Prompted by a recent discussion with an advocate of a school of contemporary Advaita Vedānta that discounts mystical experience, I explore the positive and indispensable role that mystical experience plays in awakening to enlightenment.
(Revised August 6, 2026)
You can follow along with the transcript on the audio or you can read the slightly edited version of the transcript here:
I’ve been staying for the last few months at an ashram in Germany. It’s a traditional place where the Hindu deities are honored in daily pujas and ceremonies. It’s possible to engage in spiritual practice from five in the morning until ten at night. There are aratis, satsangs, yoga classes, and traditional teachers of Vedanta from India. Globally known yoga teachers and Ayurveda physicians are also in attendance here. So it’s an extraordinary opportunity to be here and to revive and deepen my spiritual life. I’ve been writing, reading, and doing my seva here at the ashram. I’ve also been deeply meditating, practicing yoga, and experiencing a reunion with the Self. That’s exactly what one expects from time spent in an ashram, and that’s the experience that I’ve been having here.
I was listening yesterday to a teacher of Advaita Vedanta from India, who said something that set me to thinking about the different varieties of Advaita Vedanta that we can choose from currently. To put this quite simply, we might say that there is the traditional Advaita Vedanta that goes back to Shankara and is still taught and preserved in the ashrams, or maths, that Shankara founded in India. It’s an ancient and authentic tradition, though it’s unlikely that someone like me could study Advaita Vedanta in it. It would have been better to have been born into the Hindu tradition to be able to access this tradition in terms of language, background, and culture.
There’s a second kind of Advaita Vedanta that has been popularized across the globe over the last century and a quarter by swamis such as Swami Vivekananda who began teaching in the West. They articulated a Vedanta that’s generally known as Integral Yoga, a concept introduced by Swami Sivananda but traceable to Swami Vivekananda. Integral Yoga integrates the four classical yogas that are often mentioned in connection with Hinduism. These include Karma Yoga, which is the yoga of seva, of work, of activity, of offering the fruits of your actions to your favored deity, to your ishta-devata. Second, is what are commonly known as Raja Yoga and Hatha Yoga. They are distinguishable and not quite the same. We can call them the yoga of the subtle body and the yoga of the physical body. Next is Bhakti Yoga, which is the yoga of devotion and of love for the Divine. It speaks directly to our hearts as well as to our minds.
Finally, there’s Jnana Yoga, which is the yoga of wisdom, the yoga of knowledge. As presented currently among those practicing the Integral Yoga of the Sivananda traditions, which were inspired on this point by Swami Vivekananda, Jnana Yoga is an experiential practice. You can know that you are Brahman either through direct insight, or jnana, or through the practice of samadhi. On the direct path you say to yourself, ahaṃ brahmasmi, or, in English, “I am pure consciousness.” Then you remain still. In that stillness, there may be a twinkle, a sensation, an awareness, or an insight of the truth that there is only a singular consciousness of nondual, formless, and blissful Brahman—which is also atman, or the Self. To attain this insight, this spark of jnana, or to bolster it, you practice dhyana and samadhi as prescribed in the Yoga Sutra.
A third variant of Advaita Vedanta comprises the recent movements mostly among nontraditional adherents of Advaita Vedanta known as Neo-Advaita. As with traditional Advaita Vedanta, Neo-Advaita teaches that there’s nothing to attain because we are already the Self that we’re looking for. To put that in the memorable saying of a recent Neo-Advaita teacher, we can simply call off the search. There’s nothing to search for because we’re already found! We are the Self that we’ve been looking for. There’s nothing else to do. And everything else is merely a distraction from just being what we already are, which is pure, eternal, formless, infinite consciousness.
There’s a fourth kind of Advaita Vedanta, which is now becoming more influential, and there are many varieties and streams that enter into this view. It’s gaining ground among academic researchers on Advaita Vedanta, popular Advaita teachers opposed to Neo-Advaita, and in some Hindu ashrams—although it seem to have less standing among the most traditional Advaita Vedantists in the maths founded by Shankara. What unites the different streams of this recent variant of Advaita Vedanta is the downplaying of the practice and experience of samadhi as taught in the Yoga Sutra. One variant of this approach adds the claim that enlightenment, or moksha, is attained only through hearing and reflecting on famous sayings in the Upanishads such as “You are That” and “I am Brahman.” Another variant of this type of Advaita Vedanta holds that enlightenment comes only through an ongoing dialectical process of first affirming (adhyaropa) that Brahman is x, where x is any feature of experienced reality that you choose, and then subsequently denying (apavada) that Brahman possesses that attribute. Like Neo-Advaita, these schools retain the profound Advaita Vedantic teaching that we’re already enlightened. Since there is only pure consciousness, it’s not possible to be anything other than pure consciousness. But they also pose a challenge to Neo-Advaita by claiming that there is in fact one—and only one—practice that conduces to enlightenment: we recognize the truth of our natural enlightenment only by hearing and reflecting on Upanishadic statements such as “I am Brahman” or “You are That.” That suffices for us to throw off the shackles of illusion. Cultivating samadhi and attending to mystical experience are not avenues to moksha. Indeed, they may become impediments if we see them as more than preparatory practices
Because the emerging schools of this fourth variety of Advaita Vedanta hold that virtually all of the other schools of Advaita Vedanta since Shankara and his disciple Sureshvara have fallen away from the correct path, we might name this approach “Revisionist Advaita Vedanta.” Because this carries a negative connotation, perhaps something like “Repristinated Advaita Vedanta” is preferable. It captures the intention of these movements to return to what they see as the pristine teachings of Shankara and Sureshvara.
The arguments separating these divergent schools of Advaita Vedanta are subtle but also interminable, and they can also become a distraction from practice. In my own practice, I am drawn more to the teachings of Swami Vivekananda, Swami Sivananda, and Sri Ramana Maharshi than to the other schools of Advaita Vedanta, which has influenced me for multiple decades. The beginning of nondual insight, or jnana, occurred for me early in my spiritual practice over fifty years ago when my first guru asserted that “you are not this body.” That claim stunned me when I first heard it, because I thought, if I’m not this body, what then am I? That led to the classic practice of atma-vichara, or self-inquiry, which is the inquiry or the investigation of one’s experience to see what in that experience is actually the truth. If you really grapple with the statement that you are not this body, it can lead—as it led in my case—to an almost furious search to find out who who I am if I’m not my body.
It’s an extraordinary claim for physicalists and materialists. It would be laughable to them at the outset, but even they might be challenged by it if they started to grapple with that teaching. If I’m not my body, who or what am I? Am I my mind? But the mind constantly changes, and what is a mind in any case? I can touch my body but how do I touch my mind? How do I define a boundary ar…