Listen

Description

By John M. Grondelski

Many commentators identify the origin of politicians' (especially Catholic Democrats') "personally opposed but" approach to abortion as John F. Kennedy's 1960 presidential campaign, particularly his September address to the Greater Houston Ministerial Association. Carl Anderson, former Supreme Knight of the Knights of Columbus, insists that's not quite right – at least not in a straight line, though there are similarities. His book, Conscience as a Political Problem, helpfully explains why.

Kennedy knew that there was a "Catholic vote," Democrats needed it, and JFK could deliver it. The problem was that the United States had never had a Catholic president. Could a Catholic candidate overcome Protestant prejudices and make the delivery? Kennedy believed he could by invoking "conscience" as his guarantee of freedom from papal interference in the nation's affairs.

Anderson argues that, in the context of the time, Kennedy was right. Most Protestants who opposed Kennedy did so out of fear that a Catholic president would send an ambassador to the Holy See and push parochial school aid. But as Anderson notes, those were questions of prudential politics: Catholics were not bound to do either. To the degree that JFK asserted his independence in such policy matters, he was within Catholic bounds. And Kennedy, in Houston, was not parsing theological principles, but just saying what it took to get elected.

Where "conscience" became a more serious problem was when issues were not prudential policies but involved permanent moral questions – abortion in particular. That wasn't an issue for Kennedy in 1960; it would be for Ferraro in 1984, Kerry in 2004, and many others since.

The main contribution of Anderson's book is not, however, the history – important as that is. It's his recognition that the crucial questions are anthropological and still central: Whom do you say man is? He wrestles with this problem in his final chapter. But far from being the end of the story, I take it as the beginning, an unfinished idea that merits ongoing, comprehensive Catholic engagement.

The anthropological problem is twofold. First, it involves a proper definition of conscience. Anderson seeks to do that by invoking John Henry Newman's distinction between a "Christian" and a "secular" or "counterfeit" conscience. For Newman, a Christian conscience is what Catholics rightly understand conscience to be: a power that examines objective good and evil and, guided by the first principle of practical reason ("good is to be done and pursued; evil to be avoided"), makes judgments in light of objective reality. A secular or "counterfeit" conscience gives the appearance of conscience but is, in reality, self-will with an admixture of pious-sounding rationalizations.

When 1960s Protestants heard JFK invoke the term "conscience," they heard the hymn's praise of "Our fathers chained in prisons dark / Were still in heart and conscience free." But by the 1980s, the Protestant Mainstream was collapsing, and Evangelicals assumed the mantle of defending that old-time religion. Traditional Protestants began recognizing that the Catholic notion of conscience – accountability before preexistent moral good and evil – was also their own.



And many Protestants also began to understand that the political invocation of "conscience" was, often enough, being used to bypass that proper understanding, actually ignoring moral good and evil, and instead substituting a secular counterfeit that imagines that a radically free person actually creates rather than encounters moral truths.

Kennedy never tackled the larger conscience question of when political choice and objective moral good clash, at least not in any systematic or thoughtful way. It remains a phantom, haunting how a true Catholic acting in the political realm should bear witness to Catholic principles (and not just pander for Catholic votes), especially since Vatican II insisted on the laity's crucial role ...