Did everything right and life still fell apart? You are not alone, and it might not mean what you fear.
Sharon Edmundson opens the tougher teachings of Jesus with one of His hardest promises — "in this world you will have trouble." It is not a verse anyone pins on their wall. But Sharon makes the case that it is actually good news, because the same sentence ends "take heart, I have overcome the world." This is honest talk about why following Jesus doesn't hand you a trouble-free life, why that isn't a sign you've failed, and how to hold on when the answers don't come. Anna Kettle and Dave Connolly carry the conversation on from there, with the community joining in live.
Sharon starts with John 16:33 — "in this world you will have trouble." Not might. Will. For anyone who assumed faith would smooth everything out, that lands hard. But Sharon reframes it as a kindness. If we believe being a Christian guarantees a trouble-free life, then when trouble hits we blame ourselves, or doubt whether God loves us, and we can throw our faith away for no reason.
"It doesn't even say you might have trouble, it says you will." — Sharon Edmundson
Sharon walks through the different sorts. There is the trouble we bring on ourselves through our own choices. There is broken-world trouble — illness, grief, miscarriage, the endless job search, abuse — the kind that hits everyone regardless of what they believe. And there is the trouble that comes as a cost of faith, from Paul's beatings and prison to the milder cultural pressure and workplace friction believers can face in the UK today. Ephesians 6 adds that some of it is a spiritual battle we can't see.
The verse doesn't stop at trouble. "Take heart, I have overcome the world." Sharon points out that Jesus said this like a commander steadying His soldiers right before battle — knowing He was about to be betrayed and that His closest friends would scatter. "The world" here means the human systems that ignore God, and the evil at work behind them. And God is greater than all of it.
Sharon holds two stories side by side. In Acts 5 an angel breaks Peter out of prison. Just two chapters later, Stephen is stoned to death — carried, even then, by a vision of heaven opened. She tells it from her own life too. Diagnosed with skin cancer last year, she experienced deep peace, a skilled surgical team and a Christian anaesthetist praying for her, and a good outcome. A colleague with the same diagnosis died a few months ago — yet she was carried by God's peace and the hope that death wasn't the end. Same God. Two very different roads.
"Jesus dying on the cross looked like a big failure, but in fact it was part of God's rescue plan." — Sharon Edmundson
There is real mystery here. We don't get the full "why" this side of eternity, and Sharon doesn't pretend otherwise.
Where the talk ends and the real conversation begins.
"Even if not" — Dave on Daniel 3. Dave took the theme back to Shadrach, Meshach and Abednego, facing the furnace in Daniel 3. Their line — our God is able to rescue us, and He will, but even if He does not, we still won't bow — became the heart of the segment. God can, God will, but even if He chooses not to, He has a bigger plan.
"God can, God will, but should He not, He has a greater plan." — Dave Connolly
The cheap gospel. Dave was blunt about a version of faith that promises everyone a better life the moment they come to Jesus. He called it cheap, and said it sets people up to fall away when trouble comes. Following Jesus isn't an upgrade or a do-over — it's handing over your life. He and Anna agreed the church carries a responsibility not to undersell that.
The temporary fix and the eternal one. Anna shared something from Tyler Staton, speaking at Wildfires over the summer, that stuck with her. Even when God steps in and heals now, it's a temporary fix — the person will still face the end of life one day. The permanent solution is the hope of eternity that believers already hold.
Can you lose your salvation? Anna put the deep one to Dave directly. His honest answer, drawn from his own story of walking away for a couple of years and coming back, is that he doesn't believe you can lose something freely given — you can't stop being God's child any more than his own kids can stop being his. He held it gently, admitting he swings between the two views, and pointed to the thief on the cross as proof that God's heart is bigger than getting all the answers right.
A closing caution from Sharon. Sharon ended with something important. Trouble coming against us doesn't mean it's God's will — He tells us to pray for His kingdom to come on earth as it is in heaven precisely because His will is not always what happens. She was especially clear for anyone in an abusive or unsafe situation — do not read your circumstances as God's will, and know that God is not asking you to stay there.
From the community. Alicia wrote in that being able to bring our frustrations to God is an underrated ability — even angry, she still senses Him with her. Ellis shared an honest struggle: God never promised a specific outcome, so how do you sit with the "what if" of things going wrong? And Talita offered the flip side — for her, hard seasons have grown her faith rather than shaken it, which the hosts tied back to how deep the roots go.
"Once you've known God's presence, you can't unknow it again." — Anna Kettle
Crowd Church — a community for those who might not see the point of church.