As I approached the car I gestured for the driver to join me on the pavement.
In the UK, the police don’t normally speak to you through the window, it’s much safer to both be standing. That way you can see their hands, and they’re not able to suddenly speed away in the car.
This was early in my career, when I was still in uniform.
The man was on his own, and so was I.
I hadn’t stopped him for anything he’d done wrong. It was just what we call a routine check.
I can’t even remember now what brought him to my attention.
So, here we were.
I introduced myself, with the usual smile I always gave to people. It’s far better talking to a relaxed person than an agitated one.
He smiled back, but there was something not quite right about him.
He gave me his name, date of birth and address, all of which seemed to come naturally to him. But my gut was telling me there was something off.
Do you have ID on you? A driver’s licence, credit card?
No
No problem, I’ll check the car.
It wasn’t registered to anybody.
No worries. If you give me the phone number of someone you know, I’ll get my control room to give them a call so they can confirm what you’re telling me.
He couldn’t remember one (and this was before the days of mobile phones).
The more I pressed, the more his smile faded.
I was starting to get a bad feeling.
I was on my own and looking at the size of him, I wasn’t sure how it would turn out if things went south, so I discreetly asked for back up.
Then I brought out my trusted curve ball question.
So, what star sign are you?
He just looked at me.
Then I saw his eyes flicker over my shoulder.
I knew what was coming.
He suddenly turned and was about to run, when I jumped on him, both of us going to the floor.
I’m glad I wasn’t in the position of today’s police, with people filming arrests and plastering them all over the internet, because I’m not sure how dignified I’d have looked rolling around on the floor with him.
Thankfully, my back-up didn’t take long to join me, and we soon had him detained.
Why had he tried to get away?
The name, date of birth and address he’d given me were all false.
He was wanted for stabbing someone a few days earlier.
I had no idea when I stopped him.
But that’s not the point of this story.
It was nothing special. In fact, I could’ve chosen any number of similar incidents.
The point is, I was using something a mentor told me when I first joined.
Don’t try to prove a person is lying, try and prove they’re telling the truth.
Because that’s the best way to unmask a liar.
And it was something I carried with me throughout my career.
Monday 13th August 2018
At around 1.40pm on this day, Officer Scott Coonrod was sent to 2825 Saratoga Trail in Frederick, Colorado, to carry out a welfare check.
It was the home of Chris and Shanann Watts, and their two daughters, Bella aged 4 and Celeste aged 3.
A friend of Shanann, Nickole Atkinson, had called the police out of concern.
When the officer arrived, Nickole was there and told him she had dropped Shanann home at around 1.48am after a business trip to Arizona. Shanann was 15 weeks pregnant, had not been feeling well, had failed to attend a 10am doctor’s appointment and was not responding to calls or messages.
Nickole had gone to the house with her adult son, Nicolas. They had seen Shanann’s Lexus in the garage, with the children’s car seats still inside.
She had already contacted Chris Watts who had agreed to make his way home.
When Watts arrived, he gave Officer Coonrod permission to enter and search for Shanann, Bella and Celeste. They were not there.
Other items belonging to Shanann were found in the house. Her purse was there. Her wallet contained her driving licence, cash and bank cards.
Her mobile phone was found between cushions of a sofa in the upstairs loft area. Watts gave police permission to examine it, and Officer Coonrod recorded that there had been no outgoing calls from the phone that morning.
Nickole told him that it was extremely unusual for Shanann to leave without her phone because she used it for work and normally took it everywhere.
Watts’ account was that Shanann had arrived home from her trip at around 2am. He had been asleep and woke at around 5am to get ready for work. He and Shanann then began talking about separating.
According to Watts, the conversation was civil. They weren’t arguing, although both were emotional. He said they had been talking about separating for several weeks.
He said that at around 5.27am he backed his work truck towards the garage to load tools. Shanann was still in bed at that point and had told him she was going to take the girls to a friend’s house. He said he hadn’t asked which friend.
He then drove to an Anadarko oil-well site beyond Hudson, where he was alone for a period of time.
Later, Detective Dave Baumhover asked Watts to walk him through the period when he had last seen Shanann.
Watts gave a broadly similar account, but the detective recorded the separation conversation as taking place at approximately 4am, with both of them upset and crying. Watts again said Shanann had told him she was going to a friend’s house, and that he backed his truck into the driveway at approximately 5.27am before leaving for work.
Detective Baumhover noted that the master bed had been stripped of its bedding, which was lying on the floor. The bedding was checked for signs of foul play, but nothing was found.
The officers reported seeing nothing inside the house, vehicles or garage that gave the appearance of an altercation.
Officer Coonrod began checking with neighbours to establish whether anyone had seen somebody coming or going.
A neighbour showed him footage from his home CCTV system that showed Nickole’s car leaving at 1.48am. At 5.27am, it showed Watts’ work truck backing into the driveway and leaving a short time later. The rear of Watts’ truck was obscured by the garage from the camera’s view.
It also showed no other vehicles coming or going from the house.
Officer Coonrod also recorded some observations about Watts.
He described his demeanour as nonchalant.
He said Watts asked whether he should go and look for his family. Officer Coonrod told him to remain there for the time being. He noted that Watts didn’t ask again and didn’t appear overly concerned.
He also said Watts mentioned the garage door being left open at least three times, which the officer found unusual.
Nickole gave a different assessment. She told the officer she thought Watts appeared extremely nervous.
Shanann’s mother called while Officer Coonrod was at the house. She was adamant Watts had done something and told him to check the GPS on Watts’ work truck. The officer was able to establish that the work truck did indeed have GPS.
Officer Coonrod also canvassed the neighbourhood. Nobody he spoke to reported seeing vehicles coming or going or anything unusual. At the same time, he asked residents to provide footage from any CCTV cameras they may have had.
He also circulated a welfare-check BOLO for Shanann and the children, meaning other officers in the area knew to be on the lookout for them.
Shanann’s phone was transported to Frederick Police Department for examination.
By the end of Monday, police hadn’t located Shanann, Bella or Celeste.
Tuesday 14th August 2018
By Tuesday morning, Shanann and the girls still hadn’t been found, and the investigation was beginning to grow.
Frederick Police requested assistance from the Colorado Bureau of Investigation and the FBI.
Officers continued searching the house and surrounding area, including using search dogs and a drone.
Nothing was found that explained where Shanann and the girls were.
But there were other things they could check.
The previous day, police had established that Watts’ work truck was fitted with GPS.
So, CBI Agent Tammy Lee contacted Watts’ workplace and requested the GPS information from the truck.
Police were also continuing to investigate information coming in from the public.
There was a reported sighting of Shanann and the girls, but when investigators viewed the CCTV footage they were sati…