Welcome to another fascinating episode of Preserving History and Democracy! In this episode, hosts Cynthia and Bern sit down with historian Professor Christopher Schurtz to explore the remarkable — and often mysterious — history of Shalam Colony and the Faithist community that once called it home.
Professor Schurtz begins by sharing how he first became interested in this unique chapter of American history before introducing John Ballou Newbrough, the visionary behind the Oahspe, a spiritual text that inspired the founding of the Faithist movement. He explains what the Oahspe taught, what the Faithists believed, and how those beliefs led to the creation of a utopian settlement known as Shalam Colony in Doña Ana County, New Mexico.
Listeners will also hear about Andrew Howland, another key founder, and the group's ambitious goals — including their efforts to raise children within the community's ideals. Professor Schurtz discusses historical deeds documenting the purchase of the colony's land, how the local community reacted to the group's arrival, and how newspapers of the time portrayed Newbrough and his followers.
The conversation delves into the daily life at Shalam, illustrated through rare photographs, as well as the challenges the Faithists faced — from lawsuits to internal struggles. Professor Schurtz sheds light on the colony's children, why their names were changed, and what became of them after the community dissolved.
The episode also covers Newbrough's death, Howland's continued efforts to sustain the movement, and the later development of Levitica Colony, an inclusive settlement that welcomed non-Faithists and people of all races. Schurtz even touches on Newbrough's daughter and her reflections on her father's legacy.
Finally, the story takes a chilling turn when Professor Schurtz reveals a mysterious discovery in the archives — a marriage license signed by John Newbrough himself, years after his death.
Join us for this deep dive into a forgotten utopian experiment that blended faith, community, and controversy in the deserts of New Mexico.
Hosted by: Bernardine Caporale, Cynthia Mendoza
Special Guest: Christopher Schurtz
Produced by: Bernardine Caporale, Cynthia Mendoza, Jacob Slaughter
Edited by: Jacob Slaughter
