We will all have to wait at least a little while longer for that new all-time record high in the S&P 500 index. Despite teasing us at times during what was a very subdued week, stock prices never quite got high enough to break the record closing level of 4796.56 achieved almost exactly two years ago on January 3rd 2022. This was the first time since 2012 that the S&P 500 had failed to close at a record high at least once during the year, but the index still earned a total return for 2023 of almost 27%.
Wall Street traders came back from the long weekend filled with Christmas cheer on Tuesday, pushing stocks higher again - albeit in a thin volume environment that allowed for prices to drift upwards without needing much conviction behind the move other than just continuing momentum fueled by the fumes of a very impressive last couple of months. The S&P 500 index got to within 25 points of its previous record high.
There was really nothing to report from Wednesday’s snoozer of a session. Stocks spent the day treading water, inching slightly higher but left us still waiting to launch the confetti for that new record high.
Thursday was not much different, a rock bottom-volume journey to nowhere (only two-thirds of the annual daily average number of shares changed hands) with the indexes finishing unchanged on the day and still short of that new all-time record territory.
Stocks sank on the final trading day of the year on Friday, led downwards by the brightest stars of the recent boom, tech and Small Caps. The S&P 500 briefly got to within nine points of its elusive magic number, but ended the day, month, quarter and year at around 4770. Santa Claus departed for another year and there are a few concerns that he may have taken his rally with him.
Typically, the price action in the week before Christmas and then the week between Christmas and New Year can be considered as just noise and not particularly instructive or predictive of anything that’ll move markets in the upcoming year. But I do think that this time we are seeing an excessive amount of complacency and giddy optimism over the festive period and a quickly developing very high-conviction view from Wall Street that corporate earnings are going to look really good in 2024. And really, what is the recent track record of the end of year narrative? It’s not good.
In December 2021, there was universal optimism for the year ahead. Then the S&P 500 hit a new all-time record high on the first trading day of 2022, but it was all downhill from there. The consensus for 2022 was entirely bullish .. and entirely wrong. The Fed was much more aggressive than expected on rate hikes, inflation exploded, growth slowed and the S&P 500 dropped 20%. The stock price of Amazon and Nvidia got cut in half over the course of the year, while Alphabet/Google fell 40% and Meta/Facebook crashed 65%. Meantime, unprofitable tech (the likes of Zoom, Peloton and others) got absolutely annihilated, with shareholders watching their investments lose 80-90% of their value in many cases.
Now, think back a year to December 2022. Investors were despondent and miserable. The S&P 500 was ending the worst year in over a decade and bonds had just experienced pretty much their worst year ever. Thoughtfully constructed, balanced portfolios had taken a beating like never before. The Fed was incessantly hiking interest rates at every meeting, inflation wasn’t breaking and everyone (and I mean, everyone) was convinced that we were facing an imminent recession. The consensus for 2023 was entirely bearish .. and once again entirely wrong. Growth and earnings remained resilient, inflation was broken and the Fed pivoted to a more accommodative stance. Those same stocks that had had the crap kicked out of them in 2022 led the way higher in 2023 which ended up being a bonanza year for the indexes.
Now, in December 2023, the consensus is universally bullish again. Investors seem to passionately believe that an economic soft landing in 2024 is all but assured. The Fed will cut interest rates six times next year, but not because of slowing growth and instead because inflation is about to go into some sort of free-fall. Despite there being numerous geopolitical hot spots, none of them will get materially worse. U.S. politics won’t be a problem (even though it’s an election year and there’s no debt ceiling solution in sight) and despite a potentially slowing economy and margin compression, companies in the S&P 500 will grow earnings by nearly 10% this year. The 5000 mark on the S&P 500 isn’t a matter of “if” , but “when”.
All of those things may well come true. It might be exactly how 2024 works out. It’s just that we need to watch for warning signs that it isn’t and probably brace ourselves for some volatility if that turns out to be the case, since so much of this good news is already baked into the current level of stock prices, leaving markets highly vulnerable to any disappointment.
The plain fact is that there are real, legitimate risks lurking out there in the new year. We can still have a growth slowdown and a recession. Earnings growth can falter as demand slows and margins compress. Geopolitics can easily worsen from here, providing negative surprises, sometimes seemingly out of nowhere. Inflation could bounce back. And around the world, but especially in the U.S., there are going to be elections in 2024 that will be highly consequential and maybe brutally contested (both before and after polling day).
We can expect markets to normalize this week and immediately get to work answering some of these pretty important questions about economic growth, actual vs. expected Fed policy and corporate earnings.
Stay with me in 2024 and I’ll try and make some sense of things for you as we go along. Meantime have a safe, healthy and happy New Year!
OTHER NEWS ..
In such a zzzzzzzzzzzz week, finding any interesting “other news” was pretty challenging. Normal service will be resumed next week.
On the plus side, my latest Quarterly Market Review looking back on financial markets in Q4 2023 should be completed and sent to subscribers by sometime in the middle of this coming week. Keep an eye on your email inbox.
UNDER THE HOOD ..
Five technical caution signals that I will be watching for in 2024 that could indicate a market top and act as warning signs for a possible reversal in stock prices (which could still be months or quarters away if they come about) ..
1) Market Breadth.
Participation is often one of the first things to fall away in an equity bull market so if the number of stocks trading above their long term moving average starts to meaningfully decline, that can be an early warning signal of a potential reversal. You can track this reading each week in this report, see % OF S&P 500 STOCKS TRADING ABOVE THEIR LONG TERM MOVING AVERAGE below.
2) Investor Sentiment.
Overly bullish or optimistic sentiment is consistent with a crowded long side of the market and typically precedes market peaks. So a divergence between the broader stock market (still moving higher) and sentiment (beginning to fall) would be a notable caution signal for stocks. You can track sentiment each week in this report, see both the WEEKLY US INVESTOR SENTIMENTand theFEAR & GREED INDEX below.
3) Treasury Bill Yields.
Futures are pricing in a March rate cut which is now less than three months away, however the 3-month Treasury Bill yield held steady at between 5.40% and 5.45% for all of December. If we do not see the 3-Month Bill yield begin to move down towards 5% in the coming days and weeks, that will be a negative development for stocks. You can track the state of the yield curve each week in this report, see US TREASURY INTEREST RATE YIELD CURVE below.
4) The CME’s Fed Watch Tool.
This is largely a continuation of the previous point, but if the Fed Watch Tool begins to show less rate cuts or rapidly fading odds of a March rate cut (currently 87%), that could be a major headwind for stocks…