So how do we live in harmony with one another, and the orchestra of Creation, over whom God is the Conductor? It is true that we cannot continue business as usual. I remember a teacher in high school citing a statistic that if everyone lived as decadently as we do in the West, we would need something like 4.5 planets. And yet, people in developing countries, understandably aspire to live as comfortably as us, and their resentment of policies that penalize their carbon emissions when the West had free reign to develop unrestricted for hundreds of years is understandable too. But the fact is, the effects of climate change do not respect borders or care about geopolitics. Given our better understanding of climate change and how our behavior has contributed to it, we in the West need to repent for the culture of consumerism we developed, and we all need to put politics and grievances aside and find a way to move forward toward a more sustainable future together. To incorporate another analogy, we all need to go on a diet, curtail our gluttonous consumerism and figure out what we actually need to thrive. I believe we can survive, even thrive with less.
But what I found when I changed the way I eat is that it has not meant a life of misery, tiny, unsatisfying portions of gross food. I like to think of Glenn Beck's dystopian view of environmental restoration as this kind of diet. Despite all of the evidence that climate change is a real existential threat, Christian Nationalists like him view climate change as nothing more than a conspiracy for government control. Antihumanists by contrast, recognize that climate change is a real threat, but feel that our condition is so hopeless we should just do our best to get through life, hope maybe a catastrophe like a more virulent global pandemic will put us out of our misery sooner, and make sure not to procreate and subject future generations to a life of misery on this earth we have so devastated. Transhumanists hope that we might develop artificial intelligence technology smarter than us (another spiritual rant I am saving for another post), or maybe we can figure out how to colonize Mars. But to colonize Mars, we would need man-made technology to supply our own oxygen, grow food further from the sun and protect ourselves from the much colder climate, and after the recent tragedy with the submarine that imploded, should we really entrust the future of humanity to these billionaire "innovators?" And even if we figure out how to colonize Mars with reliable technology, but our greedy human hearts have not changed, wouldn't we ultimately figure out how to exploit Mars to the point that it also becomes uninhabitable? Transhumanists are like the person who acknowledges their problematic habits, but believes one day there will be a magic pill. Most of us in the West are like the person that knows we need to change, knows there will be no magic pill, at least not one without unintended consequences, but the details of exactly how to change our habits feel so daunting that we are always saying, "I will do better tomorrow," as we give ourselves a giant scoop of frozen chocolate custard with hot fudge on top.
My eating habits still aren't perfect. Like many Americans, I got complacent with my portion sizes during the pandemic when I was home all the time, bored and anxious about what the future held. But the journey of changing the way I eat has been a sort of spiritual experience that has given me insights that I believe are relevant to the climate change discussion as well.
When I took the course on the book of Genesis my first semester at Trinity, the final paper required students to identify one mission God sets out for humans in the book of Genesis, and trace it through the Bible. I chose Creation care. While reflecting on this subject filled me with passion, I was a bit overwhelmed by this assignment, the most demanding assignment I had done since my undergraduate capstone at Carroll University in 2012, and my brain was just barely recovering from the atrophy caused by working in the corporate world, so the research process exhausted me. The final week of the semester, my parents and I also had to make the difficult decision to put my sweet guide dog and companion for 12 years, Gilbert to sleep. He had been slowing down for a couple of years, so I had accepted that it was time to say goodbye, but after the procedure, I still had difficulty concentrating. It had also been so long since I had to cite scholarly sources and use footnotes that this process overwhelmed me as well. I felt inspired to open the paper with the first few lines of Colors of the Wind, a song from Pocahontas, but could not find any examples of how to cite songs in Trinity's library resources, so I know this was cited incorrectly. But I managed to submit my paper in the nick of time, and to my amazement, earned a 97%. I believe this professor showed grace and mercy, giving me a much higher grade than I deserved, but I think he could sense my passion, and he gave me excellent feedback on how to make my argument more compelling. He also recommended that I read Stewards of Eden by Sandra Richter, a seminary professor from Kentucky passionate about convincing Christians that Creation care is a biblical mandate. Since then, I got sidetracked by life, but finally at the end of last month, I read this book and it was excellent. In my paper, I directed most of my blame for Christian apathy toward the climate crisis to the bad influence of prosperity theologians who conflate material wealth with God's blessing. The professor pointed out that while it is certainly true that the prosperity gospel has had a terrible influence on Christianity, it is a straw man argument because there are a lot of Christians who reject this theology and yet don't recognize that Creation care is a biblical mandate. After reading this book, I finally understand what he was getting at. For example, most Christians are no different than most Americans in that we give little thought to the milk, eggs and meat we put into our grocery cart. We are merely the invisible consumer, looking for the best product at the lowest price. It is the seller's responsibility to worry about where the product originated and how it was produced. Personally, I avoid beef and pork because red meat (at least red meat tender enough to be tolerated by the rest of the family) is very fattening, sits like a cement block in the stomach, and has almost no nutritional value. The fact that cows produce a lot of methane is a bonus reason not to eat it. Chicken and turkey make up the bulk of my meat consumption with fish once or twice a week, and eggs for breakfast twice a week. Long before reading this book, I was aware of the inhumane conditions of factory farms that produce pretty much all of the chicken, turkey and eggs Americans eat, that I eat for enjoyment, and because it is necessary to consume animal products to obtain vitamin B12 naturally. But I am embarrassed to say the suffering of these animals really didn't break my heart: in fact I barely even thought about it. I suppose I viewed it as a necessary evil to provide enough food for the population. Besides, God permitted us to eat meat, and the Bible doesn't say much about the treatment of livestock. But Sandra Richter opened my eyes to the fact that actually, God has a lot to say, especially in Leviticus and Deuteronomy, about the treatment of livestock. Of course, factory farms were not an issue back in biblical times. In fact, the ancient Israelites would have been subsistence farmers, who barely grew enough to survive. Even so, God mandated that livestock be treated with dignity. The Israelites were commanded for example, to not muzzle their oxen while they worked, so that the oxen could enjoy some of the grain while threshing, even though every grain of wheat would have been precious to the Israelites. When animals were slaughtered, they had to be t…