Description

On December 9th, 2001, novelist Michael Peterson called 911 from his Durham, North Carolina home, saying his wife Kathleen had fallen down the stairs. But when first responders arrived, what they found raised far more questions than answers.

Kathleen’s injuries, the blood evidence, and Michael’s story didn’t seem to align — sparking one of the most infamous and debated true crime cases of the last two decades. Was it an accident? A brutal murder? Or something stranger… like the infamous “owl theory”?

What We Cover:

• Kathleen’s final night and the 911 call that began the case
• The crime scene evidence and why investigators doubted a fall
• The shocking twists: Michael’s secret life and a past staircase death
• The trial, conviction, and eventual Alford plea
• The “owl theory” — could a wild animal have played a role?
• Our own thoughts and theories on what really happened

⚠️ Content Warning:

This episode includes discussions of violent death and graphic injuries. Listener discretion is advised.

Join the Discussion:

What do you believe happened to Kathleen Peterson? Accident, murder, or something else? Share your thoughts with us:

• Instagram: @DeadEndsPod
• TikTok: @DeadEndsPod
• Email: deadendspod2025@gmail.com