Listen

Description

Stocks closed out a truly spectacular November last week with the S&P 500 index finishing about 9% higher than it was at the beginning of the month. Tech stocks were the best performers by sector, but real estate came a close second - despite the cratering post-pandemic commercial space. Energy was the worst performer, falling 2% in line with very weak oil prices and was the only sector with a negative outcome for the month.

Monday proved to be a rather forgettable session, with prices trapped inside a narrow range, eventually finishing a touch lower. The only thing of interest going on was the trickle of data releases on all the shopping being done the previous week. The biggest takeaway from the early data was that consumer spending could be up handsomely from last year and that (shocker!) we are all doing more of our shopping online rather than braving actual stores.

Some of the good vibes returned on Tuesday. A report showed that consumer confidence increased in November after having fallen for three consecutive months. Fed-speak was generally supportive also. Federal Reserve Governor Christopher Waller said policy is well positioned to return inflation to the Fed’s 2% goal and his colleague Michelle Bowman deftly avoided answering when directly asked if there would be another interest rate hike. Most stocks took another small leg higher.

More encouraging Thanksgiving-related data came out on Wednesday. Over 200 million U.S. consumers participated in weekend shopping, that’s 18 million more than expected and more people travelled through U.S. airports in a single day on Sunday than ever before.

But the big news of the day was that the second of three official estimates indicated that the U.S. economy grew faster in Q3 than even optimistic analysts had thought. Gross Domestic Product (GDP) rose at a mind-bending 5.2% annualized pace, up from the previous estimate of 4.9%, more than double the previous quarter’s growth rate and the fastest since the economy began rapidly accelerating out of the depths of the pandemic two years ago. Consumer spending also grew, but at a less-breakneck rate of 3.6%. After initially jumping higher on the data, stock prices faded in the afternoon to finish largely unchanged.

Before the market opened on Thursday, we learned that the Fed’s darling inflation measure, the Core Personal Consumption Expenditure (PCE) index, came in as expected at a year-on-year 3.2% and the annualized rate over the last six months has now fallen to 2.5%, pretty much putting the final nail in the coffin of any chance of an interest rate hike on December 13th at the Fed’s final rate-setting meeting of the year (see FEDWATCH INTEREST RATE PREDICTION TOOL below). Stocks ticked higher again.

Friday marked the beginning of the final month of 2024 and Decembers have traditionally proved pretty generous to stock investors. And we got off to a solid start this year, following a speech from Fed Chair Jerome Powell, making the rather innocuous, not-very-startling statement that he believed the central bank's recent policies have helped bring down inflation. But in the current giddy glass-is-half-full environment, this was seen to even further bolster the case that policymakers won't raise interest rates any further.

Stocks took their cue from this interpretation and all the indexes finished the day meaningfully higher, with Small Caps in particular outshining the rest.

The end of 2024 guesstimates for the S&P 500 are rolling in .. much of what I’m seeing clusters near a record-busting price target of close to 5000 (the all-time high is 4796, reached on the first trading day of 2022), with some of them as high as 5400 and remarkably few predicting lower prices than where we are now.

The index closed on Friday at around 4595, so a 5,000 level on New Year’s Eve 2024 implies a rally of 8.8% over the next thirteen months. This is not far from the historical average gain per year for the index but, if accomplished, would represent a rather impressive total two-year gain of more than 30% from the end of 2022 to the end of 2024.

Interesting factoid for 2024 crystal ball-gazers; in election years of first-term presidents, whether they get re-elected or not, the stock market has historically moved higher literally 100% of the time.

The bullish argument for stocks can largely be summed up by; Everything that’s already priced in actually happens. Because a lot of it hasn’t yet. Bulls are anticipating; no economic slowdown, immaculate disinflation, resilient corporate earnings continue to beat expectations and a healthy dose of interest rate cuts from the Fed in 2024 and beyond.

The bearish argument for stocks can largely be summed up by; Everything we were worried about for 2023 actually ends up happening in 2024. In other words, the long list of concerns for 2023 weren’t misguided, they were just early. Bears are anticipating (much as they were a year ago); economic growth actually contracts leading to a recession, inflation stops falling and maybe even ticks back higher again, corporate earnings growth disappoints and the Fed does not cut interest rates as soon or by as much as expected.

We should remember that outcomes are rarely binary and elements of both theses will probably come to fruition, but these are the factors to keep an eye on which - along with any kind of unpredictable external shock and I think the inevitable craziness that will accompany the U.S. presidential election - will determine how accurate these year-end 2024 price target guesses end up being.

OTHER NEWS ..

Riddle Me This .. On Monday, we got data that showed that the median price of a new home had plunged 18% year over year. Then the next day, we were told that existing home prices rose for an eighth straight month, surging to a new record high.

Put that all together and housing prices are .. rising? Falling? It depends? Everyone expected home prices to fall when mortgage rates shot up to 8%. But it turns out that most American homeowners had already locked in a mortgage interest rate far below today’s and have no intention of giving that up, meaning hardly anyone is selling. This lack of inventory has led to bidding wars and higher prices for existing homes.

Builders, meanwhile, have now started trying to fill that gap with accelerating new construction and the market for new home sales has had a different dynamic altogether.

The housing/shelter component is about a 40% weighting in the Core Consumer Price Index (CPI) reading. Without lower price inflation in that category, it is going to be hard for the Fed to reach its target of bringing inflation back down to to 2%.

New Blood .. Joining the S&P 500 index on December 18th in one of its occasional reconstitutions will be Uber, Jabil and Builders FirstSource. Booted out to make way for these three new members will be Sealed Air, Alaska Air and SolarEdge Technologies.

Apple Pulls The Plug On Goldman Sachs .. The tech company recently sent a proposal to the Wall Street investment bank announcing its intention to exit their credit card and savings account partnership contract in the next 12 to 15 months, according to a Bloomberg report. This contract had previously been extended through 2029 just a matter of months ago.

The end of the much-heralded cooperation initiative which began with the Apple credit card in 2019 and then the high yield savings account earlier this year is the final nail in the coffin of Goldman's doomed bid to expand into consumer lending which was launched back in 2016 with the introduction of the Marcus savings account.

UNDER THE HOOD ..

It is important to remember that the market deals in probabilities, not certainties. That’s where certain forms of technical analysis can be useful, but frequently it exposes two sides of a coin. This is one of those times.

The continuation higher in the last two or three weeks of the percentage of stocks trading above their Long Term Moving Averages (see below) is consistent with a f…



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit simonbrady.substack.com