Episode 68: Normally the team hunts for the perfect slice of savory pizza, but York, Pennsylvania serves up a far darker dish. In this episode, we investigate one of York PA's most disturbing legends: the Fiji Cannibal Dwarf and the infamous events tied to the historic Penn Hotel. The story goes that the Fiji Cannibal Dwarf died at the Penn Hotel and was allegedly eaten, turning the site into one of the most talked about pieces of true crime folklore in Pennsylvania history. Buried in a potter's field in York, his story refused to stay underground. When the grave was later exhumed, the body was gone, sparking rumors of grave robbing, desecration, and lingering paranormal activity. As we explore the Penn Hotel location and surrounding historic sites in York PA, we sift through local legends, ghost stories, and documented accounts, encountering echoes of the past that refuse to rest. Is this simply a grotesque chapter of American history, or does something still linger where this unholy meal took place? Grab a slice of pizza and join us as we unravel one of York Pennsylvania's strangest mysteries, blending paranormal investigation, dark history, urban legend, and true crime into a story that still unsettles the city today. Sources: Spooky York Pennsylvania by Scott D. Butcher and Dinah Roseberry 2008 York Daily Newspaper- May 15, 1872 True Democrat Newspaper The Beauga Republican- March 6, 1872 Perry County Democrat - May 22, 1872 P. T. Barnum's "Struggles and Triumphs, Forty Years Recollection" 1872 James Shettells "Circus Scrap Book" Sites: www.holyhoundtaproom.com
