For this episode of the Colleague Down the Hall podcast, a group of colleagues join me to discuss a complex case involving a client who is dealing with grief and depression following the death of a childhood friend in a car accident. We delve into the consequences of a therapist's decision to research a client's background information without their consent, the implications of this action for trust and disclosure within the therapeutic setting, and how to handle the resulting ethical dilemma and personal internal conflict.The discussion revolves around how to address the ethical implications, manage countertransference, and whether to disclose the unauthorized research to the client, all while considering the potential impact on their therapeutic relationship and exploring avenues for professional consultation and personal reflection to navigate these challenges.
“I think I feel like Jeanene, I'm on the same page as you is that I try to be as authentic and transparent as possible. And I feel like it would be really hard for me to be able to have that information and not share it and not be able to be fully present. I'm there to help support my client if they didn't know that I knew that information, I mean I just feel like that, for me, it's kind of like an ethical thing of being able to be open and honest and say, ‘Hey, I messed up, I made a mistake’, you know, and I just feel like as a clinician we’re the instrument, it could come out in nonverbals, or a way of like, that you're judging that you don't realize is coming out in your face or your body language or something like that. And that's, I think that's what I would have a hard time with.”-Beth Maples
Here are the key takeaways:
Importance of Professional Boundaries and Ethics: The situation underscores the ethical dilemma of researching clients outside of the therapeutic setting without their consent. It raises questions about privacy, trust, and the potential impact on the therapeutic relationship.
Dealing with Countertransference: The therapist's personal history with a similar situation creates internal conflict and countertransference, highlighting the need for therapists to be aware of their personal feelings and biases that may affect their work.
Client Disclosure and Trust: The case illustrates the complexities of client disclosure. Clients may withhold information for various reasons, including shame, fear, or not being ready to confront certain aspects of their experience. It points to the need for building a strong therapeutic alliance where clients feel safe to share sensitive information.
Impact of Therapist Actions on the Therapeutic Relationship: The therapist's action of researching the client's history without consent poses a risk to the therapeutic relationship, potentially leading to loss of trust and affecting the client's willingness to open up. It serves as a cautionary tale about the repercussions of crossing ethical boundaries.
Transparency and Repairing the Relationship: The discussion about whether and how to disclose the therapist's actions to the client touch on the principles of transparency, honesty, and accountability in therapy. It explores the potential benefits and risks of such disclosure for the therapeutic process.
Decision-Making in Gray Areas: The case illustrates the complexity of decision-making in therapy, especially in situations where there's no clear right or wrong answer. It highlights the need for therapists to carefully consider the ethical, legal, and clinical implications of their decisions.
Self-Compassion and Human Error: Finally, the conversation emphasizes the importance of self-compassion and acknowledging human error within the practice of therapy. It encourages professionals to learn from mistakes and use them as opportunities for growth, rather than sources of shame.
Connect with Jeanene:
*Get your free Four Keys to Private Practice Peace of Mind workbook: https://collaboasis.com/4keysworkbook
*Learn more about clinical consultation groups: https://collaboasis.com/
*Join my free therapist Facebook group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/oasispcgt
*Connect on LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/in/jeanene-wolfe-lcsw-64042220a/
