Listen

Description

Edited Transcript (to be updated)

Today I want to talk about Advaita Vedānta, because I’ve been in discussions with various people about what the genuine Advaita Vedānta is.

That’s a difficult question. It’s a rich topic for an academic. As an academic, I could happily spend a lot of time going through the different varieties of Advaita Vedānta. And I’ve done that informally and provisionally in some of my Substacks posts here.

What I’ve noticed about this topic is that there’s an academic discipline in universities that studies Advaita Vedānta, and there’s a lot of recent work in this area. But there’s an almost complete disconnect between the academic study of Advaita Vedānta and the popular versions of Advaita Vedānta that have become more familiar in recent years, like people who are followers of Neo-Advaita or the global communities of people who see themselves as disciples of Bhagavān Śrī Ramaṇa Maharṣi. The academics who study Advaita Vedānta as a scriptural tradition, Sanskritists and Indologists, don’t study or interact with these other groups. That’s left for academics who study contemporary religions.

Then there’s another issue. There’s a strand of Advaita Vedānta that’s become increasingly influential that claims that the only way to mokṣa, to enlightenment, is through the practice of śabda-pramāṇa.

The appeal to śabda-pramāṇa is the claim that because Brahman is formless and not identical with any physical, mental, or intellectual formations, there’s no way to approach it other than through the statement of the Upaniṣads, the great statements, the mahāvākyas. For instance, “tat tvam asi“ (“You are That”).

Simply by hearing that, if you’re sufficiently purified and sufficiently prepared, you should realize instantly, instantaneously, that it’s true. That there’s only Brahman. There’s nothing but Brahman. It’s formless. It’s eternal consciousness. It’s what we fundamentally are. And there’s no division in it. There’s no cut in it. So there’s only one consciousness, one Brahman, and it is what it is right now.

That is, of course, a completely understandable stance to take. But I’ve noticed two difficulties arise with this approach.

The first is that often people who advocate it are exclusivistic. That is, they see it only as the only true path. They allow there are lots of paths, and you can follow them, although they think that they lead only to experience seeking. They lead to something other than mokṣa. They lead to more māyā, more involvement in saṃsāra. In the end, they leave you where you started, with maybe a more exalted sense of the deeper depths of māyā.

So that is what you expect from exclusivistic religious teachings, because you always find among exclusivists the claim that they have the only truth. What’s really amusing to me as a scholar of religion for many decades who has written about pluralism is that all exclusivists from different traditions and schools mostly think in the same way. There’s a logical similarity between their arguments—different contents, same types of arguments. I’ve taken this up in one of my books, Pluralism, The Future of Religion. But that’s not the topic for today. The point I want to make that does bear repeating, though, is that the teachings of different schools of religious and philosophical exclusivists have different contents but similar types of arguments.

But that is an argument that doesn’t prove anything to an exclusivist.

So the second issue is that this approach to Advaita Vedānta not only assumes that it’s ultimately the one true teaching, but that the other schools of Advaita Vedānta and the other schools of Vedānta are also wrong—what to speak of the schools of Yoga and Tantra. They’re all just forms of mysticism, of experience seeking.

So the issue then arises: is it true that śabda-pramāṇa is the only true or ultimate teaching?

Well, let’s just assume that it is. Let’s make the assumption that reflecting on the statement “You are That” (tat tvam asi) is the only way to awaken.

In my experience, most people who follow this path understand this intellectually in the way that I understand that today’s Thursday or that the sun doesn’t really revolve around the earth even though it looks like that—it’s actually the other way around. So that’s knowledge, intellectual knowledge. And I have no problem with intellectual knowledge. It’s important.

But the real test for whether someone has actually attained realization of Brahman through śabda-pramāṇa is in the change in that person.

Someone like Sri Ramana Maharshi spontaneously realized non-dual Brahman and lived a life that was completely different from the life of a person who just has an intellectual understanding of tat tvam asi. If we have only an intellectual understanding of Brahman, when we come to difficulties in life—sickness, illness, old age, loss—we’re deeply affected by it, and immediately we revert to that person who is actually not very enlightened.

We can see that the enlightened saints and teachers of Advaita Vedānta actually realized that there’s only Brahman because when they were faced with illness, suffering, and so on, they didn't revert to being frightened, scared, or egocentric. How could they? There’s only Brahman for them, and all of this was really an illusion for them. We only have to look at how Sri Ramana Maharshi endured his final illnesses.

I think that it’s important when speaking about śabda-pramāṇa to realize that most people who speak about attaining Brahman realization through śabda-pramāṇa have attained an intellectual realization. They know the difference between the rope and the snake. It’s pretty easy to understand the basic teaching that there’s only Brahman, we are it, there’s only consciousness, and any perceived distinctions in Brahman are illusory. The difference between knowledge (jñāna) and not-knowledge (avidyā) just comes down to knowing that that snake on the ground is actually a rope. What a relief!

So this means that—and what I’m saying very informally here is also grounded in texts from the Advaita Vedānta tradition—there isn’t only one true school of Advaita Vedānta, especially one that just arose in the last century. That’s like what happens in other religious movements when a new religious movement arises and it claims to be the only true expression of that religion, even though the religion itself is a couple of thousand years old and the new movement is twenty years old, fifty years old, or one hundred years old.

So the test is realization. The test is whether one has realized the import of śabda-pramāṇa, which means that there’s no one left to realize it, there’s no one left who can be subjected to suffering even if the body is suffering because that person has attained insight. So for me, it’s important to bring that point to bear.

Because in my experience, which is limited, people I’ve known who are followers of Neo-Advaita and some other traditions and versions of Advaita Vedānta speak about enlightenment and talk about realization, but they have not proven that they have moved from an intellectual understanding to a profoundly enlightened standpoint. So that test is very important to keep in mind. I just wanted to speak about that for a few minutes today here.

I want to raise another point: this more recent school of Advaita Vedānta often sees people who follow other paths as just being experience seekers. And that’s similar to religious traditionalists who judge people who travel from one religious tradition to another as like going to the cafeteria or the delicatessen and just picking something out, throwing it together, and calling it your spiritual life.

This is a caricature. Surely there are people like that, but most people who are serious spiritual seekers do understand that there is a difference between having random, unrelated experiences and actual insight into the nature of reality.

In the Christian mystical tradition, it’s clear that experiences of mystical union—which are very similar…



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit kenrose51.substack.com