The S&P 500 ended the week, month and quarter sitting almost exactly in the middle of its range over the last year and a strange calm seems to have descended upon markets. No scary news from the banking sector last week allowed investors to focus on other things, such as earnings and economic releases, which were mostly pretty good.
Traders started the week with a smile on their faces as they learned that First Citizens BancShares (FCNCA), a North Carolina-based regional bank, had agreed to take over substantially all of the assets and liabilities of collapsed Silicon Valley Bank (SVB).
The big economic news of the week was the release of the Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) Price Index. This is the inflation reading that the Fed trusts for measuring inflationary pressures even more than the Consumer Price Index (CPI) as it believes it more closely tracks spending decisions by US consumers and therefore, in many ways, it’s a more important measure when it comes to assessing the Fed’s position.
The PCE index rose 0.3% last month, less than the 0.5% expectation and well down from the 0.6% rise in January. On an annual basis, the index was up 5.0%, decelerating from 5.3% the month before. The important Core PCE Price index, which excludes volatile food and energy costs, was up 0.3% last month and is now down to 4.6% year-over-year, below the level of short term interest rates for the first time in a long time.
These numbers were all regarded as very positive and boosted optimism that the Fed might be able to pull back on their aggressive efforts to fight inflation with a possible pause next time out in May and even possible rate cuts before year-end, although Fed officials continue to deny that such rate cuts are even under consideration. It should be pointed out, however, that this data does not reflect any economic slowdown or tightening of credit conditions resulting from the bank chaos of the last two or three weeks.
This is the fear for the economy; a mini credit-crunch for corporate America (particularly small and mid-size firms), brought about by tighter lending controls instigated by the spooked banks themselves, but also coming down from the regulators.
A brief explainer/reminder of how we got here:
If you were a bank like SVB, you decided to own longer maturity 100% credit-secure US Treasury bonds that you had priced on your balance sheet as if you were going to hold them till the maturity of the bond. The fact that the current re-sale market prices of these bonds had dramatically fallen in value as interest rates have moved back higher didn’t really matter if you are going to hold on to them for their entire duration, as was the original plan, since you weren’t going to be selling them at that current price. If you aren’t selling them, why would you care what the going price is for these bonds?
Until suddenly your customers are pulling their deposits out for a variety of reasons ranging from the implosion of crypto, newly-expensive borrowing costs, VC money drying up, margin calls (see EXPLAINER: FINANCIAL TERM OF THE WEEK, below) on huge losing stock positions in tech/growth stocks - whatever it may be. And the only way to have enough money to fulfill those withdrawal obligations is to actually sell these bond assets in advance of their maturity, something you never planned to do. And all of a sudden, that much lower current price for these assets really does matter!
You are now losing millions upon millions of dollars in hours and days versus what your accountants valued the assets at, as those previously unconcerning paper losses suddenly become real losses. The rest of your customers see what’s happening and self-preservation takes over and they pull their deposits too. And so the death-spiral begins.
The reason the market responded so well to the simple fact that things didn’t get noticeably worse in the banking sector last week is because it is really, really, really important that First Republic (FRC) and any of the other at-risk regional banks like PacWest Bank (PACW), Comerica (CMA) and Zions Bancorporation (ZION) do not fail or become forcibly absorbed by a big box bank. If that happens, contagion will be confirmed and all bets are off.
And then where would the next problems become apparent? Keep half an eye on commercial real estate if that happens. In fact, come to think of it, keep half an eye on commercial real estate anyhow.
But a sense began to emerge last week that perhaps that bullet might have been dodged with no further meaningfully damaging news coming out of the sector.
The Trump circus is being completely ignored by markets and will continue to be unless something highly dramatic comes out of left field, which of course cannot be ruled out.
The short term major market focus is (in order):
* Is there an extended banking crisis?
* Will the Fed cut rates before year-end?
* Will there be a recession?
* What’s happening to inflation?
Last week, the market’s responses felt like:
* We increasingly think probably not.
* The Fed says no, we think yes.
* Maybe, maybe not - but even if there is one, it might be mild and short.
* It may be sticky in parts, but it is generally moving steadily lower.
These sentiments can change very fast from week to week obviously, but by Friday they had contributed to positive end to the day, week, month and quarter (I’ll be publishing my quarterly market review sometime this coming week).
OTHER NEWS ..
Crypto alert .. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) last week issued an official warning to investors on the risks of investing in crypto asset securities. It stated what has become blindingly obvious, that crypto investments are highly volatile and speculative and that the platforms that provide them may not have the necessary protections for investors. Additionally, companies offering crypto asset investments may not comply with federal securities laws. The SEC also urged investors to exercise a lot of caution when relying on Proof of Reserves, a method used by crypto asset entities to supposedly offer evidence that they have sufficient reserve assets to cover customers' balances.
The SEC emphasized the other undeniable point that registration by entities such as Registered Investment Advisors (RIAs, like Anglia Advisors) provides important protections for investors and, conversely, unregistered entities that deal in crypto have no such protections.
The meh-taverse .. Disney last week entirely shut down the internal division that was developing its metaverse strategies. Microsoft recently permanently closed down a social virtual-reality platform that it acquired to a big fanfare in 2017. Even Mark Zuckerberg, who not long ago bet the entire farm on the metaverse, recently cut several positions and projects in Meta/Facebook’s metaverse division and focused far more on artificial intelligence (AI) on the most recent earnings call last month during which the buzzword-mention score was: AI 28, metaverse 7.
Meanwhile, the price for virtual real estate in some online worlds, where users can hang out as avatars, has completely cratered - to the surprise of almost no-one inhabiting planet Earth. Apparently, the median sale price for land in Decentra-land (yes, there is such a virtual place!) has declined 90% from a year ago.
College isn’t worth the cost, say the majority of Americans .. A Wall Street Journal survey found that 56% of Americans now think earning a four-year bachelor’s degree is a bad financial bet, up from 40% in 2013 and a new low in confidence in the monetary value of a college education. There’s a significant divergence in respondents from different age groups and skepticism is strongest among people ages 18-34. Also, the opinions of people who themselves do hold college degrees have soured the most over the last decade.
UNDER THE HOOD ..
The technical state of the market is far more precarious than is implied by the increasingly positive market sentiment described above.
The “no-man’s land” I me…