After having risen for 14 of the last 15 weeks, the S&P 500 fell a smidge last week. It basically went on a wild ride to nowhere, driven mostly by messy economic data. There were two signals that inflation isn’t dying as quickly as markets (and the Federal Reserve) would like and there was also a sign that the prolific American consumer may finally be starting to close their wallet a little, all of which combined to hurt stocks, causing one index to have its worst day in years. Yet somehow the week also managed to contain more new all-time highs for Large Cap U.S. stocks.
Markets started out on Monday just as they had ended the previous Friday, although on lower volume - perhaps not that surprising on the day after the Super Bowl, when an estimated 16 million Americans skipped work. The result was at first another straight march higher but then, with the 5,050 level within sight for the S&P 500, nerves finally set in ahead of the following day’s retail inflation report. Traders decided that they wanted to maybe take a little off the table, being that many of them have been making some pretty big bets on the inflation-down/stocks-up narrative already this calendar year. Most indexes sank back and ended up down a touch for the day except for the Russell 2K Small Cap index which was having a moment, up almost another 2% on the session.
When it came out pre-market on Tuesday morning, the Consumer Price Index (CPI) measure of retail inflation caught Wall Street off guard and took a sledge hammer to stock prices. Core CPI rose 0.4% in January, climbing the most in eight months for a year-on-year rate of 3.9%. Both these data points were higher than expectations and stocks charged headfirst into a buzzsaw, plunging at the open and continuing lower all day.
This was the S&P 500’s worst reaction to a CPI release since September 2022. The NASDAQ-100 and the Russell 2K Small Cap index did even worse, the latter crapping out nearly 4% on the session, its worst day in years and bringing its recent short run of outperformance to a crashing halt.
Treasury yields soared, pushing bond prices lower as the reality seemed to finally hit home that there are now not going to be any interest rate cuts in March and very possibly not in May either. Those market-driven probabilities quickly tumbled to just 7% and 33% respectively. The deemed-most likely interest rate at the end of the year rose to 4.375%, a mere 1.0% lower than now, implying just four rate cuts in 2024 (which finally almost matches what the Fed has been consistently saying since November) as opposed to the market consensus expectation just over a month ago of as many as seven rate cuts this year.
There was something of a knee-jerk snap reversal though on Wednesday, as stocks clawed back a decent portion of Tuesday’s heavy losses as the apparent disgust that inflation had actually dared to pause its rapid downward decline wore off a little in something of a re-think of the need for the previous day’s freakout. The S&P 500 regained the 5000 level but stalled there as stocks ended the day priced almost exactly where they had closed on Thursday of the previous week. Rate cut probabilities recovered a little, too.
Most of the time American consumers can be firmly relied upon to spend lots of money that they don’t have on lots of stuff that they don’t need. But, in another piece of rather surprising economic data, we learned on Thursday that Retail Sales broadly declined last month, indicating that usually turbo-spending Americans finally took a breather. The value of retail purchases in January decreased 0.8% from December, its biggest drop in nearly a year.
Markets reacted by stumbling aimlessly around for much of the day, before Wall Street finally decided that recovering from Tuesday’s over-reaction was more important than running scared from some possibly temporary Retail Sales disappointment and stocks ended the day higher again with the S&P 500 back in all-time closing record high territory.
Next up on Friday morning was the Producer Price Index (PPI) measure of wholesale inflation experienced by manufacturers. The core number for January climbed 0.5% from the prior month and 2.0% from a year ago - both exceeding expectations and acting as something of a confirmation of Tuesday’s rough retail inflation number. Wall Street’s knee jerked yet again and the recovery rally stalled and the S&P 500 floated back down again to end the week about half a percent lower than where it started it.
I said in a recent report that if the probabilities of an interest rate cut in May fell far enough, then “look out below”. That’s what we saw on Tuesday, when the market-driven probability of such a cut fell below 50% on its way to crumbling further to eventually represent only a one-in-three chance by Tuesday’s closing bell.
Indeed an intriguing new narrative began to slowly and quietly emerge last week, initially restricted to the outer fringes of the financial media - but which moved into the mainstream when repeated on Bloomberg TV by somewhat-respected former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers, who said; “There’s a meaningful chance — maybe it’s 15% — that the next move is going to have be upwards in rates, not downwards. The Fed is going to have to be very careful.”
That scenario coming true would horrify Wall Street which has taken stocks on an almost unbroken powerful upward journey since late October of 2023 based primarily on the unshakeable assumption that interest rates were imminently moving lower. While there has maybe been a little disappointment surrounding the timing of such cuts, the idea that they will arrive sooner or later as the Fed’s next move remained totally unchallenged in public until last week.
It will take another couple of cycles of data releases to either establish a new alarming inflation trend or to show that last week’s data was just a bump in the road before we know if this rather frightening narrative will either take hold or fall silently into the (overflowing) garbage can of financial pundit hot takes that simply never come to pass.
OTHER NEWS ..
Sorry, What Did You Say? .. Ride-hailing provider Lyft had a bumbling, chaotic week. The firm saw the price of its shares soar 67% in after-hours trading on Tuesday after releasing results that showed projected earnings jumped by 11% and included a prediction that margins were set to expand this year by an eye-watering 500 basis points (5.00%). But less than an hour later, company CFO Erin Brewer came out and said that in fact the company is actually expecting margins to expand by 50 basis points (0.50%), with a company spokesperson later attributing the extra-zero mistake to a “clerical error” .
Lyft’s rather annoying CEO David Risher did himself no favors by going into lamentably transparent spin mode on TV, casually saying it was “my bad” , acting like he had just spilled someone’s beer or something. He also attempted to minimize the issue by suggesting that it was only a case of just “one zero in a press release.” (false: the error also appeared in multiple documents and was repeated over again on the earnings call before eventually being corrected).
Rumors began to swirl (denied by Risher) that the misinformation was a result of the firm having used AI to generate its earnings report and associated documentation. By the time pre-market trading opened the following morning, the price gain had fallen all the way back to just 17%. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is quite correctly investigating the incident.
Gloomier And Gloomier ..The economic picture around the world darkened as both Japan and the UK fell into technical recessions last week. Adding to the gloom, the European Commission said it expects weaker economic growth across the EuroZone bloc in 2024 and 2025 — bad news for its largest economy, Germany, which is already stagnating economically as well as suffering from increasing political and social turmoil. Of course, these onl…