It was a quiet week, so let’s take the opportunity to zoom out a bit, look at the bigger picture and see where we stand in the ongoing saga of this bear market ..
There wasn’t too much to take from a choppy, vacation-shortened week with increasingly thin attendance and extremely low volume (see EXPLAINER: FINANCIAL TERM OF THE WEEK as well as UNDER THE HOOD below) ahead of and right after the Thanksgiving holiday.
We got the minutes from the last Fed meeting earlier this month which raised interest rates by 0.75% and they clearly showed that a substantial majority of those present judged that a slowing in the pace of rate increases “would likely soon be appropriate” and it was noted that some participants expressed concerns about the potential negative impacts on the financial system if the Fed continued to pursue its aggressive rate-hiking policy at the current high-octane pace.
This appeared to confirm the momentum that seems to be building among investors that the Fed will indeed slow the pace of tightening as soon as at its next meeting in early December and is now not far from its terminal rate (the Fed Funds rate on the day that they announce the end to interest rate increases).
We also saw some strong quarterly earnings reports from retailers. Best Buy (BBY) posted solid Q3 results and raised its 2022 final sales projection. Dick’s Sporting Goods (DKS), Abercrombie & Fitch (ANF) and American Eagle Outfitters (AEO) also gave upbeat outlooks.
What the market needs to see is slowing but not collapsing economic growth and a tangible downward shift in inflation and that is a nice segue to a quick review of our ongoing Three Keys To A Market Bottom.
* Key #1: Inflation clearly peaks and then declines and the Fed openly pulls back from its current hawkish stance. This is by far the most important key of all when it comes to finding a bottom to this bear market. If inflation can get back down into the 3%-5% area, that will probably make the Fed back off the hawkish rhetoric, likely resulting in a sustainable bottom in stocks. Based on the most recent data, inflation does now appear to have peaked in the US and that obviously needed to happen before we can hope for progress on the remaining two fronts (meaningfully declining inflation and peak Fed hawkishness) although neither of those appear that imminent. Where are we now? A step in the right direction, but a lot further to go.
* Key #2: Chinese lockdowns ease and growth resumes. Over the past few weeks Chinese officials have signaled there will be substantive changes to COVID policies, including more targeted lockdowns that don’t paralyze entire cities, shorter quarantine times for international travelers and the importation of proper COVID vaccines, among others. While we are not expecting to hear an explicit declaration that China will abandon its Zero-COVID policy, a process of moving away from that policy has clearly begun. It will, however, take a good amount of time for the Chinese economy to return to a pre-COVID normal. Where are we now? Notwithstanding some reported outbreaks and sporadic lockdowns last week, movement towards this goal is definitely under way.
* Key #3: Geopolitical tensions decline. Positively, global commodity prices have fallen - but these declines haven’t been the result of reduced geopolitical tensions. Instead, it’s been the result of the commodities markets pricing in the rising chances of a global recession. Regarding geopolitics, we have seen some progress over the past month, in spite of the Poland rocket story. “Diplomatic chatter” about working to find a ceasefire has definitively increased over the past weeks, with Russian, Ukrainian and US officials all making guardedly positive comments about potential talks, which is noticeable improvement over the situation a while back, when there appeared to be no chance that would materialize. Where are we now? More hopeful than for a very long time, although it should be emphasized that nothing has actually happened yet.
The overall macro takeaway from these Three Keys is net positive in terms of the direction in which things are going but less so, perhaps, when it comes to the pace of progress. There’s still an awful lot of work to do, but the last time we took a hard look at these keys in late summer/early fall, the outlook was far more dismal on all fronts.
There’s still an ongoing drumbeat of other factors in the background, of course. Not least the ongoing and increasingly jaw-dropping story of the collapse of the FTX crypto exchange.
Last week we learned from FTX’s own lawyer that a “substantial amount” of the company’s assets is “missing”, very possibly stolen. He said that FTX had been under the control of “inexperienced and unsophisticated individuals, some or all of whom were compromised individuals” - clearly pointing the finger squarely at Sam Bankman-Fried, the former man-crush of crypto bros everywhere, now cowering in his luxury apartment in the Bahamas awaiting the inevitable and long overdue knock on the door from the authorities. The trademark scruffy t-shirts and ripped jeans could well be replaced soon by an orange jump suit.
Venture capital firm Sequoia Capital came out and apologized to investors for its $150 million loss on FTX and vowed to “improve its due diligence” before making such risky investments in the future. Now there’s a revolutionary idea!
As the terrific Jason Zweig of the Wall Street Journal put it;
“In good times, when markets are booming, taking stupid risks doesn't stop you from getting rich quick; if anything, it can even help. But if you want to get rich slowly and stay rich reliably, you have to learn to avoid taking stupid risks.
That's what down markets are for. They don't just separate people from their money. They also separate people into those who learn from mistakes and those who don't.”
OTHER NEWS
US retirement balances lower .. A study from Fidelity found the average 401(k) balance fell to $97,200 in Q3, down 6% from the prior quarter and 23% lower than a year ago. The average 403b balance was 6% lower than it was at the end of June and 21% lower year-over-year. The average IRA balance was $101,900, an 8% drop from Q2 and a 25% decline from 2021.
Now investors are pulling out of the housing market as well.. Investor buying of homes crashed by 30% in Q3, a sign that the toxic combination of the rise in interest rates and high home prices that pushed traditional buyers to the sidelines are causing these investment firms to pull back, too. Companies bought around 66k homes in 40 tracked markets during Q3, compared with 94k homes during the same quarter a year ago. This is the largest quarterly decline in investor purchases since the sub-prime crisis of 2007/2008, other the freak second quarter of 2020 when the pandemic shut down most home buying.
Just a few months ago, these firms were buying homes in record numbers, helping to supercharge the housing market. Now, investors are reducing their buying activity in line with the decline in overall home sales.
Recession in earnings? Not so much .. Company executives may be talking about recession risks a lot these days. But if you look at what they're actually doing, things look a little different. The nation's biggest firms reported record capital expenditure (investments in buildings, new machinery or technology).
But company borrowing has slowed on the back of higher interest rates, which suggests that while companies continue to invest at a brisk pace, they might not be borrowing as much to do so. Rather, they are relying on booming profits built up in recent years.
So while whether or not the economy will fall into recession at some point may remain up for debate, there is clearly no recession right now in company earnings. Cash flow levels are very healthy.
UNDER THE HOOD:
We are now witnessing a significant divergence between the macro-economic and conventional messaging (see above) and the under the hood market technicals.…