Listen

Description

To reiterate what I said last week, the absolutely key question when it comes to financial markets in 2023 is: Will inflation fall faster than economic growth and earnings?

Mark your calendars for when we will get the next hints at an answer ..

* Thursday, January 12th when the US Consumer Price Index (CPI) measure of retail inflation is released. Why It’s Important: The key for the next CPI report (and every CPI report in 2023) is solid evidence of continued downward momentum in inflation. Specifically, the headline CPI number turning negative month-over-month (down from the 0.1% increase last month) and the year-over-year reading falling below last month’s 7.1%. Even more important than headline CPI, however, is the Core CPI reading as it give us a better view of service sector inflation. Markets will want to see tangible declines from the 0.2% month-over-month and 6.0% year-over-year increases that we saw for November. If we see this hoped-for trajectory, stocks could definitely begin to pick themselves up off the floor. A failure on the part of the CPI data to come through with these improvements, however, could be very damaging indeed.

* Friday, January 13th through Friday, January 27th which is the meat of the Q4 2022 earnings season.Why It’s Important: One of the main reasons stocks dropped in December was the growing concern about the likely state of corporate earnings in 2023. If the general tendency of Q4 earnings is disappointing, that will begin to weigh heavily on stocks. Conversely, if earnings are more resilient than currently feared, then that will be an early positive catalyst.

Bottom Line: Markets enter 2023 at an important transition point. One path is paved with continued disinflation, resilient earnings, gently moderating growth, a more balanced labor market with higher unemployment and rising stock and bond prices. The other path is paved with sticky inflation, rapidly slowing growth, a continued tight labor market with low unemployment and continually falling stock and bond prices. These two data points in January will offer important clues as to towards which path the markets are heading.

Nothing new was really added to the overall narrative during what was a low-volume trading week with a somewhat negative feel to it. Traders trickled back from the holiday break on Tuesday, with exactly the same lack of excitement for growth-focused stocks that they've had for pretty much all of 2022. Markets churned back and forth aimlessly all week.

A daily average of only around 3 billion shares changed hands on the New York Stock Exchange last week versus the year-to-date average of more than 4.6 billion. Low trading volume can exacerbate daily moves, there are just fewer traders at their desks inclined to step in and counter any trend that develops.

The final grisly scorecard for calendar year 2022 was a 19% decline for the S&P 500, its biggest pullback since 2008 and fourth worst year in its history, and a 33% decline for the NASDAQ, also its worst year since 2008. And add to that, of course, a collapse in government bond prices as yields spiked with the Fed’s aggressive interest rate hiking policy as well as the implosion of the whole crypto eco-system in a mushroom cloud of fraud and deceit.

There is an unfortunate behavioral tendency early in a calendar year that can be summed up in the expression: “things had better improve quickly or I’m out”, referring of course to clients throwing in the towel and selling out of stock positions because the turnaround does not appear imminent. This is, of course, the exact opposite of what is sensible, but many people still do it.

We are experiencing historic times in financial markets. Most investors have some kind of a combination of both stocks and bonds. The year that just ended was the most difficult for stocks since 2008 and the worst year for bonds in any of our lifetimes. Both at the same time!!

Never before in history have both stocks and bonds both fallen by double-digits in the same calendar year. That makes it a really, really bad time to sell if you don’t have to. It also makes it a really, really good time to buy stock ETFs if you have a long term horizon.

Market history is extremely clear:  Periods like this provide opportunities to help secure your long term financial future, as long as you resist the urge for short term protection at the expense of longer term gains. The actions you take at times like this determine the end-balance of money available to you in the far future to a much greater degree than the actions you take during those years when stocks are moving higher all the time (almost every year from 2009-2021 for example!). There is definitely light at the end of the tunnel but the problem is that we have no idea how long this current tunnel may be.

While we can never know where we’re going, we ought to try to understand where we are. The goal of this weekly report (and the quarterly market reviews, look out for the next one sometime this week) is to help you recognize why markets are falling at the moment, but also to show you what I believe likely needs to in place for this bear market to finally end (there is a legitimate path to a rebound in early 2023, not an easy one, but it does exist) and also to put everything in a proper long term context.

OTHER NEWS

Stock-pickers just suck .. Just in case there’s anyone left on the planet who still thinks that picking stocks is a profitable endeavor in the long term,a report in the New York Times showed that, over the last five years, not a single actively-managed mutual fund in the US beat the market regularly, using the definition that S&P Dow Jones Indices has employed for two decades.

The S&P Dow Jones team looked at all 2,132 actively-managed domestic stock mutual funds (non-index funds that have professional human fund managers picking the stocks in the fund) that had been operating for at least twelve months as of June 2018, excluding very narrowly-focused sector funds and leveraged funds that, essentially, use borrowed money to magnify their returns.

The team selected the 25 percent of the funds with the best performance over the twelve months through June 2018. Then the analysts asked how many of those funds remained in the top quarter for the four succeeding twelve-month periods through June 2022.

The answer was none.

Not a single one of the actively-managed funds in the US managed to achieve top-quartile performance for five successive years. Then they did the same thing for actively-managed fixed income funds and came up with the same result: zero. Not a single bond fund was in the top quarter when it came to performance for five 12-month periods.

The inevitable conclusion: those fund managers who did make it into the top quartile from time-to-time simply got lucky for a year or two. They benefited from unsustainably good fortune for a while - and it always ran out. If it was down to skill, then why did it never, ever persist?

Then the researchers used a far easier test with a much lower bar. How many funds ended up in the top 50 percent all five years? How many simply did better the median for five years in a row?

For those 2,132 funds, the answer was .. a dismal one percent!

Consider a school with 210 students in a class. Not all the high performers will always score in the top 25 percent of their class every single year for five years, but you’d expect that at least some would. And if only two kids in the whole class showed above-average performance every year for five years, I’d begin to think that there was something seriously wrong at the school.

Growth vs.Value is not even a debate right now, with little sign of change .. Tesla’s price meltdown (it cratered almost 70% in 2022) has pushed it out of the top ten US companies by market value. As of last week it was in 16th place and dropping further down the charts like a stone.

The stock’s collapse continues to infect the whole high growth / tech / communications sector which…



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit simonbrady.substack.com