Description

On November 19, 1863, President Abraham Lincoln stood before a desperate nation at Gettysburg and delivered what newspapers immediately called "silly, flat, dish-watery utterances." The Chicago Times wrote that "the cheek of every American must tingle with shame" at his performance. Even his hometown paper suggested the nation should drop "the veil of oblivion" over his embarrassing words. Critics wanted fireworks and got restraint. They wanted two hours of verbal gymnastics like the main speaker Edward Everett delivered. Instead, Lincoln spoke for barely three minutes.

But those 272 words became the Gettysburg Address—considered today one of the most profound speeches in American history. This episode explores why initial reactions are often wrong, how hot takes and extreme judgments blind us to substance, and why sometimes less really is more. At a time when rage and overreaction dominate our discourse, Lincoln's story reminds us to gravitate toward measured voices rather than loud ones, to value character over applause, and to never let critics define or break you.

Subscribe to Hometown History for forgotten American history stories that reveal unexpected truths about our past. New episodes release Tuesdays.

Show Notes: In This Episode:

• Why newspapers across America savaged Lincoln's Gettysburg Address as incompetent
• The two-hour speech everyone forgot that completely overshadowed Lincoln's remarks
• How the speech that lasted less than three minutes became one of history's greatest
• What Lincoln's experience teaches us about critics, hot takes, and the danger of overreacting
• The surprising truth about why the best things often get canceled or dismissed

Key Figures:

• Abraham Lincoln - President delivering cemetery dedication address
• Edward Everett - Harvard professor and "best orator in America," main speaker
• Chicago Times, Illinois State Register - Contemporary critics who panned the speech

Timeline:

• July 1-3, 1863: Battle of Gettysburg, one of Civil War's bloodiest battles
• November 19, 1863: Cemetery dedication ceremony at Gettysburg
• November 20-21, 1863: Scathing newspaper reviews published nationwide
• Following decades: Speech recognized as masterpiece of American rhetoric

Tags: Gettysburg Address, Abraham Lincoln, 1863, Pennsylvania history, Civil War history, American history, presidential speeches, true story, local history, forgotten history, Battle of Gettysburg, Edward Everett, 19th century America, historical criticism, famous speeches

Category: History

Chapter Markers: 0:00 - Introduction: When You Need a Great Speech 2:15 - The Stakes at Gettysburg 4:45 - Lincoln Takes the Stage and Bombs 7:30 - The Critics Destroy Him 9:15 - Lessons from a "Failed" Speech 11:00 - What They Actually Got: The Gettysburg Address 12:34 - Conclusion