Description

In this episode of The Setlist of Life podcast, the main focus is setting up a new game concept exploring "One Hit Wonders" - examining whether artists labeled as such actually had albums worth revisiting.

The hosts discuss their approach to music categorization and decide to divide decades among themselves: Aaron takes the 1960s, Kirsten the 1970s, Christine the 1980s, and Leslie the 1990s.

Each host researched and selected potential one-hit wonders from their assigned decade:

Aaron's 1960s picks: The Lemon Pipers ("Green Tambourine"), The Chamber Brothers ("Time Has Come Today"), and Tin House ("Slipping and Sliding")

Kirsten's 1970s selections: Manfred Mann Earth Band ("Blinded by the Light"), Blue Swede ("Hooked on a Feeling"), and The Knack ("My Sharona")

Christine's 1980s choices: Modern English ("Melt with You"), Kajagoogoo ("Too Shy"), and A Flock of Seagulls ("I Ran")

Leslie's 1990s picks: Macy Gray ("Try"), Primitive Radio Gods ("Standing Outside a Broken Phone Booth"), and The Toadies ("Possum Kingdom")

The hosts plan to listen to full albums from these artists and discuss whether they deserve more recognition beyond their single hits. The episode ends with plans to start with the 1960s selections in future episodes.

5 Takeaways

1. Music categorization is more complex than decades: Musical movements and genres often span 3-7 year periods that don't align with decade boundaries, making genre-based analysis potentially more meaningful than decade-based analysis.
2. The "one-hit wonder" label may be unfair: Many artists categorized as one-hit wonders may have produced quality albums that deserved more attention, suggesting the need to revisit their complete works.
3. Record industry practices have dramatically changed: Earlier decades saw labels investing in 3-4 album deals, while modern practices often drop artists after one unsuccessful release, contributing to more one-hit wonders in recent decades.
4. Quality songwriting is exceptionally difficult: The hosts' research revealed how rare truly memorable, hook-laden songs are, emphasizing the craft and skill required for successful songwriting.
5. Collaborative music discovery enhances appreciation: The podcast format of shared research and discussion creates opportunities for deeper musical exploration and discovery that individual listening might miss.

Chapters

00:00 Introduction

05:06 Exploring One Hit Wonders

09:45 Decade Breakdown of Music

15:11 The Process of Selecting One Hit Wonders

19:50 Discussion of Selected Songs and Artists

32:51 Exploring 80s Music and One-Hit Wonders

39:50 The Evolution of Music Industry and One-Hit Wonders

47:45 Diving into Personal Music Choices

56:45 Planning Future Music Discussions and Listener Engagement

thesetlistoflife@gmail.com