Listen

Description

Video notes: Grading Texas’ dramatic win over Ohio State
TexasVOCFB | Hosts: Matthew Miller & Thomas “Tommy” Bresee
Sponsored by Fandle

Historic comeback win. Position-by-position grades after the game.



Intro

0:00–0:18
Welcome to grading the Texas Longhorns. Historic comeback. Straight to QB.



Quarterback — Arch Manning

Grades: Tommy B+ | Matthew C+
Range they land on: C+ to B+

0:18–3:42
Tommy (B+): Incredible down the stretch. Deserves all the respect. Take the drops away and you’re looking at ~270 yards, 2 TDs, 0 INTs. Could have been 350–370 with how many guys were wide open. Sark scheme got people open consistently. Missed Spencer Shannon (scrambled instead), Ryan Wingo over the middle, Emmett Mosley over the middle. Film room with Sark and A.J. Millwee won’t be kind on accuracy. Adjusted completion % around 68% after drops. Numbers are fine; leftover tape issues.

Matthew (C+): Tale of two halves. First half pretty bad. Down-to-down play still an issue. Explosive throws he will hit — Cam Coleman catch (Coleman should have just run under it instead of the weird almost-dive; it was a C throw). Wingo drop would have been another explosive. Trouble reading the middle of the field; outside is easy, checkdowns come quick. Has to rip the middle more.

Fourth quarter: A++. Best fourth quarter by a Texas QB since Vince Young. Better than any Colt McCoy fourth quarter they remember.

Big-play guy who can make all the throws, but the “boring QB stuff” isn’t all the way there yet. If supporting cast doesn’t drop balls, the conversation is glowing with only nitpicks.



Running backs

Grades: Matthew B- | Tommy B+

3:42–5:22
Matthew (B-): Really good three quarters. First quarter rough because of Relique Brown fumble. Can’t give the ball away in a game like that. Lucky to lose the turnover battle and still win. Without the fumble it’s A-. Hollywood Smothers and Relique Brown really good down the stretch. Relique’s physicality in the second half — running people over — was fun. Reminiscent of Super Bowl snap-over-the-head moment; demons exercised.

Tommy (B+): Two big mistakes — Relique running out of bounds on 3rd down (should have put his head down for the extra yard and avoided 4th down) and the fumble. Outside of that, lights out. Smothers consistent all day. Relique’s physical runs late. Duo they went out and got in the offseason made the difference.



Wide receivers

Grade: Both C+ (Matthew could have gone C-)

5:22–7:50
Lowest unit grade of the game. Did not help Arch enough.

All three of the “big three” had a massive mistake. They bounced back enough. Unit going forward is still elite if they clean up the small stuff. Ohio State took Coleman and Wingo away at times.



Tight ends

Grades: Matthew A | Tommy A-

7:50–10:09
Best unit on the team.

Matthew (A): Blocked really well. Emery Winston second-leading receiver + the biggest 4th-down conversion of the game (biggest play of the game). Needs to lose 10–15 lbs to become a real receiving threat, but he’s a good player and will play a lot. Spencer Shannon one drop (6-7 guy has to catch it when he’s going to get hit). Nick Townsend injury sucks — he would have taken some of Winston’s snaps. Georgia-level blocking. Receiving can improve but they don’t need it.

Tommy (A- only because of Townsend injury): Three guys who can block at an incredibly high level. If Winston is 40 yards a game that’s plenty. Will need TEs more as teams key Coleman/Wingo. Worst-case Saturday: elite blocking, not a ton of receiving — liveable with the weapons around them.



Offensive line

Grades: Matthew A- | Tommy A

10:09–12:02
Matthew (A-): Only negative is first-half interior push. After that, good. Pass pro amazing — two sacks (one on OL, one 100% on Arch getting flustered). Fine vs Ohio State. Will face better DLs (LSU, others) but they’ll have more reps.

Tommy (A, on a curve): Didn’t think they would push Ohio State off the ball at any point. They did in the fourth quarter. Drives of 15, 13, and 12 plays don’t happen without interior push. 3.4 YPC including sack yardage. Pass pro very good against a group that can create problems even if not elite. Two weeks in, as good as they could feel about this unit. Solid OL is all they asked for in the offseason to win a title.



Defensive line

Grades: Matthew B+ | Tommy B

12:02–14:42
Matthew (B+): Good, not great. Driven off the ball for a quarter and a half, then turned it around. Colin Simmons a lot of pressures + caused the hold that essentially ended the game. Several uncalled holds (Ian Jafar on Sayin, another on the broken play). Run-fit and tackling concerns at times.

