The week and the month began with investors shifting their attention away from March's banking turmoil and back to the risk of a recession that could drag down consumer spending, thereby corporate profits and thereby stock prices. And the holiday-shortened week provided plenty for them to focus on.
Unexpected output cuts from the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC, see EXPLAINER: FINANCIAL TERM OF THE WEEK below) were announced on Monday after oil prices dipped in March amid the banking stress and fears over the global economic outlook.
Unsurprisingly, oil prices and oil stocks soared to start the quarter’s first trading day, as did the odds of another quarter point hike by the Federal Reserve next month. That’s because higher oil prices is a potential blow in the Fed’s battle against inflation, a fight it had looked to be slowly winning.
The White House got very grumpy about the move. It was apparently made clear through diplomatic channels that, given the cost of living issues in the US and broad market uncertainty, it considered this production cut as “ill-advised”.
Pretty much all the economic data released before the big one (the Jobs Report on Friday) implied that the economy isn't just lifting its foot off the gas pedal, it may now be stomping on the brakes.
The US manufacturing activity index fell to 46.3, to its lowest level since it completely collapsed back in those frightening dark days of May 2020. Numbers below 50 indicate contraction and by this index, manufacturing has now been contracting for four straight months. The overall reading has fallen to this level only sixteen other times in the index’s history dating back to 1948. In twelve of those sixteen instances, the economy was either already in a recession or fell into one shortly after.
Employers seem to be finally pulling back from their breakneck, hire-at-all-costs approach of 2022. The Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS) for February showed a very sharp 632k decline in job openings to a much lower total of 9.93 million with declines across all industries and sectors. Estimates had been for 10.45 million openings. This represents over 2 million fewer job openings than there were a year ago. For context, however, the pre-pandemic record-ever high in job openings was around 7.5 million. Another example of how the pandemic broke data.
We also learned that service industry expansion was coming to a screeching halt and that factory orders were disappointing.
The market seemed somewhat confused and appeared unsure which way to react. There was push-me/pull-you pressure being exerted on stock prices from two distinctly different camps.
The optimists’ case was that all this recession-pointing data took a lot of pressure off the Fed to keep raising rates and that the absolute worst case for the next meeting in early May would be one final quarter of a point hike (71% probability, see FEDWATCH TOOL below) but with a pause and no increase at all still very much on the table (29% probability). Good for stocks.
However, an increasingly common narrative is that it’s economic data, not the banking situation and not the Fed, that will mostly determine whether the next 10%-15% move in the S&P 500 is higher or lower.
That’s because the major unknown for investors is whether the economy falls into a recession or not. It’s not how much more the Fed hikes rates (we know it’s not much more, if at all), and it’s not whether the government will rescue depositors in the case of other regional bank failures (we pretty much know that they will).
On that basis, the pessimists’ case is that bad news about the economy is now simply bad news which means likely lower corporate earnings and less tolerance for risk by investors. Bad for stocks.
We then had the rather strange and unusual situation on Friday of the all-important Jobs Report coming out at 8:30am ET on a day when the stock market was closed for a holiday and therefore unable to immediately react.
Payrolls grew by 236k in March, totally in line with estimates and below the upwardly-revised 326k in February. The unemployment rate somewhat surprisingly ticked lower to 3.5% and average hourly earnings rose 0.3%, pushing the year-on-year increase to 4.2%, the lowest level for that reading since June 2021.
Although still elevated by historic standards, this increase in jobs was the smallest of the entire post-pandemic economic recovery and definitely appeared to fall into a “Goldilocks” sweet spot of not too hot (which could embolden the Fed to definitely keep raising rates) and not too cold (stark evidence of a recession).
OTHER NEWS ..
Layoffs soaring .. US employers have recently dealt with higher borrowing costs and moved to reduce expenses by increasingly laying off staff, according to executive coaching firm Challenger, Gray & Christmas.
US employers announced 89k job cuts last month alone, a 15% increase from February and a rise of over 300% compared to March 2022, continuing a trend seen all year so far. For Q1 2023, layoff announcements skyrocketed by almost 400% from Q1 2022.
Technology workers have been the hardest hit, with 38% of all layoffs so far this year coming from that sector. Over 100k employees have been laid off from tech firms so far in 2023, a massive jump from the same period last year.
Poor reward .. The reward offered for owning stocks over bonds hasn’t been this small since before the 2008 financial crisis. This reward is known as the Equity Risk Premium (ERP); the gap between the S&P 500’s earnings yield and that of the 10-year Treasury Bond currently sits at around 1.6 percentage points, a low not seen since now-notorious convicted crypto shiller Soulja Boy first suggested that we crank that in 2007. That is well below the average gap of around 3.5 percentage points since then.
The reduction is a potential challenge for stocks going forward. Owning stocks needs to promise a meaningfully higher reward than owning bonds over the long term. Otherwise, taking the higher risk of owning equities relative to holding risk-free US Treasury bonds would begin to stop making sense from a risk/return standpoint and liquidation of stocks for the purchase of bonds would likely accelerate, driving stock prices lower.
UNDER THE HOOD ..
Only 25% of the stocks in the S&P 500 are currently outperforming the index. Read that again, it’s a remarkable statement. This low level has only been reached a few times in history. This is the very definition of a market (as determined by a headline index) being propped up by just a relative handful of very large (mostly tech or tech-adjacent) stocks.
This degree of concentration is confirmed by the fact that the smaller the capitalization index, heading down from Mega Cap to Large Cap to Mid Cap to Small Cap to Micro Cap, the weaker the price performance. This makes uncomfortable reading for the bulls as sustainable turnarounds have historically been led by stocks on the smaller end of the capitalization spectrum.
Prime technical indicators getting back towards news highs would be a minimum requirement for an improved environment, but that is simply not what is in place today. The probabilities therefore favor a continuation and even a possible acceleration of the primary trend which is still a downward one, which could still possibly take prices back down to, and maybe even break through, those lows of October last year.
Anglia Advisors clients are welcome to reach out to me to discuss market conditions further.
AVERAGE 30-YEAR FIXED RATE MORTGAGE ..
* 6.28%
(one week ago: 6.32%, one month ago: 6.65%, one year ago: 4.72%)
Weekly data courtesy of: FRED Economic Data, St. Louis Fed as of Thursday of last week.
US INVESTOR SENTIMENT LAST WEEK (outlook for the upcoming 6 months) ..
* ↑Bullish: 33% (22% a week ago)
* ↔ Neutral: 32% (32% a week ago)
* ↓Bearish: 35% (46% a week ago)
* Net Bull-Bear spread .. ↓Bearish by 2 (Bearish by 24 a week ago)
Weekly data courtesy of: American Association of Individual Inv…