What does a book editor actually do? And can you really just hire an editor to fix your manuscript once you've finished writing it?
For first-time authors, "editor" might be the most misunderstood word in publishing. Developmental editors, copy editors, line editors, acquisitions editors, book coaches… they all work with books, but they do very different things. And misunderstanding those differences can lead to some pretty unrealistic expectations about what happens after you finish your first draft.
In part one of this two-part series on what new authors need to know about editors, Dr. Amanda Nell Edgar breaks down three common misconceptions about working with a book editor, including why an editor can't simply fix your manuscript, why AI editing can actually work against your goals, and why even the best manuscripts require multiple rounds of revision.
You'll also hear a real-world case study from Page & Podium author Maryann Hobbie, whose forthcoming memoir, *Less Than*, offers a behind-the-scenes look at how an author and editor work together to strengthen a manuscript over time.
**In this episode, you'll learn:**
- The differences between developmental editing, copy editing, line editing, book coaching, and ghostwriting
- Why hiring an editor doesn't mean you can hand over your first draft and receive a finished book
- Why grammar and sentence-level corrections should come near the end of the revision process
- When hiring a ghostwriter might make more sense than hiring an editor
- How AI editing can make your writing more generic, even when its suggestions seem helpful
- Why a skilled human editor focuses on strengthening your unique voice, perspective, and ideas
- Why editors sometimes identify new problems (or even reverse earlier recommendations) during subsequent revision rounds
- What a collaborative editorial relationship actually looks like, from first draft through production
The goal of editing isn't perfection. It's making your book as strong, distinctive, and meaningful as it can be. And understanding what your editor can and can't do is an important first step.
**RESOURCES MENTIONED IN THIS EPISODE**
**Take the FREE Book Strategy Quiz:** Answer 10 questions and get a personalized recommendation for your next step, a custom podcast playlist, and resources to help you move forward with your manuscript.
https://pageandpodium.com/quiz
**Get a Professional Manuscript Review:** Find out what's working in your manuscript, what needs attention, and how to prioritize your revisions with expert developmental feedback.
https://pageandpodium.com/manuscript
**Editor in Your Pocket — One-on-One Book Coaching:** Work directly with a professional editor to strengthen your writing, develop your ideas, and get support throughout the drafting and revision process.
https://pageandpodium.com/editor-in-your-pocket
**Explore Our Four-Part Series on AI and Nonfiction Writing:** Learn more about the challenges of using generative AI in your writing process, including the importance of editorial discernment and preserving your own voice.
Find the series on the Page & Podium Podcast channel.
**CHAPTERS**
00:00 Why "editor" is the most misunderstood word in publishing
01:16 Why the term is so confusing
03:20 The different editor roles at Page and Podium
07:15 #1: You can't just hire an editor to "fix" your draft
11:30 Why grammar comes last
13:35 Editor vs. ghostwriter
16:38 #2: AI editing vs. a human editor
18:23 The AI predictability paradox
21:45 What a human editor does differently
23:36 #3: Every round of edits finds new things
25:13 Case study: Maryann Hobbie's memoir
32:27 Your editor is your partner
33:57 Free Book Strategy Quiz
**ABOUT PAGE & PODIUM**
Page & Podium helps aspiring authors turn their ideas, experiences, and expertise into powerful nonfiction books. Through book coaching, ghostwriting, manuscript reviews, and publishing services, we help authors bring their stories to life and share them with the world.
Explore our services and resources: https://pageandpodium.com
Subscribe to the Page & Podium Podcast for weekly conversations about writing, revising, and publishing memoir and nonfiction books.
#BookEditing #WritingANonfictionBook #FirstTimeAuthor
Music licensed through Soundstripe.
Code: JHOVFRLLBNAZURUE