For the first three days of last week, the market’s price action felt a bit like a head-thumping hangover the morning after the month-long bender that was November. Then on Friday we got a very Goldilocks Jobs Report which sent prices spiraling upwards again and the S&P 500 had managed to squeak out a new 2023 high by Friday’s close.
A majority of S&P 500 stocks moved higher on Monday,but the index fell - dragged lower for once by the so-called Magnificent Seven (Apple, Microsoft, Alphabet/Google, Nvidia, Meta/Facebook, Amazon and Tesla) all of whom fell by more than 1% for the session.
A narrative developed, bolstered by some of the talking-head types on CNBC and Bloomberg TV, that maybe the expectations of when and by how much the Fed will begin cutting interest rates may be the teeny-tiniest bit over-optimistic and that when the Fed loudly insists that it will not go on a drunken, indiscriminate rate-slashing spree in the first half of 2024, there’s at least a small chance that they might actually mean it.
On Tuesday, we learned from the latest Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS) that the number of job openings in the US dropped to 8.73 million in October, down from September's 9.55 million, the lowest level since March 2021 and well below the expectation of 9.40 million. Bond yields responded by coming down sharply with the 10 year Treasury interest rate, which had been over 5.0% as recently as October, falling below 4.2%. The S&P 500 index ticked lower again but most of the Magnificent Seven came right back, reversing Monday’s losses.
Wednesday saw another moderate drift lower in stock prices, completing a three-day losing streak for the first time in over a month. Indexes were driven lower partly by their energy-related components as the oil price dipped below $70 on excess supply concerns and a continuing sense that November’s meteoric rise in stocks may just have been overdone and that the upside from here could be more limited as a result.
Artificial Intelligence re-emerged as a market influence on Thursday as both Google and AMD announced new AI-related initiatives. There’s absolutely nothing 2023’s stock market loves more than even a sniff of a mention of anything to do with AI and all the indexes shifted higher, bringing the short losing streak to an end in the lead-up to the all-important Jobs Report the following day.
It landed before the market open on Friday. Payrolls rose 199k in the month, a little above estimates. The unemployment rate fell to 3.7%, below all forecasts and a four-month low as well as extending an historic 22-month stretch in which it has remained below 4% — the longest since Neil Diamond first let us know that good times never felt so good as they did with Caroline in 1969.
The combination of last week’s two big labor market reports keeps current interest rate expectations (no more hikes, cuts coming up pretty soon) in place and did not imply a loss of momentum. In other words, it didn’t really move the needle much and keeps the soft landing thesis very much on the table. We also got a consumer sentiment reading that soared higher as Americans grow more and more confident about where the economy is heading. Stocks moved higher on the back of this feast of good news.
Generally speaking, once Thanksgiving is in the rear view mirror, market participants simply want the year to end quietly, with no surprises and perhaps a few decent gains. The net result is that markets tend to temporarily ignore any data or commentary that might jeopardize the gains (assuming it’s not too bad) and embrace any data or commentary that pushes the bullish narrative, into year-end. I think we are in the midst of that right now, as shown by the bubbly reaction to a couple of AI stories and some pretty good, but hardly sensational, labor market news.
Once this peculiar period ends and January gets under way, things tend to normalize again. What will that normalization look like in early 2024? I think it is all less complex than it seems and will mostly be about expectation vs. actual facts.
Put very simply, if actual facts about economic/inflation data, earnings, bond yields and Fed interest rate policy turn out better than market assumptions, stocks will likely rally. If the actual facts disappoint compared to market assumptions - particularly if the baked-in idea of early rate cuts does not come to pass - then stocks will probably drop, maybe quite hard.
OTHER NEWS ..
Dow Left Behind in 2023 ..Sharp-eyed subscribers will have noticed that, while I frequently refer to indexes like the S&P 500, the NASDAQ and the Russell 2000 in my reports, I do not ever talk about the media’s favorite index, the Dow Jones Industrial Average. That’s because it’s a stupid index. It also hasn’t under-performed the far-superior S&P 500 by this much at any time since the end of the century.
While focusing on one year’s worth of performance data and drawing big conclusions is never a good idea (see ARTICLE OF THE WEEK below) it’s still interesting to note that the olden-timey classic Dow gauge of market performance is up only 10% this year, half that of its big S&P brother, whose 2023 performance itself is only half that of the NASDAQ-100. The biggest reason? The much heavier tech and communications services presence in the S&P 500's and especially the NASDAQ-100’s composition.
Why bother? .. The useless end-of-2024 predictions for the S&P 500 keep coming in. Their record of accuracy is rubbish. For the last five completed years, the prediction vs. actual outcome error ranged from 26% too low to 21% too high. On average, the median annual estimate was off by about 18 percentage points! That’s nearly double the index’s long-term average annual return. Please don’t take any notice of this stuff.
Like A Bad Smell .. Meme stock favorite and nonsense company GameStop came back into our consciousness last week. The good news for the “diamond hands” shareholders who bought in using their Robin Hood accounts during the pandemic, slurped all the Reddit-fueled Kool Aid and held on is that the stock surged 20% on Thursday alone. It’s also up 30% since Thanksgiving. The not-so-good news is that it is also still down more than 82% from its high in 2021.
Three Trill .. Shares of the technology giant Apple rose to close the week at $195.72 which put its market capitalization at over the $3 trillion level (that’s $3,000,000,000,000) and was its highest close since its all-time high in back in July.
UNDER THE HOOD ..
Buying Power’s path of least resistance remains to the upside after having reached new multi-month highs in recent days. However, Selling Pressure has a tendency to strengthen as indexes reach new high-water marks, such as the new 2023 high experienced by the S&P 500 last week. Sometimes the sellers only stick around for a short while, but it does make continued price acceleration harder.
Selectivity is still apparent, favoring Large Cap stocks, but buyers are beginning to find new targets in the Mid Cap and Small Cap space, narrowing the Large/Small gap. While core technical indicators still have work to do to erase negative divergences in place since July, a continuation of this recent resurgence in smaller stocks, thanks to their larger numbers, will be crucial for market-wide improvements in Demand and a sustained intermediate-term advance.
Anglia Advisors clients are welcome to reach out to me to discuss market conditions further.
THIS WEEK’S UPCOMING CALENDAR ..
This week is the last big one of the year when it comes to data, headlined by the Federal Reserve's December rate meeting with a decision due on Wednesday afternoon. The market overwhelmingly expects it to keep the Federal Funds rate steady at a target range of 5.25%-5.50%.
Attention will be on Chairman Jerome Powell's press conference that afternoon and on the Federal Open Market Committee's latest quarterly so-called “Dot Plot”, the Fed officials' latest projections for the economy and the mem…