Dan and Carl dive into Discipline by King Crimson for a Convince Me! episode. Dan brings the 1981 reinvention-era Crimson to Carl, who’s heard of the band more than he’s actually heard the band. What follows is a deeply nerdy, musically technical, and surprisingly heartfelt discussion about prog rock, mis-buying albums as teenagers, King Diamond confusion, interlocking guitar madness, Adrian Belew’s vocal chops, Fripp’s strict musical geometry, and why this seven-track album still hits like a brick of ideas.
They break down each song, calling out rhythmic trickery, Chapman Stick wizardry, Talking Heads DNA, Zappa-esque spoken-word chaos, unexpectedly gorgeous balladry, and the political undercurrent inside “Thela Hun Ginjeet.” Carl even makes a compelling case that the entire record functions as a narrative arc.
By the end, Carl is fully convinced: Discipline outperforms a chunk of the official Rolling Stone list.
