In the end it proved to be a rotten week for U.S. stocks. A geopolitical shadow hung over markets the whole time with American officials warning of an imminent Iranian reprisal for Israel’s recent deadly air strike against a consulate in Syria, which kept the price of oil very perky. Meanwhile domestically, the big news was more hot inflation data and a slowly-emerging troubling concern about the prospects for interest rate cuts in 2024.
JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon used his annual letter to shareholders on Monday to add his voice to the quietly growing chorus of those warning that the Fed’s next move might not be an interest rate cut at all, but rather a rate increase. He listed factors including ongoing fiscal spending, increased U.S. remilitarization, restructuring of global trade, continued geopolitical unrest and the capital demands of a new green economy as inflationary factors that could feasibly result in interest rates in fact moving higher this year, contrary to the conventional wisdom that interest rate cuts are just around the corner.
Stock traders, however, appeared to be biding their time to start the week, preferring to focus more on the eclipse and swapping highly dramatic (!!) New York earthquake stories ahead of U.S. inflation data out later in the week and prices barely moved on what was the second-lowest trading volume day of the year so far.
Tuesday was no different, another lackluster trading session for stocks with indexes little changed for a second straight day. Market interest rates continued their relentless march higher with the 2 year, 5 year and 10 year Treasury yields all touching new highs for the year. This pushed bond prices lower.
Pre-market on Wednesday, the release of the Consumer Price Index (CPI) measure of retail inflation showed that stubborn upward price pressures persisted in March, appearing to slam the door shut on any lingering hopes of a Fed interest rate cut in either May or June, especially since the May CPI reading is scheduled to come out on the same day as the Fed's June decision. Even the probability of a cut in July was pretty much reduced to a toss-up (see FEDWATCH INTEREST RATE TOOL below).
March CPI rose 3.5% from a year earlier, higher than forecast and a meaningful pickup from February’s 3.2%. So-called Core prices (ex. food and energy) rose 3.8% from a year earlier, unchanged from the previous month but above expectations. This was the third consecutive hotter-than-anticipated inflation reading and reinforced the fact that, while inflation is not showing signs of rebounding, its decline has definitely stalled.
The stock market’s verdict was swift and brutal, it headed straight into free-fall right from the opening bell. The “zero-interest-rate-cut-in-2024-in-fact-expect-interest-rate-increases” theory of Jamie Dimon and friends suddenly did not seem so fanciful after all. Indeed, once ex-Treasury Secretary Larry Summers endorsed the theory on Bloomberg TV after seeing the inflation numbers, this particular elephant in the room suddenly started to become visible to everyone.
Those Treasury yields soared higher again, deeper into new 2024 record territory, sending bond prices spiraling even lower. Even the often-overly-optimistic futures market-driven expected total number of interest rate cuts in 2024 ticked down from three to two (remember, as recently as January, these same markets were assuming seven!).
The inflation picture got a bit more muddled on Thursday morning, when CPI’s cousin, the Producer Price Index (PPI) measure of wholesale inflation experienced by manufacturers, actually came in a touch softer than expected. This helped stop the bleeding to a certain extent as both stock and bond prices stabilized following the rout of the previous day, indeed the NASDAQ in particular had something of a healthy pop, helped by Amazon’s stock price hitting a new all-time high.
Friday was the official kick-off of the Q1 2024 earnings season and the traditional curtain-raiser of earnings and forecasts from some of the major banks could be described as mixed at best. With spiking fears of an imminent flare-up in the Middle East conflict and the ongoing intertwined inflation and interest rate concerns, stock markets swiftly resumed their sharp downward trajectory and by the close, Friday’s nosedive had proved to be even worse than Wednesday’s.
Although it was clearly responsible for a major selloff in stocks last week, I want to put forward the case that the March CPI number was not, of itself, quite the destructive negative game-changer that many seem to now be fearing.
Contrary to what you may be seeing on TikTok and on the more wacky fringes of Fox Business, we are not yet witnessing a rebound in inflation. Just that the decline has stalled. Annualized rates are heavily dependent on the base number from a year earlier and even the 0.4% monthly increase was actually 0.359% if taken out an extra decimal place meaning that it was in fact only one hundredth of one percent away from actually meeting the expectations of a 0.3% increase, which might well have elicited a less dramatic market response.
Higher interest rates and elevated inflation do not of themselves mean stock prices are in danger of falling. The keys are growth and earnings, which we need to watch very closely since the safety net of imminent interest rate cuts is now likely gone. If Q1 2024 earnings are strong and economic growth remains stable, then stocks can still move higher despite lofty market interest rates and limited or even no Fed rate cuts.
With “higher for longer” interest rates as a result of inflation’s stickiness, the dominance of tech will likely continue to fade, most probably making way for sectors like financials (Friday’s earnings notwithstanding), consumer defensive, healthcare and energy. This could lead to a more unified, less fragmented stock market that could be a rising tide that lifts all boats.
It’s entirely possible that last week’s experience will soon be either a) a rather forgettable speed-bump in a continuing upward march in stock prices or, b) the turning point that brought the October 2023-April 2024 rally to an end. Which it is will be determined by how earnings and economic growth shake out in the coming weeks.
OTHER NEWS ..
Front-Running? .. Unlike the Federal Reserve, the European Central Bank (ECB) seems quite happy to show that it is poised to kick off the global interest rate-cutting cycle among major economies very soon. It strongly hinted on Thursday that this would happen in June, which would likely front-run the Fed.
Air Contrast .. The share price of Boeing fell hard last week after a whistleblower claimed it took a number of shortcuts (including using Dawn dishwashing liquid as a lubricant for fitting a door) to speed up the assembly of the 787 Dreamliner and that the model is at severe risk of aging prematurely. The plane maker had earlier called such accusations “inaccurate” , but delivered the fewest aircraft in a quarter since mid-2021.
This is in stark contrast to the fortunes of one of the firm’s largest clients, Delta Air Lines whose forecast for this quarter blew past Wall Street’s estimates. It’s largely a function of well-heeled passengers willing to pay top fares rather than price-conscious flyers shopping for basic economy toward the rear of the plane. Revenue from the group of these more affluent flyers jumped 10% annualized last quarter, compared with 4% for the main cabin.
More Delinquency .. U.S. credit-card delinquency rates have hit a record level. Almost 3.5% of balances were at least 30 days past-due at the end of December, according to the Philadelphia Fed. That’s the highest figure since 2012. About 10% of borrowers now have an account balance that exceeds $5,200 and credit scores are getting worse.
The numbers signal added pressure on household finances in an era of swiftly increased interest rates. Only about one-third of cardholders pay their balance in full ever…