Listen

Description

February delivered a reality check to investors after a giddy January; the S&P 500 fell 2.6% for the month and the NASDAQ dropped 1.1%.

Stock and bond prices had risen impressively in January on the ideas that i) Inflation was declining, ie., disinflation, ii) the Fed was almost done with rate hikes and iii) there wasn’t going be a hard economic landing (ie., we were going to get inflation conquered without a recession). At least two of those three ideas are now pretty much considered off the table right now as a result of the data of the past three weeks. That’s why stocks gave back more than half of 2023’s gains.

Since the start of this interest rate hiking cycle a year ago, the market has proved to be consistently over-enthusiastic in pricing in an end to Fed rate rises, taking any hint of a drop in inflation or slowing growth and extrapolating it out to be some catalyst that will cause the Fed to back off.

That expectation has been proved wrong every single time so far and my default position is to remain rather skeptical of these rallies (even if the stock market isn’t) until we see more tangible progress on persistent disinflation, a gently cooling economy and - most importantly - a clear and believable expression from the Fed that an end to interest rate increases is imminent. We certainly aren’t there yet.

Analyst talk last week revolved around the often-dangerous idea of TTID (“This Time It’s Different”). The thinking goes that the consequences of the COVID pandemic permanently transformed the economic landscape and that the Fed may be applying olden timey rules to a new, altered economy by assuming that it could accomplish all it wants simply by raising interest rates to beat off inflation. This is what has caused the professional forecasting community to be almost continually wrong since the beginning of 2020 about the the path of the US economy, the level and duration of inflation and the direction of interest rate policy.

For example, the TTID narrative goes, the vast majority of existing homeowners aren’t going to change their spending (and therefore their contribution to the inflation rate) as the Fed raises interest rates, since they have a 30-year fixed mortgage, likely refinanced around 3% or less and don’t care what a new mortgage costs. Many households have been flush with COVID stimulus money and did not necessarily respond as the dusty old economic textbooks from the 1950s say they should have done to a rising rate environment.

If the TTID truthers are correct, it could be that in order to accomplish their stated goal of bringing inflation back down towards 2% again, recent economic strength and these new debt dynamics could mean the Fed has to work even harder, tightening policy even more harshly and for longer at a level that is absolutely not yet priced in to stocks with the S&P 500 around 4000.

Having said all that, markets ended last week higher as focus shifted temporarily at least from inflation and interest rate concerns to corporate news and earnings reports, which were mixed but generally on the positive side.

Target (TGT) reported better-than-expected earnings, but future guidance was set lower. The retail firm, considered a good proxy for the retail sector as a whole, provided a bright outlook for the overall industry as it said that inventory issues were improving, contracting 3% year-over-year in Q4 2022. However, it also reiterated that the environment remains challenging and that pre-pandemic operating margins are not likely to be recognized before fiscal year 2024 at the earliest.

Last week’s Fed-speak was a little confusing and contradictory. Federal Reserve Bank of Boston President Susan Collins said interest rates must move quickly higher and remain restrictive for some time to bring inflation growth back under control. But at the same time, Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta President Raphael Bostic said he favors using smaller interest rate adjustments (read: 0.25% at a time) to fine-tune monetary policy and thinks rate hikes could well pause by mid-summer.

Nevertheless, the futures market is showing a quite extraordinary about-turn in professional sentiment about what is going to happen to interest rates (see FEDWATCH TOOL, below) and it doesn’t make pleasant reading for those who like to roll the dice on owning low/no-profit young tech or communications sector growth names for whom higher interest rates are kryptonite.

The odds of a half-percent hike instead of a quarter at the next Fed meeting later this month continue to rise, now reaching 31%, from literally 0% a month ago. Fedwatch also shows that there is basically no-one left who thinks interest rates will be below 5% at the end of the year compared to a 90% perceived chance of this just a month ago.

The probability of rates being at or above 5.25% on New Year’s Eve 2023 is now almost 70%. A month ago, that probability was priced at less than 1%.

OTHER NEWS ..

Closing the Silvergate? .. Incredible scenes last week at the top crypto bank Silvergate (SI), the biggest platform used by cryptocurrency holders to make transfers, which said it was “postponing” the release of its latest annual report and admitted that it was under multiple investigations by the Justice Department. As a result, key partners like Coinbase, Galaxy, Paxos and other crypto firms (hardly Hall of Famers themselves when it comes to good behavior, stability and transparency) decided to stop accepting or initiating Silvergate payments.

The share price plummeted 60% on Thursday alone to a record low of below $6.00 (that’s down over 97% from the high it made near the end of 2021) after the company essentially questioned its own viability, pretty much waving the white flag.

Silvergate reported a $1 billion loss for Q4 2022 and said it expects to record massive further losses related to its securities portfolio after selling additional debt to cover withdrawals. The bank still holds more than $11 billion of client money.

Short sellers and analysts have been banging on for ages about the enormous risks associated with almost all of Silvergate’s client base being unregulated entities, often incompetently run and exposed recently in many cases as being involved in fraud and criminal activity. The rest of the world seems to have finally caught up.

Analysts all over Wall Street slashed their ratings on Silvergate and Morgan Stanley, which had had a sell rating on the stock, even removed its price target entirely, citing the “high level of uncertainty” around the firm.

This looks like an old-fashioned “run on the bank” (see EXPLAINER: FINANCIAL TERM OF THE WEEK, below) and these always end in tears.

This was accompanied by worrying concerns about Tether expressed in a Wall Street Journal exposé last week and on the back of release of the fascinating investigative podcast, Real Money. Tether is the company behind the largest crypto “stablecoin” that claims (without a great deal of verifiable evidence, it would seem) to hold enough funds to be able to maintain a one-for-one peg to a proper currency such as the US Dollar or the Euro in order to facilitate the buying and selling of cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, Ethereum and the rest.

The whole crypto eco-system feels distinctly unstable right now.

Still falling .. Home prices fell at the end of 2022 as high mortgage rates and concerns about the economy impacted the real estate market. The National Home Price Index showed home prices fell 0.3% in December after seasonal adjustment, and were up 5.8% from a year ago. It was the sixth consecutive month of declines, putting the index 4.4% below its June peak. Prices dropped in all of the 20 cities analyzed by S&P, falling by a median of 1.1%.  

On an annualized basis, the cities with the biggest price gains are Miami (+15.9%), Tampa (+13.9%), and Atlanta (+10.4%). Prices fell over the last twelve months in San Francisco (-4.2%) and Seattle (-1.8%). 

Mortgage rates rose for the fourth week in a row, dampening the…



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit simonbrady.substack.com