In this podcast episode, I speak off the cuff and informally. It would take a few days to write an article on this topic and longer to refine it for an academic journal. But in my Substack posts and podcasts, I want to speak more freely than possible when speaking in a course on mysticism at a university. It’s more fun this way and allows me more freedom of thought and expression, albeit somewhat imprecisely at times. In this edited transcript of my talk, I have attempted to straighten out some of the tangents and imprecision of a spontaneous talk but without refining away its directness and spontaneity.
Well, it’s afternoon now at the ashram and it’s a lovely sunny day in early April, which in northern Europe is a month when there can be sunshine and rain and occasionally even snow. So if you hear some sounds in the background, it’s because there are people playing with the frisbee and everyone’s really delighting and having some sun after a very long winter. I want to continue talking about the topic of Advaita Vedānta and religious experience. This is a significant issue for me, and I think for many others as well. I want to make some comparisons to clarify what I’m trying to uncover in these informal talks.
As a person who taught comparative religion for many years at the university level and who has written books on this topic and researched in this field, I would assert that comparative religion is a liberative technique in the history of human consciousness. It’s not in fashion currently in academic religious studies, although academic religious studies, as opposed to theology, was largely shaped in its origins one hundred to two hundred years ago by the comparative religionists who discovered commonalities between different religious traditions. Back then, the comparative religionists weren’t clearly distinguished from the comparative theologians, and they often had an ulterior motive in looking for comparisons. They were motivated by theological concerns. But soon there came a new stream of scholars in this field who began to distinguish between comparative theology and comparative religion. The early significant figures in the field undertook a quest to discover commonalities between religious traditions, religious doctrines, and religious experiences in order to demonstrate the underlying unity of human consciousness across different cultural divides.
One of the significant liberative insights that comes through the practice and the study of comparative religion is that religions change, doctrines change, and descriptions of experience change. Religious authorities, religious institutions, religious customs, and religious practices are diverse around the globe. Nevertheless, religions express a set of fundamental ideas, experiences, and teachings. This discovery unveils the spiritually liberative potential of comparative religion when considered as more than just an academic field. When we take a comprehensive and non-exclusivist approach to spirituality, it’s natural to become a comparative religionist. If one has fluency in more than one religious tradition, it’s natural and inevitable that one begins to see the similarities between them. If you study German and English, you can’t help but notice similarities. If you study Sanskrit, Greek, and Latin, you also can’t help but notice similarities. It’s harder to discern similarities across different language families, but even there, the quest can be continued to find similarities.
There are scholars and academics who see the search for commonalities as a type of essentializing that does violence to the particularities of different traditions. No doubt a facile comparative approach can generate ahistorical essential concepts that are out of touch with the realities that they express. But generalization is essential to thought. Every concept is itself a generalization. Whenever we use the word dog or tree, we are already engaged in generalizations because all concepts are generalizations. So we inevitably use essentializing concepts. We use them constantly in everyday speech.
These reflections about comparatives studies are meant as prologue to an intriguing comparison that occurred to me earlier today when I was thinking about the last post that I recorded on Advaita Vedānta and mystical experience.
In that podcast, I spoke about four different kinds of Advaita Vedānta that I have detected. (There are others besides the four that I mentioned. Recent scholarly studies of Advaita Vedānta deal comprehensively with traditional forms of Advaita Vedānta in India and the newer, highly erudite expressions of non-mystical Advaita Vedānta. But they don’t venture into discussing more popular forms of Advaita Vedānta, such as Neo-Advaita.) These four varieties of Advaita Vedānta can be illuminated by drawing upon a parallel from Catholic mystical theology.
Catholic mystical theology is a subject that’s long fascinated me, and not for merely scholarly reasons. This fascination began in my personal spiritual quest, which was deeply shaped in my early years by an encounter with devotional Hinduism. After that, there was a deep encounter with evangelical Christianity. The bridge between those two worlds was the writings of Thomas Merton, who opened my mind to a wider spirituality. In learning to engage his writings, I was inevitably led towards other Catholic mystical theologians and the so-called manualists. The most significant of the manualists for me is a French mystical theologian of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the Jesuit Augustin Poulain. His manual of mystical theology, The Graces of Interior Prayer, remains to this day a valuable source of knowledge about mystical experience and the ways in which it has been articulated or schematized in the Catholic mystical tradition. A decade ago, I wrote Yoga, Meditation and Mysticism, a book in which I delved deeply into Poulain’s taxonomy, or mystical map, which he structured on the basis of Teresa of Avila and John of the Cross’s mystical writings. The detailed contemplative maps devised by the manualists in the Catholic tradition, a school of thought that extends from the 1700s to the early part of the twentieth century provide significant data for a comparative study of mysticism. After Vatican II, the manualist tradition seems to have slipped out of view in mainstream Catholicism, but among traditionalist Catholics and students of comparative mysticism, Poulain’s manual is still highly regarded.
In Poulain’s highly articulated map of the spiritual life, there are two fundamental distinctions that have to be kept in mind. The first is the distinction between ascetical theology and mystical theology; the second is between acquired contemplation and infused contemplation. For those of you who are more familiar with Hinduism or Buddhism, this will likely be obscure language, but to put the shoe on the other foot, someone coming from the world of Catholic mystical theology would likely find the terminology that is used in Hinduism and Buddhism as equally obscure. The obscurity does evaporate, though, with familiarity. (On a side note I’ve noticed that here in the ashram in Germany where I have spent the last four months, most people are oriented towards Hinduism and to a lesser extent Buddhism. When I teach courses comparing the stages of samādhi in the Yogasūtra, the jhānas in the Buddhist Visuddhimagga, and the degrees of mystical contemplation in the Catholic mystical tradition, some ashramites react to my sudden breaking into what sounds like very traditional Catholic language as if I were speaking a language that they have never before encountered. Or perhaps they have, but their experiences with it have not been positive. It takes a little bit of getting people acclimated to these concepts before they feel at ease with them.)
To say a few words about these two pa…