It took just over two years, but we finally have ourselves another new all-time record closing high for the S&P 500 which was reached on Friday when the index closed at 4839.81. The U.S. stock market really is an incredible piece of work. Never in history has it ever once failed to recover from all of its losses, no matter how huge, and then go on to set yet another new record high. If you are investing for the long term, you need to bottle this moment and remember it the next time stocks are down large and everything seems hopeless.
After yet another long weekend, during which geopolitical tensions around the world continued to escalate and Trump won big in Iowa, Wall Street traders returned to the battlefield on Tuesday morning and were soon confronted by Fed Governor Christopher Waller saying that, while the state of the U.S. economy was “almost as good as it gets”, he was unconvinced that higher inflation had been killed and that fact could impede progress towards the frequent and extensive interest rate cuts that the market expects the Fed to provide, starting as early as March. Stocks glided lower, especially when officials from the European Central Bank (ECB) started making similar noises.
We learned on Wednesday that U.S. consumers in December kept on spending like drunken sailors. The Retail Sales data came in hot, up 0.6% from November’s spending and 5.6% higher than a year ago, providing more signs that the economy is continuing to grow and just adding to the “inflation is not dead”side of the ledger.
The probability of a Fed interest rate cut by March, which had been as high as over 80% as recently as the previous week and was basically a 100% certainty at the beginning of January, reacted by collapsing to pretty much that of a coin-flip.
Stocks dropped further in response and it’s not hard to figure out why. The high probability of at least one interest rate cut by March this year was a major contributor to the December melt-up and we’re seeing some of those gains being given back now that that particular probability is deemed to be much lower.
The skies brightened on Thursday, however, and all the stock indexes moved in a northerly direction, helped partly by a very optimistic outlook from Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing (TSM), which supplies chips to Apple and Nvidia. Also, the Senate passed yet another Continuing Resolution, atemporary spending bill to avert a partial U.S. government shutdown this weekend, which once again just kicks the can down the road, this time to March 1st (partial shutdown) and March 8th (lights out).
A calmer mood settled over markets on Friday with the sense that, yes, recent hot economic data readings might well defer interest rate cuts beyond initial expectations, but they also imply that whatever meaningful recession fears remain for 2024 may be unfounded and that can only be good for future corporate earnings.
After a sluggish start, stocks ripped higher after lunch on the back of this new interpretation of the Retail Sales numbers and also a buoyant-again tech sector which is helping to offset some of the growing caution elsewhere with a new burst of AI optimism following TSM’s earnings report, to erase the week’s losses and we finally reached a new all-time record closing high for the S&P 500. Hurrah!
Asset prices in the U.S. are priced for perfection in what is a very crowded trade and that’s a concern. Markets are still assuming that even if the Fed doesn’t cut on January 31st or March 20th, it will definitely cut on May 1st and that the current expectation of a total of at least six rate cuts in 2024 will, more or less, stay intact.
But we are getting closer to the wire whereby if the Fed doesn’t signal at least one interest rate cut either before or at the May meeting then markets could well freak out. No rate cuts through May will mean that Wall Street will have to accept that it is wrong about its aggressive expectations for Fed easing that underpinned the entire Q4 rally. Pull that punch bowl away and you could be looking at a 10-15% decline in stock prices or more.
From a market standpoint it doesn’t matter so much when the rate cuts start, as long as the expectation for a lot of policy easing (let’s call it > four interest rate cuts) remains intact. Ironically, a real risk for this market is that the Fed does exactly what it currently says it will do and only cuts two or, at a real stretch, three times.
So far, there is no budging on the expectations of a rate cut before or at the May meeting as they remain intact at a 100% probability. However, where that number goes, stocks also will go and, in some ways, this is the most important data point to keep track of right now. As long this probability remains at or very close to around 100%, stocks will be able to continue to move higher. But if doubt sets in and we see the reading fall to like 75% and continuing lower, then look out below.
Consequently, I am now adding tracking for the May meeting probability to this report each week (see FEDWATCH INTEREST RATE TOOL below).
OTHER NEWS ..
Home Sales Have Collapsed .. Sales of existing homes crashed last year to the lowest level in nearly three decades, after elevated mortgage rates and a lack of homes for sale shut out buyers. The number of existing home sales tumbled 19% in 2023 from the prior year to 4.09 million, the National Association of Realtors said on Friday. That total was lower than during the sub-prime crisis of 2007-08 and the lowest full-year level since Montell Jordan told us that this is how we do it in 1995.
After two years of soaring home sales that started during the pandemic as people sought more space and new locations, the housing market skidded to a halt in mid-2022 as rates began to rise again and the supply of homes for sale stalled at very low levels. But there are some signs of life as mortgage rates ease to their lowest levels since last May and it’s possible that last year represented a bottom for sales activity.
Recession Indicator? .. I don’t normally take too much notice of regional economic activity readings, but the New York Fed Manufacturing Index is prized by some as an early tip-off each month on where the manufacturing sector in the country as a whole is heading. The sight of this index dropping deep into negative terrain for January – a truly horrible reading and the lowest since the COVID was raging in the Spring of 2020 – convinced some observers to warn that the jig is up and a US recession is now near. Maybe, but it’s hard to make a high-confidence call based on one indicator, especially when it is one regional manufacturing indicator that draws only on survey data from manufacturing executives in the NY Fed’s district.
Remember When Chinese Stocks Were Supposed To Be The Future? .. Chinese shares sank to the lowest in nearly five years after another bout of weak economic data. The largest brokerage in China is said to have suspended short selling for some clients in mainland markets following the rout in Chinese stocks at the start of the year. State-owned Citic Securities made the move after so-called window guidance from regulators. A Hong Kong gauge of Chinese stocks has notched up its worst week since March, while global passive funds are adding to the pressure by joining in with the selloff in another sign of deteriorating investor confidence.
UNDER THE HOOD ..
The market’s primary uptrend appears intact, although recent increased selectivity in Demand favoring Large Caps makes markets increasingly vulnerable to another short-term dip in prices. This phenomenon should not perhaps be unexpected as it was Small Caps that led the charge in those turbo-charged final weeks of 2023.
The number of S&P 500 stocks trading above their 50-day and 200-day moving averages declined modestly last week (see below) despite the continued gains and a new record in the index at the same time. At this time, this is not an alarming drop in the measures of market breadth, …