The open road tempts us with adventure and anonymity...but sometimes “death in disguise” is waiting on the side of the road. This episode covers two jaw-dropping incidents of hitchhiking gone nightmarishly awry, one on the ride back from New Orleans (Jett Simmons McBride & Caleb “Kai” McGillvary), the other a wild goose-chase from North Carolina to Vermont (Gary Sampson). Hosts Kimberly and Edward reveal which one of THEM is the survivor of an actual highway abduction, and two surprise guests pop by to “judge” our storytellers' submissions.