Featured Guests:
Stan Horton - Former Enron Executive; President & CEO, Boardwalk Pipeline Partners, LP
Scott Keith - Regional President, North & Central Florida Region, BB&T
Marshall Schminke - BB&T Professor of Business Ethics (Management)
Robert Folger - Distinguished Alumni Endowed Professor in Business Ethics
Merrell Bailey - Managing Partner, Your Caring Law Firm
Episode Transcription:
Stan Horton: I was on the Enron executive committee when the company went bankrupt. I just witnessed firsthand how a company can implode just due to poor ethics. I saw good people do bad things.
Paul Jarley: It's not just about good people doing bad things.
Marshall Schminke: But it's also interesting to figure out why bad people do bad things and good people do good things. Right?
Paul Jarley: It focuses on what people do rather than what authorities say they should do.
Rob Folger: The advent of behavioral ethics was the advent of doing research on what people do and why they do it rather than telling them what they should do.
Paul Jarley: And it might empower people to step forward and question things. Even when it turns out their wrong.
Merrell Bailey: How would you be able to train a teller to say it's okay to tell a client no and we will back you up and you won't lose your job and you won't lose your health insurance and your...
Paul Jarley: Even if you're wrong?
Merrell Bailey: Even if you're wrong.
Paul Jarley: Right.
Paul Jarley: Behavioral ethics holds the promise of helping companies do the right thing. But will firms provide faculty with the access necessary to help them solve their deepest problems? Or, will they just keep them locked up in the closet?
Paul Jarley: This show is all about separating hype from fundamental change. I'm Paul Jarley, Dean of the College of Business here at UCF. I've got lots of questions. To get answers, I'm talking to people with interesting insights into the future of business. Have you ever wondered, "Is This Really a Thing?"
Paul Jarley: On to our show.
Paul Jarley: This podcast is a little different. It was done over drinks and hors d'oeuvres before the Colleges' Deans' Advisory Board Meeting in September. We brought together five people with a common interest in ethics, had a conversation, and edited it down to what you're about to hear. Our guests were:
Paul Jarley: Merrell Bailey. Merle is a four-time alumnus of the College. She's on our Deans' Advisory Board and has degrees in Accounting and Law. Two fields with extensive codes of ethics.
Paul Jarley: Scott Keith is Regional President for BB&T in North and Central Florida. BB&T sponsors both an ethics class in the College as well as the faculty member who teaches that course, Marshall Schminke. Marshall is the BB&T Professor of Business Ethics. He joined us for the evening via Skype because he was speaking at a conference in East France.
Paul Jarley: They're joined by Rob Folger. Rob is considered the Father of Behavioral Ethics. He sits in an endowed position that was funded by our last guest.
Paul Jarley: Stan Horton. We caught up with Stan a couple of weeks after the event and added his insights into the conversation. Stan is an alum of the College and the President and CEO of Boardwalk Pipeline Partners. Stan was the only member of Enron's top management team that was not indicted in the Enron scandal. He closed Enron. It is not a stretch to say that the biggest corporate ethical breach of the last century started a chain of events that led to a whole new way to study ethics and that that is happening at UCF.
Paul Jarley: My first question was for Scott Keith.
Paul Jarley: Could you explain why BB&T has had a long-term interest in ethics and what it hopes to get out of ethics education?
Scott Keith: To BB&T, the people, the values that we have is the culture of our organization. There are three non-negotiables in our organization: our vision, our mission and our values. We want to be the best financial institution possible but the only way that we do that is by living-out ten core value which we deem the ethics of BB&T. We have thirty seven thousand associates; we're bringing new ones on all the time. We think it's critical that we invest in the future of not only BB&T but the future of the markets that we serve. To do that, we have the opportunity to team up with wonderful institutions like UCF's College of Business. For us to be able to partner with Marshall and have a course speaking to young-minded, young professionals with bright futures about ethics and the importance of that in business is helping us live out our mission. It's critical to our culture long-term. We want to hire folks that live that way because they'll fit within our organization.
Paul Jarley: Stan, tell me a little bit about your motivation for giving the gift that led to the Ethics Chair.
Stan Horton: On that, it's pretty easy. I was with Enron. I was on the Enron Executive Committee when the company went bankrupt. I was the only member of the Enron Executive Committee that stayed during the bankruptcy and I just witnessed firsthand how a company can implode just due to poor ethics. I saw good people do bad things that I didn't really know if they knew they were doing bad things at the time. But, some of them compounded themselves and after you look back for while you realized that it was the culture of the company and that culture did not stress or recognize strong ethical behavior. When you don't do that, over time, the culture deteriorates and what happened to Enron, happens.
Paul Jarley: I'm going to turn to Rob. Rob, you're considered one of the founders of behavioral ethics. I'd like you to talk a little bit about how behavioral ethics maybe differs from traditional ethical approaches and training.
Rob Folger: Sure, let me say, first of all, thanks to Stan because part of what behavioral ethics is today is because of him, is because of his support. Ethics, for me, or in business schools, for example, it was dominated by philosophers and so ethics was about ethical philosophy.
Paul Jarley: Aristotle, right, if we want to go all the way back?
Rob Folger: And so, the advent of behavioral ethics was the advent of doing research on what people do and why they do it rather than telling them what they should do. The kinds of things that Scott, for example, wants to be able to promote, how do you promote it? What motivates people besides the inspiration of the leadership of a company when they're in the trenches?
Paul Jarley: Marshal, do you think its fair to say that behavioral ethics is the study of how and why good people do bad things?
Marshall Schminke: A lot of people would agree that that's a pretty reasonable place to start. But, I think we go beyond that as well because it is interesting to try to understand why good people do bad things. But it's also interesting to figure out why bad people do bad things and good people do good things. Right? My big epiphany came; I spent eight years a an academic fellow with the Ethics and Compliance Initiative. They're a group of about sixty or so Chief Ethics Officers from Fortune 50 level firms and people from the SEC and VA and that sort of thing. You don't have to spend very many years with a group like that to figure out what they're interested in is what levers do we pull to get the sorts of behaviors and the sort of commitment that we need to see among our ninety thousand employees.
Paul Jarley: How about you Rob? Would you agree with that?
Rob Folger: Oh, yeah. Oh, absolutely, I think that the experience of people in business many times is they don't always know the levers to pull the buttons to push in a positive, promotive way.
Paul Jarley: Merrell, you have degrees in two areas which have had a long history of ethical codes of behavior, and training people to abide by those ethical codes of behavior, and so talk a little bit about what's been the traditional approach in accounting and in legal areas to questions of ethics and what you think might be the value of behavioral ethics, or not.
Merrell Bailey: Well to quote Marshall, my epiphany was realizing that two different professions, because I'm licensed as a CPA and also as an attorney, can have different ethical standards that are completely diametrically opposed. I don't think most professions realize that they have different ethical standards. So the ethical standard for a CPA is, for auditors, they're supposed to keep everyone informed and share information on an equal playing field. And attorneys, we have to advocate for one person and forget all the rest. I've got this information, I'm going to use this information and I'm not sharing it and, in fact, it would be a breach of my duty if I did share it. So, I think that's part of the tension of CPA's working with attorneys because the CPA is like, "Well if we all would work together and you gave up this we, and I gave up that, we'd all have a really great solution" and the attorney is like, "Screw you. I've got my client and I want all of the pie".
Merrell Bailey: Every single profession that I deal with has a different ethical