Listen

Description

Bad news is often good news for investors these days, who have to perform mental gymnastics as the economic picture comes into focus. Traditionally negative indicators of a weaker economy such as rising unemployment or falling consumer spending tend to result in lower inflation, which likely means the Fed can take its foot off the gas with monetary tightening, which should mean less pressure to raise interest rates, which means potentially higher stock valuations.

We saw some of great examples of this last week.

First, the August Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS) came up surprisingly short. There were a seasonally adjusted 10.1 million job openings at the end of August, down from 11.2 million a month earlier. That's the biggest month-over-month decline in job openings since the depths of COVID in April 2020. Facing higher interest rates and signs of a slowing economy, employers appear to be cutting back on their hiring plans.

We also saw weak US manufacturing data (the lowest reading since May 2020) which offered new evidence that economic growth and demand are slowing which on the surface is not normally a plus for stock markets. But you can follow the breadcrumbs from this data to a Fed that is showing signs of success in bringing inflation back under control and therefore may be more inclined to ease off the pace of its aggressive interest-rate hikes in the months ahead.

Investors didn't panic at these clear signs that the economy may be heading for trouble, instead they celebrated. The market, which was overdue for a rebound rally anyhow, ripped higher for two full days on Monday and Tuesday.

Bets on the Fed Funds rate getting to an upper band of 5% by the end of 2023 fell away, according to the CME FedWatch Tool. By Tuesday, futures markets were pointing to the 4% to 4.25% range as being the the most likely target.

Screens were flooded with green by Tuesday’s close after these two rather economically disappointing data releases. Sentiment were also bolstered by the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA), who surprised everyone when it raised the Australian version of the Fed Funds interest rate by a mere 0.25% when it had been widely expected to go with 0.50% or even 0.75%. Cue more hope that we may all be getting closer to peak interest rates for this hiking cycle.

Faced with this suddenly born-again idea that interest rates may not rise quite as fast or for as long as feared, the Fed got straight down to business pouring cold water on it, using its favorite weapon: dialed-up Fed-Speak. Chair Jerome Powell’s foot soldiers were blitzing the airwaves and roaring fire and brimstone from stages around the country, turning up the volume with the Fed’s highly-targeted messaging.

San Francisco Fed’s Mary Daly reiterated the Fed’s hawkish stance and the commitment to getting inflation down while strongly dismissing expectations of rate cuts in early to mid-2023. Atlanta Fed’s Raphael Bostic also dismissed the notion of rate cuts next year. Fed Governor Christopher Waller, a current voting member of the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) that sets the interest rates, was pretty explicit when he said that"inflation is far from the FOMC's goal and not likely to fall quickly" while his fellow Governor Lisa Cook described inflation as “stubbornly persistent”. Minneapolis Fed President Neel Kashkari said the Fed was “quite a ways away" from pausing its campaign of interest-rate increases.

This all burst the market’s bubble and on Wednesday and Thursday we saw far more muted enthusiasm ahead of Friday’s important jobs report as investors were reminded of the old adage that fighting the Fed is usually not a great idea. What we eventually saw on Friday was yet another classic example of the “good news is bad news” effect. More mental gymnastics required.

Pre-market, we learned that the US economy had added yet another 263k jobs in September, over 50k down from the August increase of 315k, but still a further expansion of job creation and greater than anticipated. More importantly, the unemployment rate rather unexpectedly fell from 3.7% to 3.5%, a half-century low. In normal times, all pretty positive news for the economy.

However, the market quickly decided to interpret this as a sign that the job market is still strong enough for the Fed to feel the need to continue its aggressive inflation-fighting efforts through interest rate hikes. Stock prices fell hard across the board as we experienced yet another brutal Friday (an increasingly common feature over the last couple of months).

It wasn’t enough, however, to wipe out Monday and Tuesday’s spectacular gains and the major indexes closed broadly higher for the week for the first time in what feels like ages, although well off their highs from Tuesday evening.

The script for how this market misery ends is no mystery: Inflation peaks and quickly recedes, the economy slows meaningfully but doesn’t collapse, geopolitics improves and the corporate earnings outlook stays relatively stable - all of which gets the Fed to peak hawkishness and a pivot away from hiking interest rates (maybe even towards cutting them again). That’s it. That’s the simple recipe to end this bear market and all market participants know it.

This coming week is extremely important for figuring out where we are with this narrative as we get the latest inflation numbers (both retail Consumer Price Index CPI and the wholesale Producer Price Index PPI) and the Q3 earnings season gets under way (see THIS WEEK’S UPCOMING CALENDAR below).

Longer term investors, however, should not deviate from the plan of continuing to systematically buy index funds or certain factor-based ETFs on a regular basis (weekly, bi-weekly, 2x per month, monthly - whatever), indeed stepping up the amount they buy right now, if cash flow allows. I have no idea exactly when, but one day relatively soon you will be very, very glad you did.

OTHER NEWS

K-Krypto trouble .. Finance guruKim Kardashian will pay $1.25 million to settle regulatory charges that she failed to disclose the $250k she was paid to promote tokens of cryptocurrency Ethereum Max (EMAX) to investors on her Instagram account, the Securities and Exchange Commission - SEC (see EXPLAINER: FINANCIAL TERM OF THE WEEK below) announced last week.

Her promotional post included a link to the EMAX website, which provided instructions for how to invest in EMAX, which fell 97% in value after her post first appeared. She agreed to give back the $250k and pay a $1 million penalty.

“This case is a reminder that, when celebrities or influencers endorse any investment opportunities, including crypto asset securities, it doesn’t mean those investment products are right for all investors,” SEC Chairman Gary Gensler said.

KK is the latest celebrity to face punishment for flouting investor-protection laws over getting mixed up with crypto bros and their promotional schemes. Boxing’s Floyd Mayweather, music industry’s Nick Carter (‘N Sync) and Soulja Boy and YouTuber Jake Paul all face similar or greater sanctions for allegedly fraudulent crypto involvement.

Please let it be over .. Like a bad smell, Elon Musk wafted back into our consciousness as he finally admitted defeat and agreed to buy Twitter (TWTR) by an October 28th deadline for the price to which he had originally committed, hopefully bringing this whole tiresome saga to an end.

Unsurprisingly, the news boosted the ailing TWTR stock price, but Tesla (TSLA) shareholders were not impressed that the company’s notoriously unfocused and erratic boss will now have a shiny new toy to play with and TSLA stock stumbled badly on the news. Out of the Jack Dorsey frying pan and into the Elon Musk fire. Gotta feel for those Twitter shareholders when it comes to who’s driving the train.

UNDER THE HOOD:

Regardless of the prevailing narrative, the main reason for the rally early last week was buyers’ recognition of an oversold condition and a ripe environment for BTFD activity with RSI read…



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit simonbrady.substack.com