Eve. This turnaround is quite astonishing when you look at the comparisons of where these probabilities were just a week ago and a month ago (see FEDWATCH TOOL below).
Before the market open last Tuesday morning we learned that, in the twelve months through February, the overall Consumer Price Index (CPI) measure of retail inflation rose 6.0%, compared to 6.4% the previous month. The January to February monthly rise was 0.4%. The year-on-year Core CPI rate, which excludes more volatile food and energy costs, was 5.5%, down a touch from the prior month. These readings were all broadly in line with expectations and supported a narrative that, while inflation is still a problem and the 2.0% Fed target remains pretty far away, the overall trajectory is still disinflationary - even if it is not as steep as the Fed would like.
This was broadly confirmed by the Producer Price Index (PPI) measure of wholesale inflation experienced by manufacturers which came out the next day better than expected.
The market’s reaction to the CPI report dovetailed with the emerging lower or even no rate hike expectations as well as with an exhale when it came to assessing bank contagion risk and this all drove all stock prices nicely higher on Tuesday.
Fears that another shoe was dropping, however, emerged on Wednesday when shares of troubled Swiss bank Credit Suisse (CS) fell over 27% in pre-market trading amid reports that its Saudi sugar daddy had ruled out any further financial assistance. Now anyone even half-paying attention knows that Credit Suisse has been a dead bank walking for months now (it’s even been previously mentioned in this very publication).
Quite why everyone was acting so shocked on Wednesday that a crap $2 to $3 stock of an institution already shown to have been involved in facilitating international drug dealing, global espionage, malicious and deliberate data leaks of client information, government corruption in Africa, complicity with fraudulent billionaires and hedge funds and more, became even crappier is a bit of a mystery to me but regardless, the previous day’s stock market gains were swiftly vaporized.
The schizophrenic feel continued for the rest of the week. Thursday saw markets move solidly back higher again as Switzerland announced that it would essentially backstop Credit Suisse and the Zero/Small-Rate-Hike narrative re-emerged.
Friday was always going to be wild as it was one of the four“triple-witching days” that happen each year, when individual stock options, stock index options and stock index futures contracts all expire on the same day leading to significant position covering. Kerosene was thrown on the fire by something of a re-examination by investors of what had initially been thought to be the “good” First Republic and Credit Suisse news from the day before and another pretty substantial down day was the result.
All eyes now turn to Wednesday afternoon and the Fed’s interest rate decision and Jerome Powell’s associated press conference and, for the first time in a long time, it’s actually a little unclear which way they will go. I’m on Team Quarter-Of-A-Point-Rise right now, but we will have to get through the rest of this weekend plus two more days of banking sector news narratives before we learn the outcome.
It’ll be an interesting week. I suggest strapping in.
OTHER NEWS .. Banking Crisis Edition (kind of an Op-Ed, I’m afraid)
This is absolutely NOT 2008 .. There is far too much irritating, lazy media comparison between now and 2008 when it comes the events of the last week or two. While you expect this from clueless simpletons on FinTok and Instagram, I’ve also seen it on more respectable outlets that should know much better.
The biggest difference (of many!) between 2008 and now is that fifteen years ago, the assets held at the troubled banks (mortgages on homes) were hopelessly underwater. The home values were way below the value of the mortgages owned, which created massive losses and colossal solvency issues.
Today, the assets held at the troubled banks are US government Treasury bonds which are still worth exactly what banks paid for them (par value) as long as they don’t have to be sold in distress. This makes what we are seeing today a liquidity issue, not a solvency issue. In the grand scheme of things, liquidity issues can be overcome. Solvency issues cannot.
We know from the evidence placed before our eyes over recent months and years that the tech sector, and more especially the crypto-adjacent part, is systemically infused with greed and - in many cases - outright fraudulent and criminal…