There’s a very accurate saying that that you can win just about any financial argument you like by simply adjusting the start and end dates of a scenario. There’s a perfect example of this on show right now with the most important question of all to investors.
Is what we have seen over the last few weeks a temporary pullback within what is still a bull (rising) market that dates back to March of this year .. or .. is what we have seen over the last few months a temporary rally within what is still a bear (falling) market that dates back to the end of 2021?
The highly-respected and influential Charles Schwab Chief Investment Analyst, Liz Ann Sonders, climbed off the fence last week and put herself squarely in the second camp, saying that she now thinks that what we are currently witnessing is the death of the March-July rally and a reversion back to the declining trend that began in late 2021. The implication being, of course, that the S&P 500 lows of October 2022 (which are about 20% below where we are now) could well be tested again.
Terrified as I am to go up against Liz Ann who I admire immensely, I am personally still hanging on to the opposite view to her (albeit by a narrower and narrower thread); that 2023’s stock market rally is currently being interrupted rather than terminated.
On Monday, oversold stocks bounced back from a miserable couple of weeks with the most-beaten down names coming back the most vigorously. This was despite yet another day of rising market rates with 16-year interest rate highs being reached by the 10 Year Treasury Bond. By the next day, however, a “Sell The Rally”mentality seemed to have taken over with stock investors taking the opportunity of Monday’s spike to sell and lock in profits.
Tuesday’s sour tone was not helped by Standard & Poor’s ratings agency downgrading the credit ratings of several regional banking lenders including KeyCorp (KEY), Comerica (CMA), Valley National Bancorp (VLY), UMB Financial (UMBF), and Associated Banc-Corp (ASB), citing liquidity concerns.
Wednesday was dominated by giddy excitement over the upcoming after-the-close earnings release of chip maker Nvidia (NVDA) and markets shifted nicely higher again in anticipation. After the bell, we learned that the company had indeed absolutely crushed earnings and revenue expectations. It reported $13.5 billion in revenue for Q2, up an astonishing 88% from Q1. It also projected Q3 revenue to hit $16 billion. Sales were more than double those from the same quarter a year previously. All these numbers blew away analysts’ estimates.
But any broader feel-good effects from Nvidia’s outstanding results proved to be only fleeting once things opened on Thursday. The market doesn’t generally discount the same information twice (remember it was the spectacular Q1 results from Nvidia that had already driven the stock price up by nearly 50% since May) and by lunchtime, markets were down in the dumps again as concerns grew about what Chairman Jerome Powell might say (and not say) the next day at the Federal Reserve’s equivalent of its Burning Man festival in Jackson Hole, Wyoming. Wednesday’s handsome market gains were quickly extinguished by a pretty ugly Thursday decline.
Powell made his much-anticipated speech on Friday morning and it can be summed up in four words: “This ain't over yet.” He sent no explicit signals about the Fed's immediate intentions on interest rates, but his comments set the stage for the central bank to hold things steady or raise interest rates further in the months ahead, if needed - while dismissing the possibility of interest rate cuts any time soon.
Markets weren’t sure how to react at first. Stocks, bonds and the US dollar all see-sawed in the hours following the speech before finally seeming to decide that actually Powell hadn’t really said anything new and stocks shifted solidly higher in the afternoon, helped by investors finally deciding to flip the recent script and “Buy The Dip” (see EXPLAINER: FINANCIAL TERM OF THE WEEK below). It was this that helped rescue what was a volatile, topsy-turvy five days. The S&P 500 and NASDAQ-100 both somehow ended up in the green for the week.
Bottom line, the market of 2023 in many ways resembles the current political climate in this country in that it is being defined by hyperbolic extremes. We started the year with everyone deathly afraid of a catastrophic and unavoidable recession, 1970’s style inflation and 1970’s-style interest rates. None of that happened and at some point markets decided that the Wicked Witch was dead and it was now blue skies all the way. Stocks ripped higher on a runaway train powered mostly by overly-positive sentiment (partly due to AI-mania) and extreme greed as measured by the FEAR & GREED INDEX (see below). But just because Armageddon did not come to pass when it was expected to, it is still entirely possible that:
* a significant and rather painful economic slowdown will occur,
* inflation will not magically crash to late 20-teens levels in the near future,
* the Fed may actually be telling the truth and will not suddenly set about cutting interest rates soon (which is what markets had priced in at the end of July when the S&P 500 was flirting with closing above 4,600).
The eventual truth likely lies in the middle somewhere and that’s where markets are sitting right now, as demonstrated by the day-to-day indecisive up/down/up/down/up dynamic that we saw last week. Where we go from here - and how quickly - in the coming weeks is critical to the health, or even the continued existence, of the 2023 rally.
OTHER NEWS ..
Car Trouble .. Auto-loan delinquencies are surging. Just one new car model now sells for less than $20k - down from about a dozen just five years ago. Considerably higher interest rates are only making buyers’ situations even more difficult. The average interest rate charged for a new car loan is now 9.5%, according to Cox Automotive. There aren’t many bargains on the used-car lot either, where the average vehicle lists for about $27k - up more than 30% from pre-pandemic levels. For used car loans, the average interest rate is higher, at almost 14%.
These numbers could explain why, despite a strong jobs market and robust wage growth, seasonally-adjusted rates of severe delinquency for car loans are the highest since James Blunt squealed that you’re beautiful in 2006. Clearly, an increasing number of consumers cannot afford the auto loans that they are taking on.
Airbnb Crackdown .. Thousands of New York City Airbnb listings are vanishing from the marketplace. The city is about to clamp down on all Airbnb rentals. NYC officials say that, starting on September 5th, they will be more aggressively enforcing rules on short-term rentals, including already-existing requirements that hosts must first register with the city and not rent out an entire apartment or home. Hosts are also required to be present at the property during their guests’ short-term stays. In response and in preparation for the crackdown, NYC listings are being rapidly removed from the platform.
New York’s enforcement is one of the more high-profile recent examples of cities coming down hard on short-term rentals. There were recently over 38k Airbnb listings in the city, not counting hotels that list on the platform. The annual net revenue for these listings is over $85 million. The city estimates there are about 11k illegal short-term rentals citywide.
How Much To Move? .. The lowest annual pay that would entice the average American worker to switch jobs hit a record high $78,645 in July. The so-called “national reservation wage” is up from $72,900 a year earlier, a New York Fed survey showed. And while the pay demand by women rose 11%, twice as fast as for men, they’re not asking for as much. Men want about $91k to jump jobs, while women are looking for about $25k less.
UNDER THE HOOD ..
The S&P 500 index SPXclosed on Friday at 4406,up a little for the week. The next upside resistance point…