“Which would be worse… to live as a monster, or to die as a good man?”
Join Ian, Liam & Kev for our 306th episode as we board the ferry to Ashecliffe and plunge headfirst into the mist, trauma, and unreliable memories of Martin Scorsese’s Shutter Island (2010). Megs? She’s not with us this week — she insisted on exploring Ward C “just for a quick look” and the gates slammed shut behind her. We’re hoping she’ll be released pending evaluation.
This week we discuss:
- How Scorsese blends noir, horror, and psychological drama into one of the most atmospheric films of the 2010s.
- Leonardo DiCaprio’s performance — genius unraveling, or a masterclass in controlled chaos?
- Mark Ruffalo’s deceptively calm presence — partner, puppet, or something much more unsettling?
- Are we naturally prejudiced to think Ben Kingsley is the villain because he's British?
- How does Scorsese take a psychological thriller and masquerade it within both a whodunnit and a conspiracy film
- Which special effects had us marveling at their ingenuity and which ones had us reaching for our Resties ballots?
- How could the narrative alignment choices made by Scorsese have gone terribly wrong
- Ian breaks down the film’s narrative structure — why repeated viewings make the film richer, not clearer.
- Liam asks whether the film asks too much from the viewer
- How trauma, denial, and memory shape the film’s psychological core — and why the story hits different every rewatch.
- B-Tech Kev picks up on some subtleties and asks if we saw what he saw whilst Ian talks about how the ability to pause and rewind has changed cinema
- Genre blending: is Shutter Island a detective mystery, a horror film, or a psychological portrait of grief?
- The lighthouse reveal — one of Scorsese’s most tension-filled sequences.
- We debate the meaning of the ending, Teddy’s awareness, and that final chilling line.
- And finally, whether Shutter Island is the Best Film Ever — or simply the most beautifully disorienting mind maze Scorsese ever built.
Become a Patron of this podcast and support the BFE at https://www.patreon.com/BFE.
Find out more about Juleen's nephew, Castor, and how you can help at https://gofund.me/73a67a9d6
We are extremely thankful to our following Patrons for their most generous support:
- Juleen from It Goes Down In The PM
- Hermes Auslander
- James DeGuzman
- Synthia
- Shai Bergerfroind
- Ariannah Who Loves BFE The Most
- Andy Dickson
- Chris Pedersen
- Duane Smith (Duane Smith!)
- Randal Silva
- Nate The Great
- Rev Bruce
- Cheezy (with a fish on a bike)
- Richard
- Ryan Kuketz
- Dirk Diggler
- Stew from the Stew World Order podcast
- NorfolkDomus
- John Humphrey's Right Foot
- Timmy Tim Tim
- Aashrey
- Paul Komoroski
Buy some BFE merch at https://my-store-b4e4d4.creator-spring.com/.
Massive thanks to Lex Van Den Berghe for the use of Mistake by Luckydog. Catch more from Lex's new band, The Maids of Honor, at https://soundcloud.com/themaidsofhonor.
Also, massive thanks to Moonlight Social for our age game theme song. You can catch more from them at https://www.moonlightsocialmusic.com/
