Listen

Description

It was a fourth straight week of higher stock prices with markets in a sweet spot right now as recent data has shown that growth is slowing but still positive, corporate earnings and outlooks are proving to be very strong and disinflation may have slowed, but it has not stalled.

This is also a market that once again seems to be happy talking itself into the idea that the Fed is going to cut interest rates in the not-too-distant future (a first cut in September and then another one sometime before year-end is currently the futures market’s best guess). Fed officials are sticking to the script, however, continuing to hammer home the higher-for-longer mantra in their speaking engagements last week.

Even as Wednesday’s release of the Consumer Price Index (CPI) measure of retail inflation loomed into view on Monday, there was not a lot of enthusiasm on the part of traders to take a strong view one way or another ahead of the numbers and the outcome was a fifth consecutive trading day of barely any movement in the major indexes, but with the S&P 500 still managing to hold above the important 5200 level. Beneath the index level, the news of the day was dominated by a resurgence of meme stock mania (see OTHER NEWS below).

Tuesday morning’s starter to the main course that was the following day’s CPI, was the Producer Price Index (PPI) measure of wholesale inflation experienced in April by manufacturers which came in hotter than expected, rising +0.5% for the month and +2.2% for the year. However, the prior month’s number was revised down to a very chilly -0.1% and that seemed to balance things out as far as Wall Street was concerned. The net effect ended up being positive for stocks, with a late rally carrying the indexes higher, albeit still within a pretty tight range.

When CPI came out pre-market on Wednesday, we learned that the annualized headline inflation rate ticked slightly lower to +3.4%, the first time it has cooled this year. The important annual Core inflation rate (ex-food and energy) came in at +3.6%. All of this was very much in the same ZIP code as expectations.

Also released on Wednesday were the latest Retail Sales figures that were unexpectedly flat in April along with a slight downward revision to March, indicating that consumer spending was beginning to lose some momentum. This was viewed as a nice addition to the CPI-generated narrative of potentially cooling retail price increases and a possible acceleration of the timeline for interest rate cuts from the Fed.

Markets breathed a collective sigh of relief at the lack of an unpleasant inflation upside surprise and the welcome signs of still-intact disinflation, pushing stocks higher at the open and it only got better from there. We reached new all-time closing highs for the S&P 500 (for the 23rd time so far this year but the first time since March), the NASDAQ (for the eighth time so far this year) and even the stupid Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) which got to within spitting distance of the 40,000 level for the first time and is now double what it was less than eight years ago, even without Nvidia, Meta/Facebook and Alphabet/Google being in the index.

Stock markets returned to snooze mode on Thursday, following a series of little twists and turns and closed slightly lower as traders digested the week’s gains. This was despite a very healthy earnings report driven by international and e-commerce strength from the bellwether stock, Walmart (WMT), pushing the stock price up to its highest level ever.

Another generally quiet one for stocks on Friday too, although by the closing bell, the S&P 500 index had closed above 5300 for the first time and we also saw the first-ever close above 40,000 for the DJIA, thanks to a very positive literally final minute of the session, which brought yet another solid Wall Street week to an end.

These new highs for most of the indexes have just eclipsed levels last seen in March as the 5.5% “correction” in stocks came to an end in the space of about a month, so what has happened since then?

* The first Fed rate cut is now not expected until September, not June (as it was in March). 

* The Fed is now only expected to cut once or twice, not four or five times (as it was in March). 

* The unemployment rate has now risen to 3.9%, tying the highest level in months. 

* CPI inflation for last month is now at 3.4% annualized, up from 3.1% in March’s reading for February. 

* Earnings expectations remain pretty much unchanged. 

Not one of these factors is “better” now than it was in March, indeed some of them are noticeably “worse”. So, why are stocks higher today than they were in late March?

The answer lies in all the happy talk. Investors have convinced themselves that we are in the midst of a near stock-perfect Goldilocks environmentthat’s still characterized by 1) stable growth and earnings, 2) falling inflation, 3) upcoming Fed rate cuts and 4) AI enthusiasm. While all four of those aspects of this market are probably in a worse state today than they were in March, they’re not “worse enough” to force these investors to think they aren’t still all happening. Put differently, the environment may not be as good as it was in March, but it’s still good enough to push stocks higher. 

The problem, as JP Morgan‘s Jamie Dimon pointed out last week, is what happens to markets when it becomes clear that one or more of those four factors is no longer in place, because Wall Street seems to have not really baked in that possibility in the course of an ongoing seven-month rally in stock prices.

OTHER NEWS .. MEME STOCK EDITION

Here We Go Again? .. Shares of GameStop (GME) skyrocketed over 100% in value in just the first 30 minutes of trading on Monday morning, ending the day on 30X its normal trading volume, after Keith Gill, the key driver of the meme stock craze of 2021, known by his online persona of “Roaring Kitty” and recently portrayed by Paul Dano in the enjoyable if somewhat factually incomplete movie, “Dumb Money”, apparently posted a cryptic tweet for the first time after basically having disappeared online almost three years ago. I say “apparently” because as the week wore on, doubts began to emerge out there as to whether it was actually him doing the tweeting, had he sold his account name or perhaps got hacked?

The tweet raised speculation that retail investors may again run up shares of GameStop and some of the other members of the old Meme Team like AMC Entertainment (AMC) and Hertz (HTZ), which also soared that day for no rational reason. The mania continued into Tuesday with more big price spikes - but reality suddenly set in on Wednesday when prices corrected back down and hard, wiping out a large portion of the gains in the first few minutes of trading.

The stock market continued to punch any meme stock day traders who had decided on Tuesday to hop on the bandwagon in the face on Thursday and Friday sending their stock prices cascading lower. GME ended Friday’s session more than 54% below where it had been just 72 hours earlier to a price representing just a 16% increase on the week, having been up as much as 180% at one point. There’s not a lot of “Diamond Hands” HODLing of the stock happening here.

These meme stock movements make for fun stories and amusing investor profiles for financial journalists but from an actual market standpoint, the price action just hints at a lingering complacency amongst investors. As was pointed out on many occasions last week, one wordless post on X/Twitter shouldn’t increase a company’s market capitalization by over $4 billion in a matter of minutes and, frankly, the outlook for GameStop’s business is particularly bleak right now (it has a $10 billion market cap and in the last year only reported $6.7 million in net income. It’s price to earnings multiple got to more than 1,000X last week, compared to the stock market’s 21X - obviously completely unsustainable).

This nonsense happens in frothy markets when there’s money sloshing around…



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit simonbrady.substack.com