Is there a middle ground between open borders and immigration restriction? This thought-provoking discussion with GOP strategist Mike Madrid and Venezuelan immigrant Dr. Daniel DiMartino explores the complex realities of America's immigration debate beyond the partisan talking points.
The experts delve into surprising data showing how education levels dramatically impact immigrant outcomes - college-educated immigrants are approximately 1,000 times less likely to commit crimes than those without high school diplomas. Canada's points-based system provides a compelling alternative model where immigration levels remain high but public support stays strong because immigrants integrate successfully.
What makes this conversation particularly timely is the shifting political landscape around immigration. Latino voters dramatically swung toward Republicans in 2024, partly due to border security concerns. Meanwhile, red states increasingly depend on immigrant labor to fill critical workforce gaps. This creates a unique opportunity for comprehensive reform that balances security, economic needs, and America's tradition as a nation of immigrants.
Perhaps most fascinating is the cultural dimension rarely discussed in immigration debates. At a time when confidence in American institutions is collapsing, immigrants often bring renewed faith in the American dream. "The average immigrant believes more in America and wants other countries to look more like America than the average native-born person," notes DiMartino. This aspirational energy represents a vital cultural resource our divided nation desperately needs.
While both experts remain pessimistic about the chances for comprehensive reform before the 2026 midterms, they outline how Republicans could potentially reshape immigration policy on their terms while addressing legitimate economic and security concerns. The discussion offers a rare glimpse of what pragmatic, evidence-based immigration reform might actually look like beyond the heated rhetoric dominating our public discourse.
Listen now to understand why immigration may be the key to addressing America's demographic challenges, economic needs, and even our crisis of confidence in the American experiment itself.
Support Our Work
The Center for Demographics and Policy focuses on research and analysis of global, national, and regional demographic trends and explores policies that might produce favorable demographic results over time. It involves Chapman students in demographic research under the supervision of the Center’s senior staff.
Students work with the Center’s director and engage in research that will serve them well as they look to develop their careers in business, the social sciences, and the arts. Students also have access to our advisory board, which includes distinguished Chapman faculty and major demographic scholars from across the country and the world.
For additional information, please contact Mahnaz Asghari, Associate Director for the Center for Demographics and Policy, at (714) 744-7635 or asghari@chapman.edu.
Follow us on LinkedIn:
https://www.linkedin.com/company/the-feudal-future-podcast/
Tweet thoughts: @joelkotkin, @mtoplansky, #FeudalFuture #BeyondFeudalism
Learn more about Joel's book 'The Coming of Neo-Feudalism': https://amzn.to/3a1VV87
Sign Up For News & Alerts: http://joelkotkin.com/#subscribe
This show is presented by the Chapman Center for Demographics and Policy, which focuses on research and analysis of global, national and regional demographic trends and explores policies that might produce favorable demographic results over time.
