Forgiveness has a pace of its own, and sometimes the most honest thing we can do is admit we're not there yet. This episode explores what it means to give ourselves (and each other) permission to be in process, without the pressure to be further along than we actually are.
LINKS:
Book of Forgiving | Connect | YouTube | Coming Up
TRANSCRIPT:
- Brief framing before reading:
- We're talking about forgiveness in this series. About what happens when someone hurts us — or when we hurt someone else. And about the choices we have when that happens.
- I'm going to read you the first half of a book today. We're going to stop in the middle on purpose because the most important part of the story for TODAY is actually what happens right... here. And we're going to finish it next week.
- Read first half of Wally and Freya.
- Brief unpack after reading:
- What's happening in the story: someone got hurt. Both of them, actually. And now they have a choice.
- Two roads: get even, stay hurt… OR something harder, and maybe even braver.
- Forgiveness doesn't always happen right away. It takes practice. And the very first steps are: tell somebody you trust what happened, and then tell about what it felt like.
- When somebody does something that hurts me, I feel sad, and kind of mad. Sometimes it feels like I don’t matter much to them. Just saying that out loud is an important thing to do!
- In the story, Wally and Freya are both sad. Both hurt. And now they have a choice to make. So do we. We'll find out what they choose next week.
The Stone — Kids Practice
- Give each child a stone.
- This stone is like the hurt we carry when someone has hurt our feelings, or our bodies, or our hearts. It has some weight to it, just like the hurt does.
- You can return to your seats and work in their special kids Sunday Paper:
- Trace the stone on the paper.
- Inside the tracing, write or draw what the hurt is.
- Hold onto your stone. We're going to do something with it in a few minutes, everybody together.
- You can also listen in to what I’m saying, if you want to hear more about forgiving!
Catching Everybody Up//Recap
- Welcome anyone who is new or wasn't here Week 1. I want to do a brief recap:
- We're in a series called The Book of Forgiving, drawing from Archbishop Desmond Tutu and his daughter Mpho's important work on what forgiveness actually is, and how to do it.
- The Tutus aren't theorists. Desmond Tutu chaired South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission. Mpho lost her husband to violent crime. These are people who have earned the right to talk about this.
- Their framework is called the Fourfold Path: Telling the Story → Naming the Hurt → Granting Forgiveness → Renewing or Releasing the Relationship.
- In wk 1 we looked at the first step: Telling the Story. Today: Naming the Hurt.
- The big idea underneath all of it: We desperately need an imagination bigger than the revenge cycle we live inside culturally. That cycle is everywhere— in our politics, our entertainment, our instincts. The Tutus show us a different road.
The Problem with How We Do Forgiveness
- Let's be honest about why forgiveness is so hard to practice, even for people who believe in it.
- We've collapsed forgiveness into remorse. Someone says "sorry!"— maybe genuinely, maybe not— and suddenly the pressure shifts entirely to the person who was hurt: Now you have to forgive. We skip the whole middle. That's not forgiveness. That's cruel urgency dressed up as something kind.
- We've made forgetting the goal. But the Tutus are clear: forgetting is not only impossible, it's actually counterproductive. Memory is part of how we protect ourselves. Part of how we stay honest. Forgiveness is not amnesia.
- We've weaponized it. In religious spaces especially, "forgive" has been used to protect people who caused harm and to silence people who were hurt. When forgiveness gets wielded as a command that bypasses accountability — when it becomes "Jesus says you have to forgive, so stop talking about what happened" — that is not sacred or faithful. That is abusive.
- And yet — Jesus does make forgiveness an ultimate, limitless command. Seventy times seven. God forgives without limit; our response is gratitude and extending that same grace. So how do we hold both? How do we take forgiveness seriously without letting it become a weapon?
- The answer is: we stop skipping the important steps.
Forgiveness Cannot Be Rushed
- The Fourfold Path is a path… it has an order for a reason.
- You cannot get to granting forgiveness without first telling the story and naming the hurt. Trying to skip there is what creates the toxic, pressured, performative version of forgiveness we've all experienced. And we’ll get into this later in the series, but granting forgiveness has nothing to do with the decision to either renegotiate or release that relationship.
- Forgiveness needs to be as slow as it needs to be. It has a pace of its own. That pace deserves to be honored.
- (Callback to the stone practice from Week 1): Did anybody actually hold that stone in their non-dominant hand for six hours this week? What was that like?
- [[funny?]] That's the point. Six hours felt like a lot. Some of us have been carrying something for six years. Or sixty. It deserves time.
The Second Step: Naming the Hurt
- So what does it actually mean to name the hurt?
- It starts with telling your story… to yourself? To God? To people you trust. Not to everyone. Not on social media. Not to the first person who will listen. To the right people, in a safe space.
- The Tutus: Tell your story first to a friend, loved one, or trusted person. That’s a good place to start.
- There is a reason confession exists across almost every spiritual tradition. Not as a transaction, but as the practice of being heard without being fixed.
- What naming the hurt does:
- It begins to move what happened from something that is happening to you — constantly, on loop — into something that happened, that you can now begin to look at.
- Bessel van der Kolk: the body keeps what the mind won't name. When we give language to an experience, we move it from the body's alarm system into the part of the brain that can begin to process it.
- The Tutus frame it this way: Identify the feelings within the facts. The facts are WHAT HAPPENED. The feelings are what it COST you.
- What naming the hurt does NOT do:
- It does not mean what was done to you was okay.
- It does not mean you've forgiven anything yet.
- It does not mean you owe anyone resolution.
- But there is something that begins to shift. There is relief– which to be clear, is not the same as justice, and not the same as healing, but real relief— when the hurt stops being the main character in your story because you finally named it out loud.
- The Tutus again: No feeling is wrong, bad, or invalid. Move forward when you are ready.
We Are Only Human With Other Humans
- This is why we do this together. Not because community is always safe — sometimes it isn't. But because we cannot become fully human alone.
- The Tutus: We do not heal in isolation. Connecting with others is how we develop compassion for others and for ourselves.
- What makes a good witness to someone naming their hurt? The Tutus give us a short, countercultural list:
- Listen.
- Do not try to fix the pain.
- Do not minimize the loss.
- Do not offer advice.
- Offer your love and your caring.
- That's it. Stay in the room. Don't flinch. Don't fix. That is one of the most profound gifts one human can offer another.
Invitation: The Stone Practice
- Now we're all going to do something together— kids and adults.
- Invite everyone to pick up or find their stone.
- Walk them through the Tutus' "Clenching the Stone" practice (Book of Forgiving, Chapter 5):
- Take your stone in your dominant hand.
- Think of a hurt you are carrying right now. Name it… silently, or under your breath. As you name it, clench the stone in your fist.
- Now open your hand. As you release your fist, release the hurt — not forever, not resolved, just... set down for a moment.
- You can clench and release again for each thing you're carrying.
- We're not asking you to be over it. We're not asking you to forgive it yet. We're just asking you to name it, and take the permission you can give yourself to walk the path of forgiving, at a pace that is right for you.
- That's enough for today. That's the work.