The R-word rhetoric got stepped up last week. In between increasingly tiresome inflation anecdotes that seem to pop up everywhere from social media to groups of smokers in front of NYC bars, the hot topic has been The Recession.
In today’s report I’m going to dig a little deeper in what a recession is, what it isn’t, how to recognize one and why it just may not be the stock market catastrophe that it is usually portrayed as.
Given the previous week’s carnage and a pretty news-deficient long weekend, a bounce back from oversold conditions on Tuesday was completely unsurprising. There even seemed to be some evidence of a bit of old-school BTFD (remember when that was a thing?).
The Three Keys to a Bottom (peak Fed hawkishness, peak inflation, declining geo-political risk) remain in effect and none have yet been fully triggered although we could start to see some improvement in the first two as the Fed’s favored measure of what it would call true inflation, the Personal Consumption Expenditures index, comes out this week. A benign reading would indicate the inflation could be peaking, potentially reducing the need for such a hawkish stance from the Fed and will cheer Wall Street. But if more of the same, skyrocketing inflation for at least another month with no end in sight, is indicated - look out below.
Fed Chair Jerome Powell, talking to Congress, continued to stress that he believes that the economy can handle higher interest rates. However, he also admitted in response to Senator Elizabeth Warren's questioning that higher interest rates are not going to do anything to help with lower food and energy prices. Finally! Someone actually came out and said what we have all known for months!
Powell said that while it was possible that the Fed could help orchestrate a "soft" economic landing and avoid a recession it was important to understand that “recession is certainly a possibility. Frankly, the events around the world over recent months make it [the soft landing] harder” clearly referring to the war in Ukraine and lockdowns in China that are exacerbating food and energy inflation and the world’s supply-chain problems.
Markets didn’t respond well to all this long overdue honesty and an unexpectedly frank assessment and what was shaping to be quite a nice follow-up to Tuesday’s bounce began to fizzle fast as Powell’s words were digested and Wednesday ended up in the red after a late collapse.
Later in the week, however, we saw a quite meaningful rally in stock prices, as oversold conditions proved too tempting to ignore while the financial newswires were generally quiet and we began to see the (mostly stock market-positive) effects of both index and portfolio rebalancing as well as window-dressing (see FINANCIAL TERM OF THE WEEK below) in advance of the upcoming end of Q2.
It also didn’t hurt that on Friday, the U.S. Federal Reserve released a report showing that all major U.S. banks passed its stress-testing Comprehensive Capital Analysis and Review. This is welcome news for the market with recession on everyone’s mind.
So let’s turn to the R-Word. Broadly speaking, a recession is popularly defined as two consecutive quarters of negative GDP growth as determined by the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER), although technically there are other factors that may be taken into account in determining if a recession has “officially” occurred. The point here is that it’s very much a backward-looking endeavor that’s mainly aimed at economic historians years from now and posterity in general. It is not intended for present day consumption or decision-making and certainly has no predictive qualities whatsoever. Recessions are often identified by NBER as having been in place long after the real slowdown in the economy has ended and the recovery is in fact already underway.
Frankly the only way to really know we are in a recession in real time is anecdotal. Friends and family members start getting laid off or having a difficult time of it at work. You see abandoned construction sites in your town. Stores close. Yes, there are a few stats that can indicate a concurrent recession (Purchasing Managers Indexes falling below 50, unemployment numbers starting to spike) but it’s remarkably tricky to know if one is currently experiencing one.
By virtue of her tweet: “When y’all think they going to announce that we going into a recession?”, we know that Cardi B for one is breathlessly waiting for an official recession announcement at some imminent Treasury press conference or something. Sorry Cardi, that just isn’t going to happen. If we are currently in a recession today, we’ll probably find out for sure about it towards the end of the year - by which time we may well no longer be in recession.
So what you potentially have is an extremely forward-looking animal (the stock market) colliding with a very backward-looking one (an official recession declaration) and that can often mean that the damage and the pain can be mostly over by the time we know for sure what the reason for it is. The stock market may well be looking beyond any recession very soon and that is why we need to focus on what is stirring beneath the surface of the market in terms of broad supply and demand rather than reacting to real time events when it comes to figuring out when the skies are beginning to clear. And you’ll find that in my ”Under The Hood” section every week in this report.
When looked at in this context, recessions aren’t necessarily always the stock-killers they may seem. Tom Essaye’s Sevens Report ran the numbers which showed a surprising outcome. Using periods beginning six months before the official recession start dates and ending six months after the official recession end dates, he found that, of the eight official recessions since 1969, five of them saw pretty meaningful S&P 500 price increases over those time periods, moving higher, on average, by a very healthy 14%.
It should said that the other three (1970s stagflation, the dot.com crash of 2001 and the late 2000s financial crisis) did indeed inflict long-lasting and intense damage to stock markets, but the assumption that a recession and a hefty stock market crash inevitably march hand-in-hand in simultaneous lockstep is simply not borne out by the data.
Summing up, while recession is a major buzzword right now, don’t let it significantly scare you. Recessions themselves are arbitrary designations and the economy slows well ahead of them and market declines tend to occur a long time before they are declared. By the time the economy is deemed to be in one, stocks can often have already bottomed out and are looking towards the recovery.
What matters far more than whether a recession exists or not is its duration once it has been determined that it is in place. The three “bad” ones each lasted for a long time and proved far more destructive than the other shorter ones. A short recession, even if it is intense, is going to hurt far less than a long-drawn-out affair that may never reach that level of intensity, but just drags on and on.
Other News:
Falling sales, rising prices .. Record-setting prices and rising mortgage rates sent sales of previously-owned homes to their lowest level in almost two years. The number of existing home sales 3.4% from April to May, the fourth consecutive monthly decline and the fewest sales since June 2020. That’s 8.6% lower than a year ago. The amount of home sales have essentially round-tripped back to levels seen in early 2019 before the COVID outbreak.
Further declines in sales should be expected in the coming months because of the industry euphemistically calls “housing affordability challenges”. The median price for an existing home went above $400,000 for the first time ever, reaching $407,600, a 14.8% rise over the last year.
Bye, bye Juul .. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) announced plans last week to limit nicotine levels in cigarettes and then ordered Juul to be completely sh…