⚠️ OLD FORMAT EPISODE - New listeners should start with Season 1, Episode 1
She looked like the girl next door. Polite, well-dressed, maybe a little flustered. But behind the lace gloves? A master manipulator who pulled off some of the slickest thefts in Gilded Age America...without ever brandishing a weapon.
THE STORY: Bertha Liebbeke, aka "The Nebraska Siren," aka "Fainting Bertha" | Active 1891-1894 | Used Victorian femininity as weapon | Signature move: fake fainting spells in stores | While staff rushed to help, she'd steal jewelry, cash, merchandise | Targeted department stores across Midwest | Always impeccably dressed (often in stolen clothes) | Played damsel in distress to perfection | Would claim illness, pregnancy complications, family emergencies | Store clerks fell for it every time | Arrested multiple times, talked her way out repeatedly | Eventually convicted and imprisoned
HER METHODS: The Fainting Spell - collapse dramatically, steal during chaos | The Distraction - engage clerk while accomplice looted | The Sympathy Play - tears, pregnancy claims, tragedy | The Wardrobe Con - dress like wealthy society woman | The Charm Offensive - flirt, flatter, manipulate | Never violent, always theatrical
WHAT WE EXPLORE: How femininity became her greatest weapon | Victorian gender expectations she exploited | Psychology of the fainting damsel con | Why clerks never suspected her | How appearance creates assumptions | The "respectable woman" shield | Why her methods still work today
THE CONTEXT: 1890s America - strict gender roles | Women expected delicate, helpless | Fainting considered normal feminine behavior | Department stores newly popular | No security cameras | Chivalry demanded men assist "distressed" women | Perfect environment for Bertha's cons
THE PSYCHOLOGY: Exploited gender stereotypes | Used social expectations as camouflage | Understood cognitive biases (pretty = trustworthy) | Theatricality made cons believable | Never broke character | Turned vulnerability into power | Master of social engineering before term existed
SOURCES: Omaha Bee (1891-1894) | The Inter Ocean (Chicago) (1893) | Captured & Exposed case file | Old Spirituals biography | Nebraska State Historical Society | Newspapers.com archives | Mugshot Mysteries YouTube episode
VIEW MUGSHOT: https://capturedandexposed.com/2021/03/19/fainting-bertha/
DISCLAIMER: For educational/entertainment purposes only. Based on historical newspaper archives. We are not historians or psychologists. Views explore Victorian gender dynamics and criminal psychology, not endorsement of theft or manipulation. Bertha Liebbeke was convicted. We respect all victims. This examines how social expectations and gender stereotypes can be weaponized.
She never carried a weapon. She never needed to. Her lace gloves were enough.
Stay curious. Stay suspicious.
👀 Want more? Follow us @MugshotMysteries on TikTok and Instagram for case photos, crime scene breakdowns, and stories too wild for the full episode.
⭐ Leave a rating—it helps other true crime obsessives find us.
🎧 New episodes drop weekly on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and everywhere you listen.
Stay curious. Stay suspicious. See you next week with another face... and another mystery
