Listen

Description

Those of us hoping for a clearer picture to emerge from the release of the January’s Consumer Price Index (CPI) measure of retail inflation and other subsequent data were left sorely disappointed last week. If anything, things just became more confused.

Stocks drifted nicely higher on Monday as traders laid their bets ahead of the high-stakes inflation reports that would start arriving the following morning.

When CPI came out pre-market on Tuesday, it showed that consumer prices rose at a more rapid monthly pace in January, interrupting a months-long streak of cooler month-to-month readings. Prices rose 0.5% last month, as what we paid for shelter, food, energy and apparel in particular accelerated at a more rapid pace. In the twelve months through January 2023, inflation was 6.4%, compared to 6.5% in December and above the expectation of 6.2%. Core CPI, which excludes the food and fuel prices, rose by 0.4% in January, unchanged from December’s pace for a slightly lower annualized rate of 5.6%.

Then on Thursday, we learned that the Producer Price Index (PPI) measure of wholesale inflation felt by manufacturers for January rose 0.7%, more than the expected 0.4% and is up 6% year-over-year, down from the 6.5% rate in December. Excluding food, energy, and trade services, the year-on-year Core PPI was up 4.5%, easing slightly from the month before. 

On the surface, the reports looked to be saying that inflation was running mildly hotter. But looking deeper, you can see that a highly disproportionate portion of the retail price gains were attributable to housing. This was initially interpreted as a positive thing, since pricing there tends to react slower than other parts of the economy, meaning already-existing recent rate hikes may have yet to be felt and might not need to be added to. On the wholesale side, the Core PPI number still looks somewhat promising, although it wasn’t quite as warm and fuzzy as it was perhaps expected to be.

Simply put, these numbers tell us that inflation is still declining, but that the pace of that decline is slowing.

In a sign that US consumers are still willing to spend like crazy even as prices and interest rates rise, the Commerce Department's report showed that Retail Sales surprisingly surged 3.0% in January, way above the estimates of a 1.8% increase and almost 3x the rate of increase seen in the normally buoyant month of December.

Paired with the (also quite stunning) recent January jobs report from the Friday before, the retail sales number gave yet another indication that the US economy is proving to be massively more resilient to inflation and interest rate increases than anyone ever expected, which on one hand is great for stocks but on the other hand gives the Fed the green light to just keep on lifting and holding rates until it inflicts some real damage.

Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland president Loretta Mester and St. Louis president Jim Bullard both raised eyebrows on Thursday, each separately expressing the opinion that there had been a strong case for a 0.50% hike at the last Fed meeting, rather than the 0.25% that the committee actually went for (neither Mester nor Bullard are voting members of the rate-setting committee any more) and introducing the possibility of a full 0.50% bump in the upcoming March meeting (see my new feature; FEDWATCH TOOL, below). They also both strongly pushed back on the idea of any interest rate cuts this year.

Creaking under the weight of all this mixed economic data and hawkish Fed-speak, the stock market took a day or so to digest it all and then finally decided that it didn’t really like what it saw and headed lower, led by the energy sector which had a bad week.

The interest rate market, however, was much quicker to sour on the data and futures market wagers on where interest rates will be at the end of the year are finally starting to mirror the Fed’s most recent forecasts of above 5%. Just a month ago, this probability was priced at just 2% by the futures market. By the end of last week, it was up to 69% and fast becoming consensus (see my new feature; FEDWATCH TOOL, below). The rebellious teenager from my report of a couple of weeks back is grudgingly starting to listen to the parent.

There was a clear narrative coming into 2023: The Federal Reserve had spent months pushing interest rates rapidly higher at a historic pace in a bid to tame inflation and those moves would slow growth and the labor market so much that the economy would be at risk of plunging into a nasty recession.

The worries about inflation aren't going away. But the growl of a recession is becoming increasingly distant, despite what is being loudly shouted by eight months now of an inverted yield curve, where short term interest rates are higher than long term ones, which is traditionally a strong sign of imminent recession.

Employers added more than half a million jobs in January, the housing market is starting to show some signs of stabilizing or even picking back up, Americans are still spending money like water and many Wall Street economists and analysts have marked down the odds of a harmful recession this year.

After months of asking whether or not the Fed could pull off a “soft landing” (see EXPLAINER: FINANCIAL TERM OF THE WEEK below) in which the economy slows but does not plummet, the trendy new narrative is that there may not be any landing at all, soft or hard, for a few months — that growth will simply hold up until it finally decides to either accelerate or fall off a cliff.

Growth is the critical factor here that is currently propping up the stock market. It needs to stay strong because if stocks have to confront slowing growth alongside interest rates where they are, then risk asset prices will drop, likely very sharply.

OTHER NEWS ..

The strange math of stocks .. If you had bought shares of the troubled online used car retailer Carvana at the start of this year, you’d be up 170% by now. If you had bought them a year ago, even after that 2023 spike, you’d still be down by over 91%.

Trillions .. Americans assumed a record amount of debt at the end of 2022. The Federal Reserve Bank of New York’s quarterly report on household debt and credit found that in Q4 2022, overall household debt in the US rose by almost $400 billion or 2.4% to $17 trillion (that’s $17,000,000,000,000).

Credit card debt jumped over $60 billion to an all-time high of almost $1 trillion. Mortgage balances grew by a quarter of a trillion dollars to $12 trillion, up almost $1 trillion from 2021. Debt on auto and student loans also increased, lifting total non-housing balances by $126 billion. 

The bank noted that the share of current debt becoming delinquent rose again for almost all types of borrowing. That came after two years of historically low delinquencies.

The reason for these increased delinquencies is said to be inflation combined with the Fed’s effort to get it under control. While low unemployment has kept consumer finances generally strong, stubbornly high prices and climbing interest rates are now testing some borrowers’ ability to repay their debts. The Fed added that the data show particular signs of stress among younger borrowers who are starting to miss some credit card and auto loan payments at a much higher rate. 

Another bro icon charged with fraud .. Tearful crypto bros will have to take down yet another poster of one of their heroes from their bedroom walls. After having to terminate their man-crush on FTX’s disgraced Sam Bankman Fried, they now have to resign themselves to the realization of what everyone else kinda figured out last year, that Do Kwon was also a lying fraud. The founder of collapsed cryptocurrencies TerraUSD and Luna and his company bilked investors who purchased billions of dollars’ worth of the digital assets, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) said.

The SEC filed a civil fraud lawsuit against Do Kwon and Singapore-based Terraform Labs in Manhattan federal court, accusing them of d…



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit simonbrady.substack.com