Stillwater Edge Podcast - Episode #28: Pontoon Boats vs. Float Tubes – Which One Should You Choose?
Hook: If you’re getting serious about Stillwater fishing, you’ve probably asked yourself—should I get a float tube or a pontoon boat? Both have their place, but which one actually fits your fishing style? In this episode, I break down the pros, cons, and key differences to help you make the right choice.
Key Takeaways from This Episode
Why Use an Inflatable Watercraft for Stillwater Fishing?
- Access More Water – No more being stuck on shore.
- Stealthy Approach – No motors, no noise, no spooked fish.
- Affordable & Transportable – No trailer needed, easy to store.
Now, let’s battle it out: Float Tube vs. Pontoon Boat.
Float Tubes – The Ultralight Choice
✅ Pros:
- Lightweight & Compact – Easily fits in a backpack for hiking into remote lakes.
- Affordable – Great entry-level option.
- Super Stealthy – Minimal wake, no noise, perfect for spooky fish.
- Quick Setup – Inflate and launch in minutes.
❌ Cons:
- Limited Mobility – You rely on kicking to move, which is exhausting.
- Wind Sensitivity – Hard to stay in position, difficult in rough weather.
- Low Casting Position – Back casts often slap the water.
- Cold Exposure – Your legs are in the water, meaning spring and fall fishing can be brutal.
👤 Best For:
- Hikers who want a portable, ultra-light setup.
- Anglers on a tight budget.
- Fishing small, calm lakes with little wind.
Pontoon Boats – Power & Versatility
✅ Pros:
- Better Mobility – Oars make moving across the lake much easier than kicking.
- Higher Seating Position – Easier casting, better visibility for spotting fish.
- More Storage – Extra room for rods, tackle, and even a trolling motor.
- Handles Wind & Larger Lakes – More stable than a float tube.
❌ Cons:
- Heavier & Bulkier – Harder to transport and set up.
- More Expensive – Costs more than a float tube.
- Takes Up More Space – Requires a truck, roof rack, or extra storage space.
👤 Best For:
- Anglers who fish larger lakes and want better mobility.
- Those who prefer comfort and storage options.
- Anyone who wants the option of adding a trolling motor.
The Verdict – Which One Should You Choose?
🔹 Go with a FLOAT TUBE if…
- You prioritize portability and want an affordable option.
- You fish small, sheltered lakes with little wind.
- You want something easy to carry into remote waters.
🔹 Go with a PONTOON BOAT if…
- You want better mobility, comfort, and stability.
- You fish larger lakes and windier conditions.
- You need extra storage for gear and a potential motor setup.
🏆 Greg’s Pick: Pontoon Boat – More mobility, more stability, and overall a better investment for serious Stillwater anglers. But for hiking into remote lakes, a float tube still has its place.
Final Thoughts
Your fishing style, conditions, and priorities will determine which one is right for you. Either way, upgrading from the shore to an inflatable watercraft will change the way you fish Stillwater forever.
Call to Action:
What’s your go-to Stillwater setup? **Float tube let me know on social @stillwateredge !
