Want to know whether AI has a place in your writing process? This is the first episode in a four-part series on AI and nonfiction writing, and we’re starting with the most important question: what happens when you let an LLM make creative choices for you?
Before you hand over your outline, your prose, or your voice, it helps to understand what writing actually requires—and what you may lose when generative AI starts making those decisions instead.
In this episode, I explain why I think of writing as a long series of choices, from your topic and structure all the way down to individual words. Then I look at what happens when AI starts making those choices instead, especially in the two areas where I see the biggest problems for nonfiction writers: voice and structure.
I also talk about the difference between generative AI and tools like spellcheck or grammar check, why AI can become especially tempting in the places where you already feel insecure, and why my professional recommendation is to keep generative AI out of the creative writing process.
Key topics
- How large language models generate writing
- Why AI-generated prose can sound clean but still flatten your voice (and how outsourcing word choice keeps you from becoming a stronger writer)
- Why AI-generated book structures often fail to support authors once they start drafting
- The difference between generative AI and tools like spellcheck or grammar check
- Why discernment matters when deciding whether to use a tool
Resources mentioned
Free Memoir Method Checklist
https://pageandpodium.com/checklist
Page & Podium Blog
More writing, revision, publishing, and book-marketing resources:
https://pageandpodium.com/blog
Timestamps
0:00 How Nonfiction Writers Should Think About AI
1:00 Free Memoir Method Checklist
1:33 Why I Went Down the AI Rabbit Hole
4:10 My Concerns About AI
7:03 How I Think About Writing
8:28 Writing Is a Series of Choices
9:54 Choosing Your Topic and Message
11:14 How Structure Creates More Choices
13:08 The Choices We Make While Writing
14:36 How Large Language Models Work
17:20 What AI Is Missing
18:40 The Two Biggest Risks: Voice and Structure
19:01 AI and Your Writing Voice
22:05 Why AI-Generated Structure Can Backfire
23:35 Where I Draw the Line on Generative AI
24:32 What About Grammarly and Spellcheck?
25:14 Discernment and AI
26:14 Why Insecurity Makes AI More Tempting
27:37 My Recommendation for Writers
28:27 Final Reminder: Download the Checklist
This is episode one of a four-part series on AI and nonfiction writing. In the next episode, I’ll walk through how AI is showing up at every stage of the writing and publishing process—and where I think authors need to be especially careful.
Music licensed through Soundstripe.
Code: SB7OK7HA77GWOT7E