Two bored kids invent the legend of The LetterMan - a ghost who demands a reply to his final, unfinished letter. But when Halloween rolls around, the boys realize that there may be forces at work beyond their control.
If You Don't Reply was written by Callum Haire and read by Rob Knoll.
Callum Haire on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/hairecallum
Callum Haire on Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/calscareseasy.bsky.social
Subscribe to the podcast & follow The Creepy Corner for more terrifying tales:
IG: https://www.instagram.com/thecreepycornerpod
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@cornertheaterpod
Creative Director / EIC - Annie McGrath
Executive Producers - Annie McGrath & Marisa Cooksey
Sound Mixer & Editor - Matt Keim
Editorial Team - Marisa Cooksey, Melanie Germond, Rob Knoll, Vanessa Loret, Anne Sawyier, Christine Weidner
The Creepy Corner is part of The Corner Theater Podcast Network from Straight to the Point Productions. https://www.straighttothepointproductions.com/
Episode © 2025
