Despite a valiant comeback effort on Friday, stocks endured a mostly jittery week and ended lower as some generally-accepted market narratives began to shift. Good news for the economy is finally becoming good news for stocks. The S&P 493 (without the so-called Magnificent Seven) is finally looking in good shape relative to the S&P 500 (which is dominated by the Magnificent Seven) and, according to an emerging heresy straight from the mouth of a leading Fed official no less, we may not be getting any interest rate cuts at all in 2024!
Trading on Monday was thinner than usual with many markets around the world still closed for Easter. Inflation figures released when the market was closed the previous Friday did little to bring forward the expected interest rate cut start date. The market-driven probability of a June rate cut briefly dipped below 50% for the first time and is now considered to be a coin flip (see FEDWATCH INTEREST RATE TOOL below). Market interest rates spiked higher, driving both stock and bond prices lower.
The retreat in stock prices accelerated on Tuesday with all indexes declining substantially as traders grew more anxious about higher market interest rates and the possibility of a “too-hot” Jobs Report on Friday. It also didn’t help the inflation outlook that oil prices shifted significantly higher to multi-month highs as the temperature of the Middle East conflict rose after Israel killed seven food aid workers in Gaza including American, British, Australian and Polish citizens and simultaneously launched fatal airstrikes on an Iranian consulate in Syrian sovereign territory.
On Wednesday, the fall in bond prices caused by the increasing market interest rates started looking more like a rout. The deadly Taiwanese earthquake caused some brief concern in the chip space, but giant chip producer TSMC quickly reported only a negligible effect on production, successfully calming market nerves, but Intel sank over 8% in a matter of minutes on poor profit and sales data, obviously unrelated to the earthquake.
Fed chairman Jerome Powell pretty much came right out and said it in a speech at Stanford; a soft landing seems to be happening and that just because the path to 2% inflation is bumpy doesn't mean we're off it. This encouraged a few dip buyers to finally move in to stabilize things and take most stock prices a smidge higher for the session after a pretty rough couple of days.
Thursday started out with the indexes chugging along nicely until that well-known Fed big-mouth, the Minneapolis president Neel Kashkari (who has never met a media microphone that he could resist speaking into) suggested that if progress falters in the fight against inflation, there may well be a grand total of zero interest rate cuts in 2024. This possibility has always been whispered about in hushed tones on the fringes, but for a senior Fed official to come out and openly put it out there caused havoc in an already nervy market and stock prices tumbled far and fast.
Friday was Jobs Day, with the critical data release from the Bureau of Labor Statistics coming out before the market open. We learned that job growth surged in March, as employers added 303k new positions, almost 100k more than expected and January and February’s job creation was revised upward. Unemployment ticked down to 3.8% but, importantly for inflation calculations, average hourly earnings fell to the lowest level in nearly three years at 4.1% annualized. This was the 39th consecutive month of job growth in the U.S. which has seen a total of 15 million new jobs added over that time and the unemployment rate has been not been above 4% for over two years now.
With the U.S. economy now showing signs of re-accelerating and recession risk seemingly as far away as ever, a relieved stock market took prices solidly higher in response - erasing the previous day’s losses but not those of the week as a whole.
Interestingly, this upward move in stock prices was in violation of the recent conventional formula of; strong economic data = higher inflation risk = a delay in interest rate cuts = lower stock prices. As I have alluded to of late, this old school line of logic appears to be breaking down in an environment where the Fed is showing signs of tolerance of >2% inflation, at least for a while. The updated formula would now seem to be; strong economic data = less chance of a damaging recession = improvement in earnings outlook = higher stock prices.
The shaky news last week did not really threaten the pillars upon which the rally since October has been built, but with the S&P 500 currently priced for perfection and at such very high valuations (21X earnings, vs. a long term average of around 19X), it doesn’t need to be game-changing to cause a correction of a few percent.
The merest suggestion of a challenge to an accepted orthodoxy (in last week’s case, that of the assumption of multiple interest rate cuts in 2024 following Kashkari’s comments) can have a swift and nasty effect on stock prices. In other words, there’s ample room for disappointment with markets at these levels. Wall Street seems to be beginning to take the view that the chances of a 5%-10% pullback are probably greater in the short term than the chances of a further 5%-10% rally.
Even if stock prices are able to continue higher, there are signs that investors may finally be tiring of Big Tech in general and the Magnificent Seven (which has frankly shrunk to the Fab Five now) in particular and looking to move into into other sectors that have more reasonable valuations.
OTHER NEWS ..
Tesla Crashing ..Tesla continues to get battered as a shockingly lower sales report on Tuesday saw a record miss of even the most pessimistic of estimates which, along with higher inventory data, confirmed that the world is rapidly falling out of love with the company’s products and very possibly with a very distracted Elon Musk’s unhinged antics as well. Then on Friday, Reuters reported that Tesla’s long-held plans for a new lower price-point ($25k) vehicle have been scrapped although this was initially denied by Musk in a rather detail-free tweet that simply accused Reuters of lying.
Tesla is the worst performing stock in the S&P 500 index this year, indeed if you had bought the stock at the beginning of the year, you’d be down about 34% on that trade on Friday, while the S&P 500 (of which Tesla is a major component) has moved up 9% over the same time frame.
In other Elon news, Fidelity last week cut the valuation of its position in X/Twitter by 5.7% from just a month earlier. That now implies a 73% drop in the company’s value since his 2022 purchase.
Insurance Premium Storm .. U.S. home insurance rates are expected to reach a record high this year, with the biggest increases occurring in states prone to severe weather events. The average premium for homeowners’ insurance in the U.S. is expected to hit $2,522 by the end of the year, driven largely by intensifying natural disasters, rising reinsurance costs and higher fees for home repair. That figure would represent a 6% increase over that of 2023, and follows a roughly 20% increase across the past two years.
One of the motivations to buy a home is the idea that housing costs will remain relatively fixed or stable, compared to renting, but this trend of regular and meaningful insurance rate hikes is up-ending that narrative.
UNDER THE HOOD ..
With the S&P 500 considerably overheated and overbought on a fundamental valuation basis and the threat of volatility on the rise, three potential technical downside “gap fills” were in play for the index in Q2 , the lowest of which is 4,982, which would mean a roughly 4.3% further pullback from Friday’s closing price.
While the long-term market uptrend remains firmly intact, several short-term factors increase the probabilities of an overdue pullback. In the context of the healthy long-term trend, any short term turbulence that arises is likely best viewed as just that.…