Tommy (B): Group that can take over games. Simmons sack + 2 TFLs + ton of pressures. Hero Kanua and Maraud Watson lived in the backfield in the second half. Occasional run-game spurts because Muschamp plays light boxes. A+ performance is six sacks and taking over a game — maybe next week at Tennessee vs a young QB. Lance Jackson quiet except one sack; need a second-side guy besides Biles looping up. Expectations for a 5-star second-year guy were 6–8 sacks and flashes; hasn’t shown that yet. Ethan Burke-level is acceptable, but Jackson has a higher ceiling.



Linebackers

Grades: Matthew A | Tommy A-

14:42–17:00
Matthew (A): Justin Cryer and Raheem Biles really good. Cryer good on blitzes, getting to the QB, everything. Coverage vs RBs (hip flip) will be interesting later. Great portal find from FSU tape that didn’t scream star.

Tommy (A-): Cryer the best defensive player on the field. Communication late after all the halftime adjustments. Three or four plays in a row in Sayin’s face — throwaways and dirted balls. Creative with LBs in pass rush. Biles quieter but no insane mistakes. Brad Spence flash plays. Freshmen not ready for this moment; the three who played were high-level. Weakest group on paper in the offseason, best of the three levels vs Ohio State. Should get better as Atkinson and freshmen get comfortable (Atkinson on the field at LSU).



Secondary

Grades: Tommy B- | Matthew C+

17:00–22:00
Tommy (B-): Playing Jeremiah Smith is the hardest calculus course in college — every test is curved. One of the 10 best WRs who will ever play. Dominated by Smith. Arthur Smith moved him to the slot a lot (hard to double without taking a safety out of the middle). Other OSU WRs: 2 catches, 24 yards. That’s enough. Devin McEwen, Brandon Ennis, Chris Henry Jr. are high-level but not Cornell Tate / Mecca Bucca. Alignment issues + young guys (Warren Roberson, Cade Phillips) making mistakes. Bo Masco didn’t give up a catch. Feel pretty good given the caliber of WR they faced.

Matthew (C+): Early Muschamp feeling it out with different man coverages — didn’t work. Cade Phillips got beat the most. Bo Masco best of the group. Warren Roberson: physical tools, but he is who he is — penalties, biting on routes. Third-and-long double move by Smith before the sticks; Roberson bites, lucky he only made the tackle by kicking Smith’s legs (could have been a flag). “I’ve seen enough. Need freshmen/sophomores instead.” Jelani McDonald insanely quiet (second-leading tackler but not involved in coverage). Second half better; started putting a safety over the top of Smith. Next time: let Smith get his and shut everyone else down (McEwen is a 3rd/4th-round talent). Indiana will probably do exactly that with their man coverage.



Coaching

Overall staff: Tommy B+
Jeff Banks A | Kyle Flood B/B+ | Muschamp B-/C+ | Sark same range as Muschamp

22:00–28:09
Matthew: Banks’ position groups (TEs + ST) great. Flood solid. Muschamp first-half adjustments too slow, second half good. Sark: run Arch early. Get him hit, get him out of the pocket. He loves it and he’s great at it. 3–5 designed “just go do what you want” plays in the first half. Michigan game last year — once he said “fuck it” and stopped trying to be something he’s not, he was great. Vince Young documentary parallel: they incorporated what he liked instead of forcing him to be something else and won a title.

Tommy (B+ staff): Second-half adjustments boxed a really good Ohio State staff. Fourth-down call and early Smith plan were issues (everyone has the Smith problem). Biggest piece moving forward: balance between letting Arch be Arch and running the offense. Arch missed open guys that would have made Sark look better. Give him the middle ground early so he’s comfortable, then the offense can take over. Best version of the offense is the clean pocket version Sark wants — that’s not the QB they have right now. By Game 12 it might be. Third-string QB is probably the closest thing to the point-guard / Mac Jones type Sark’s offense wants. Arch missed spring; reps will help both the spectacular and mundane.



Outro / plugs

28:09–end
Like, subscribe, drop your grades. Back Tuesday 7 p.m. ET and Thursday 6:30 p.m. ET. National Live 365 show tonight 8 p.m. ET (they’ll let others recap this game and talk the insane weekend). Hook ’em.

























































Unit Matthew Tommy
QB C+ B+
RBs B- B+
WRs C+ C+
TEs A A-
OL A- A
DL B+ B
LBs A A-
Secondary C+ B-
Coaching mixed B+ overall

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.