Listen

Description

It is said on Wall Street that the goal of the market is to extract the maximum amount of pain from the greatest number of people. What this is getting at is that when everyone is positioned as bullish, the pain trade is for markets to move lower. When everyone is bearish, the pain trade is for them to go higher.

As such, the pain trade has been mostly inflicted on the bears so far in 2023 and is helping support stocks, despite decidedly dodgy economic fundamentals. Sentiment matters in the short-term and so the pain trade was to push the market higher to some degree, especially after general caution gave way to fully-fledged bearish sentiment following the bank failures in mid-March and increasing evidence that the economy may be starting to crash.

However, it seems that sentiment may shifting again after some surprisingly decent early earnings reports, recent hopeful inflation data and the end of rate hikes finally coming into view. It’s worth keeping an eye on sentiment in this regard (I show the latest AAII Investor Sentiment Index readings every week in this report, see below) as the direction of the pain trade may be about to flip.

For the moment markets remain resilient, but that resiliency has been underpinned by the aggressive idea of an imminent “Fed hike/pause/pivot/cut” interest rate narrative and an only-gradual slowing of economic growth. We won’t know if this thesis is correct until we can properly assess how deep the economic slowdown is going to be.

While the chances of the US completely avoiding a recession seem small, there is still a very legitimate possibility that it may only be a mild one. Consider the following ..

• The S&P 500 is up 25% from the pre-pandemic levels of January 2020.

• The National Home Price Index is up 38% from January 2020.

• Wages have risen 53% since January 2020.

• Pandemic stimulus across 476 million payments totaled more than $814 billion-worth of deposits which went straight into the pockets of American consumers.

• 90% of the $770 billion Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) loans have been completely or partially forgiven, injecting massive stimulus into the economy.

The critical point here is that consumers have simply had more money to work through before they have to start changing their behavior in response to inflation and the Fed’s interest rate hikes. This goes a long way to explaining why the Fed has had to raise interest rates again and again and again at a historically unprecedented rate of basically 0% to 5% in the space of a year, simply in order to get the attention of the American consumer who entered last year flush with stimulus money, a suddenly much more valuable home bought or re-financed using an ultra-low fixed rate mortgage, higher wages and a fatter investment portfolio. The result was that turbo-charged rate hike campaign that severely damaged both the stock and bond markets which made 2022 uniquely painful even for the most diversified of portfolios.

The first shots were fired last week in the upcoming congressional grandstanding about the debt ceiling (see EXPLAINER: FINANCIAL TERM OF THE WEEK below). “Let me be clear: a no-strings-attached debt limit increase cannot pass .. debt limit negotiations are an opportunity to examine our nation’s finances." bellowed House Speaker Kevin McCarthy during a speech at the New York Stock Exchange, of all places.Chuck Schumer shot right back,"If Speaker McCarthy doesn't change his course, he could well take this country to default."

Investors aren't yet paying any serious attention to the back-and-forth sniping, even though the last serious debt ceiling battle in 2011 did cause tumbling markets and a downgrade of US debt. While we can expect some occasional short-term market volatility at times when the irksome squealing reaches fever pitch, I think it is very important to maintain a distinction between tiresome short-term Washington gamesmanship and any potential long-term damage to investment portfolios.

Traders seem to have settled into the idea of a quarter-point rate increase from the Fed next month (that probability is now up to 89%, see FEDWATCH INTEREST RATE PREDICTION TOOL below) and early earnings have been mostly fine, with just a few disappointments here and there. The result has been a collective yawn for much of the last week or two. But with earnings about to hit full steam this week (see THIS WEEK’S UPCOMING CALENDAR below), investors will finally have plenty to think about beyond just inflation, interest rates and yield curves. Earnings season has a way of returning investors' attention to the fundamentals and the bottom line.

One of the single, most dominant market dynamics right now is the deeply inverted yield curve and, for that reason, starting this week I have begun to monitor it as one of my important data points shown in this report each week (see US TREASURY INTEREST RATE YIELD CURVE below).

OTHER NEWS ..

Due Diligence Queen .. Investors recently launched lawsuits against Sam Bankman-Fried, the disgraced crypto bro founder of FTX and also against those who shilled for him in return for very large compensation, including quarterback Tom Brady and his ex-wife, Gisele Bündchen, Larry David, Kevin “Mr. Wonderful” O’Leary, David “Big Papi” Ortiz, tennis player Naomi Osaka as well as the NBA’s Steph Curry and Shaquille O’Neal. They were all charged along with others with taking a lot of money in order to participate in the duping of the millions who lost billions when SBF’s crypto house of cards came tumbling down.

However, there was one person who was smart enough not to fall for the hype. It emerged last week that, unlike the afore-mentioned money-grubbing band of hoodwinked celebs who’ll obviously say anything for a buck without looking into what it is they are peddling or any of their highly-compensated advisors who push them to do so in order to earn their own slice of the pie through commissions, Taylor Swift apparently thought to actually ask about the status of the investments as “unregistered securities”, promotion of which for financial gain makes an individual liable to claims for damages. She obviously did not like the answer she got since she declined the opportunity to promote SBF and his fraudulent enterprise.

You can shove your savings account .. Higher interest rates have so far been good news for the big banks, which have been able to charge borrowers more on loans and credit cards, but not pay as much interest to depositors. Currently, the annual interest rate paid to customers by big bank savings accounts averages a miserly 0.37% as opposed to an easily available 4.35% or more elsewhere).

Unsurprisingly, the banks’ clientele is increasingly telling the banks to stick their savings accounts and is moving its money into deposits at these other institutions and instruments that pay a much higher interest rate with zero fees and sometimes much higher levels of FDIC or SIPC insurance coverage than the traditional $250k per account offered by high street banks.

Credit spike .. Despite increasing interest charges, Americans spent big on credit cards in Q1 2023, according to an article in the Wall Street Journal last week. Bank of America said that spending on its credit cards rose 6% from a year earlier. Credit card spending was up 13% year-on-year at JP Morgan, 7% at Citigroup and 16% at Wells Fargo. Overall credit card loan balances rose sharply at the four banks, a sign that a growing number of people are now not paying off their full balances each month.

UNDER THE HOOD ..

Anyone measuring the stock market’s health solely by the gains made in the S&P 500 is not seeing the big picture. While the index, along with its large-cap cousins, the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) and the NASDAQ, have enjoyed respectable gains since early March, this has obscured the fact that smaller stock indexes are still reeling from the bank-induced sell-off six weeks ago. When it is only the largest and most high profile portion o…



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit simonbrady.substack.com