Important note: every case in this episode is completely fictitious. The scenarios are teaching constructs, invented to illustrate patterns of clinical reasoning. No case describes a real patient, and any resemblance to any individual is entirely coincidental.
In ECMO, the hard part is almost never the cannulation. Putting cannulas in and troubleshooting hypoxia are learnable. What's hard is the decision — and there's no textbook for it.
In this episode Mike and Calum work through four invented scenarios. In each one, Mike takes Calum to the point where a decision has to be made, asks what he'd do, and then reveals what happened. Every scenario has more than one entirely defensible answer, and in every one a cognitive bias is quietly doing the deciding.
We start with a young man who needs ECMO for trauma-related lung injury — and also has a traumatic brain injury. The reflex is that you can't anticoagulate intracranial contusions, but that reflex rests on an assumption modern circuits no longer require, and it crowds out one of the best prognostic groups we ever see. That's base rate neglect.
Then a patient at day forty, where a phrase appears in the notes almost daily: "he's been on for forty days." The number has become the argument. Duration isn't a diagnosis — and asking a different question ("what specifically is stopping him weaning?") turns up something entirely fixable. That's anchoring, with availability bias underneath it.
The third scenario is the subtlest, because nobody does anything wrong. A young woman is treated for severe pneumonia, correctly. Then she starts bleeding, and it's blamed on the anticoagulation — also a completely satisfying explanation. Two plausible answers in a row, each of which stops anyone completing the diagnosis. That's search satisficing, and it ends with a thirty-second rule you can use tomorrow.
The last scenario ends badly, deliberately. A single word in a CT report — "fibrosis" — carries a certainty the imaging doesn't support. A time-limited trial of steroids is agreed, with a review date set in advance. It doesn't work, and the patient dies. And the decision was still reasonable. Judging it by the result would be outcome bias — which leads to the most uncomfortable idea in the episode: when you decline, you almost never find out you were wrong, so the only errors you can see are the ones where you acted.
We finish with the full list — availability, conjunction, overconfidence, representativeness, diagnostic momentum, commission bias, the IKEA effect — and the one to end on, the GI Joe fallacy: the tendency to think that knowing about cognitive bias is enough to overcome it. It isn't. So we close with four things that genuinely help, none of which are clever.
Chapters
Key takeaways
References / further reading
This podcast is for medical education for healthcare professionals. It is not clinical advice. All cases are entirely fictitious and were created for teaching purposes only; they do not describe real patients. Always follow your own centre's guidelines and current local policy.